Deserter Tag/Surrender loot

I am tired of players who quit the clan in the middle of war. Thus I think they should earn a deserter mark everytime they quit a clan in war. (Not kicked). Not only gaining a deserter mark but losing all resources and negative 250,000 each 2,500 dark. In the time frame this game represents you would be killed as a traitor, there should be a fine and warning to future clans. I personally would split traitors loot between remaining members

Definitely a great idea. Having to lose by one or two stars in a war that could have been redeemed by a clanmates that left is the worst part of this game in my opinion

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Storm8756

I am tired of players who quit the clan in the middle of war. Thus I think they should earn a deserter mark everytime they quit a clan in war. (Not kicked). Not only gaining a deserter mark but losing all resources and negative 250,000 each 2,500 dark. In the time frame this game represents you would be killed as a traitor, there should be a fine and warning to future clans. I personally would split traitors loot between remaining members

---

Thumbs up definitely

Luckily my clan hasn't encountered this. However it I'd a good idea.

SC doesn't allow negative marks for some reason, like the hopper mark I suggested.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GregandEjay1

SC doesn't allow negative marks for some reason, like the hopper mark I suggested.

---

Then if not negative down to zero, with a warning "Leaving clan during war will have consequences" then lose your loot and earn a mark. It's quite a bit different to hop clans than to have up to 49 people relying on you than ditch out on them and wreck their play with zero affect on you.

Did I say no.
There are 24/7 war clans which gives you a higher risk of joining before right war search starts, and if this happens and the player doesn't like the clan and leaves it gives them a mark.
The clan could be toxic.
The leader could be a idiot and so on.
I vote no.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zannan

Did I say no.
There are 24/7 war clans which gives you a higher risk of joining before right war search starts, and if this happens and the player doesn't like the clan and leaves it gives them a mark.
The clan could be toxic.
The leader could be a idiot and so on.
I vote no.

---

Good point, I think there should be a hold on players war activity until the new symbol goes away anyways.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Storm8756

I am tired of players who quit the clan in the middle of war. Thus I think they should earn a deserter mark everytime they quit a clan in war. (Not kicked). Not only gaining a deserter mark but losing all resources and negative 250,000 each 2,500 dark. In the time frame this game represents you would be killed as a traitor, there should be a fine and warning to future clans. I personally would split traitors loot between remaining members

---

Totally get where you are coming from. We all hate traitors. But Supercell has a policy against negative tags or statistics so this is ruled out via that policy.

I have previously suggested burying traitors in anthills but that got no traction, I don't know why because its not against the policy. I don't say brand them or keep any stats on them. Just bury them there and leave them. In the hot sun.

Supercell won't even post how many raids you've lost, you think they'll break their "no negative statistics" just for you?

SUPERCELL WILL NOT POST NEGATIVE STATSTICS ON ANY PLAYER. hopper or not, they won't do it.

You can see as much as you can with the eligibilty timer. Thats the best you get.