Prevent new clan members who join AFTER War is Declared from seeing War Base traps.

I checked the Ruled Out sticky and did not see this listed there.

After war is declared and your enemy clan knows the Clan name of their opponent, couldn't someone use their 2nd clash account (from a different device) to join the enemy clan and discover the Trap Locations of the War Bases?

i.e. after getting matched with an enemy clan for a War they would use a different account to reconnoiter the trap locations.

They could then tell their clanmates which areas of each base are most vulnerable.
e.g. "Base #16 attack from the northeast. There are no traps there."

* If this is currently a possible tactic then SuperCell should not allow people who join the clan After Prep Day Begins (i.e. after War is declared) to see trap locations on War Bases (and possibly normal villages too if the bases are simply copied).

The new member can still see the war bases, just like their true clan, but they cannot see where the traps are located.

What do you guys think? Is this already implemented? I have only joined 1 clan so I don't know if this already exists.

Here is a simple solution, as u about to start war, close ur clan and keep it closed toll war ends, so nobody can join ur clan, hence no spies. So nobody can see ur traps.

OOORRR... a more simple solution thats already available to us is to close the clan down
It wouldnt really hurt your clan if you closed your clan for a couple of days right? Unless youre in a war clan then maybe open it for a few hours then close it again.

But I like it when you leave your clan open to anyone....


http://i.imgur.com/GJKJMru.jpg

Don't accept new members during war unless you invited them yourself. Period. Entire problem solved. Works great for my clan. Any requests on war days get instantly rejected unless they're from the forums (our recruiting thread) or we asked them to join, ie, a friend or family member.

Not getting a lotta feedback.

Perhaps this sneaky tactic is never used? So why bother?

We have 3 layout so make to skot about same map the different only in traps
open clan when war/prep day close when about to war
kicking new suspicious join too

change layout
the enemy gonna be really trapped

You're actually getting quite a bit of feedback.
Allow me to repeat what this feedback, from everyone was.
Close your clan, or make it invite only and accept only those you trust.

Just close the clan before war starts, a much simpler solution

I actually like this idea a lot. It's true that clans could just close during war, but what if a clan needs members and wars constantly? I would also suggest taking this idea a step further and removing spectators' ability to see war base reinforcements.

I LOVE IT!
I am often recruiting and it is important to have clan set to Invite Only as an option during war instead of Closing the clan.

With this as an option, the clan can remain set at Invite Only to allow approved new members to join during war.

Would love to see this implemented.

- dinner

Closing your clan is not an option if you war often. This game succeeds with the sense of community and growth. Closing the clan prevents that.

Changing the the base before war does very little during the war.

Prevent traps and clan castle troops from being seen and it solves all and keeps the community growing.

Then all all that is left is those that use the app after rooting a phone. They unfairly get to practice an unlimited time with no cost. Then when war starts the possibility of surprise is removed. Get rid of that and we have fair wars once more.

Yes, you're getting lots of feedback- its just not what you were hoping to hear.


Don't let in strangers during war, its that simple. There are 5 "Bro Clans" in our family, and this would cause problems for players who stop by to check on war / give advice and talk strategy.

I agree spectators should not be able to see your traps and teslas and the war members can!