Display 'Troops Donated to Received' Ratio/%/Grade/Rating when you Request Troops

When I first started playing Clash I would donate to anybody without even glancing at the name.

But after checking my Clan info, I see a few notorious clan members never donate, but they request constantly.

So I don't donate to them anymore. Only to other players who donate.

It'd be nice if there's a very small symbol or mark shown when a player Requests Reinforcements that quickly tells you whether or not that player is giving in addition to taking.

Perhaps it could be as simple as a Letter Grade like in American schools.

'A' means you basically give almost as much as you receive.
'F' means you're a leach and you never donate but still request frequently.

etc.

What do you guys think?

i like this idea
Maybe the Grade can be from different color and attached to a player lifetime
I must kick of player out of clan, every 2 week, but can join again and persevere in their bad habits

Ah thanks for pointing that out.

Yeah I'm not talking about a 'lifetime' grade.

Just for each "Season".

I mean, maybe a player has been on vacation or simply too busy to donate.
Who knows. Doesn't mean they should have a negative grade or rating for life.

Once a new season begins, everybody is set to zero or neutral or whatever.
But as they start requesting reinforcements, if they don't also donate a bit, they're gonna start to go into the red, or F grade, or what have you.

The person in your clan who might donate to you will be able to use their own judgment whether or not to donate to people who never give back. Most people might not care.

But some like myself do care, and it's a hassle to check the Clan data to see who has been donating this season.

A very good idea . In my clan there are many players who are like that i would kick the out if there was an system like that. the letters could be exchanged with symbols.:thumbsup::thumbsup:

Interesting idea. It need not be a letter or symbol, can even be different shades of colour of player's IGN (bright colours representing the most giving person and dark grey for those that keep taking without giving). However, do note that it is almost impossible to achieve a perfect balance. There will be people giving more than they take, and people taking more than they give. This may or may not cause certain stigmas.

Yes. Want this. More for the selfish requesters to see.

I like this idea but instead of grades which can be confusing internationally how about a simple number with their give/take ratio. Someone who donates 10 and takes 100 will show a red down arrow with 0.1. The opposite would see a green up arrow with 10.0

pointless feature.
donating isnt about who donates most or least, it's about helping your clan mates out.

If you are unsattisfied with a leecher, then talk to your leaders or find a new clan.

What about people that donates even 100 times more than they request? Should they get just an A?
I'm a clan leader and I'm helping a lot off people, I make over 900 donations per day.If ur idea came out I should get a mega super shiny A whit a bunch of stars and fireworks...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Hercuiver

pointless feature.
donating isnt about who donates most or least, it's about helping your clan mates out.

If you are unsatisfied with a leecher, then talk to your leaders or find a new clan.

---

I do manage the young newcomers who don't get the donations etiquettes. The problem to fix is that donation ratio is easy to see if you look, but new players don't know to look there. A little bit of data, donation ratio I suggest, attached to requests, would be easy to implement, and I think a gentler message that having a leader address them directly.

If we were to get clever, the number could be color coded. Red for <10%, orange 10%-50%, green 50%+.

Donation ratios greater than 1 shouldn't be encouraged. Senior members are above that, and junior members should donate some, but not too much.