Clan War Losers Get Fair Loot

When a clan loses a war, its members get only a fraction--20%, I think--of the loot bonuses they earned. However, this is not fair. It makes sense that the losing clan gets only part of its bonus; if this weren't the case winning would be practically meaningless. However, it is not fair that if a clan loses 99-100 stars, the members get the same tiny loot fraction as if they'd lost 20-150.

What I propose is this: the losing clan receive a loot bonus equal to L/W x B, where L is the losing clan's total stars. W is the winners' stars, and B is the earned bonus.

EXAMPLE:
Bob wins both war attacks and earns a loot bonus of 600k gold and elixir and 2000 dark elixir. However, the enemy clan gets 100 stars and Bob's clan only gets 50. Instead of the current system in which Bob only gets 20%, he would get 50/100 or half of his earned loot, i.e. 300k gold/elixir and 1000 dark elixir.

Alternately, the loot bonus could be 3/4 x L/W x B. In this case, Bob would get 3/4 of 50/100 of his loot bonus, or 225k gold/elixir and 750 dark elixir.

In the event of a draw, the current system (40% of earned bonuses for both clans) could be kept, or it could be increased to maybe 60%-80%.

This is interesting. I was just about to bash your idea and tell you to get better at clan wars or stop complaining. I still think those two things - do something about the people in your clan if you're losing by 50 stars in wars.

However, You put more thought into this idea than i initially thought you had. It's not terrible. Definitely needs a few changes. but I'm open to other versions of this idea.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Caguggenmos

This is interesting. I was just about to bash your idea and tell you to get better at clan wars or stop complaining. I still think those two things - do something about the people in your clan if you're losing by 50 stars in wars.

However, You put more thought into this idea than i initially thought you had. It's not terrible. Definitely needs a few changes. but I'm open to other versions of this idea.

---

I agree.
I like the idea, and would want to agree with op but can't quite yet.
Modify it a little and you'll be able to convince ppl!

Well, first of all, I should clarify that my clan isn't actually losing by that much. Lately, we've often been losing by only a few stars, but we still only get the small fraction of our bonuses. I only used 50-100 in my example because it's simpler math than 50-57 or 93-94.

And in response to your comments that it could be improved: Do you have any suggestions on how? I've considered the idea; I suppose it's not perfect, but it's complete, I proposed an alternative, and I haven't been able to think of any logistical issues.