Why we NEED an opt in/out feature ASAP

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rwelshjr

LOL, you are cherry picking like I was just saying. I actually thought I had made my point pretty well, but thanks for jumping in with the demonstration to make it even better than I did.

---

Answer the question: does Steve's statement leave you wondering about Supercell's stance on the issue?

You are making it sound like Steve made some ambiguous statment; he did not.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JohnnyBGood

Answer the question: does Steve's statement leave you wondering about Supercell's stance on the issue?

---

C'mon man. It was answered in my earlier post. Asking me again is not going to change my answer.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kruzkal

The intent of CW (from Steve again) is for the whole clan to participate, or whole clan to not participate. As a purist I agree with that. When your clan members are not on the same page regarding war frequency you already have a segregated clan. Understand that the segregation is in your clan mentality, and not the lack of a feature. They would rather you have an all in mentality then having rise of clan politics of some members in others not being able to be in etc. In short, this feature will cause more problems than it solves.

---

As a person who is on the forum to discuss things/argue, I don't accept things to stay as it is just because SC said something because they have changed their minds before and are open to discussion/change (hence the idea subforum and Steve saying that he's open to feedback). A SC staff have said before that elixir should be for offense (I think) and should be plentiful to allow people to keep attacking (no citation either since search function doesn't work well). That intent of elixir was changed with the addition of elixir walls and was changed it again with the last update.

Steve aside, I don't disagree that the segregation comes from the clan mentality but I'm saying that it is fine to stay that way and that the all in mentality is wrong

Edit: This thread is too active and interfering with raiding. I'll run away now

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rwelshjr

We are going in circles. that new home is not with their family and friends so th. You are not able to see the other point of view. To you it is about nothing but wars, that's fine, but to them there are other factors and no, they are not in discord with their clans, the war guys in there want them to stay too so they can be there cheering them on while they war. All these folks enjoy each others company. So both factions are in harmony and want the feature to make it easier to act on that.

NO, those that are there just to be with family and friends, if that is taken away, don't go join clans with strangers instead. If their real reason for being in the game taken away from them they just leave.

No I am not saying it is droves, at least not yet. The huge amount of outcry for this feature indicates that most are hanging in there and hoping SC does the right thing by them.

---

Well some of my best friends are in different clans. My mother in law is in a different clan because we have different war approaches. Is your interaction with these loved ones limited to the realms of Clash? Your paragraph is hilarious.

Is this some playground fluff? Oh no mum what if the new kids bully me? HAHAHAHAHAHA!!! Don't these clans have half their players split between war and no war anyway? You just end up with 2 smaller clans but still with the same people for the larger part.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kruzkal

Well some of my best friends are in different clans. My mother in law is in a different clan because we have different war approaches. Is your interaction with these loved ones limited to the realms of Clash? Your paragraph is hilarious.

Is this some playground fluff? Oh know mum what if the new kids bully me? HAHAHAHAHAHA!!!

---

Glad that works out for them. Everybody should do what works out for themselves.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rwelshjr

Glad that works out for them. Everybody should do what works out for themselves.

---

Funny you should say that, as an advocate of not doing what works out for themselves and rather have the system change to accommodate them.

This would be a great way to run up your war wins.... Drop all the top players, just war with the bottom 10 or 15, top players donate to the CC's I'd bet three or four LVL 7 Giants or a maxed dragon would be great against a TH 5 or 6. Count me in.

If my mil played clash! I would seriously love if she were in a different clan! Side note....I would love to constantly raid her village and smash it to bits. Actually I would love to have her in my clan just so I could kick her and totally forget to reinvite her! Then if we could go to war I could smash her some more.

Yup totally understand why your mil isn't in your clan! Hahahahaha.

No some family just needs to go pkay elsewhere, but for those that want to play together they surely should.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by THNSUM

This would be a great way to run up your war wins.... Drop all the top players, just war with the bottom 10 or 15, top players donate to the CC's I'd bet three or four LVL 7 Giants or a maxed dragon would be great against a TH 5 or 6. Count me in.

---

Those who advocate the need for opt-ins will pay no heed to obvious exploitations such systems will inevitably introduce.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mobad

If my mil played clash! I would seriously love if she were in a different clan! Side note....I would love to constantly raid her village and smash it to bits. Actually I would love to have her in my clan just so I could kick her and totally forget to reinvite her! Then if we could go to war I could smash her some more.

Yup totally understand why your mil isn't in your clan! Hahahahaha.

No some family just needs to go pkay elsewhere, but for those that want to play together they surely should.

---

Nah, you must be making assumptions based on your own experiences... Do you suffer from memory loss? You the entire list of players botted are still in chat log. Surely you done it on purpose? You naughty boy!

By play together you mean sit in the same chat room and NOT play together? There are better chat apps you know?