Suggestion: Add another star

I think we should have 4 stars instead of 3, 1 at 50%, 1 at 75% and 1 at 100% (and 1 for town hall of course) I think this would make wars a lot more fun, specially because 3 stars are very rare on high level wars, excuse me for my bad english, so what you guys think of this idea?

Wrong sub forum! This should be in Future requests and Ideas....

I dont see anything like this happening considering how basic and long standing the 3 star system has been.

Although i do feel like a 5 star system or something really could make clan wars work better.

Yeah I think it's kind of ridiculous that you can get 99% and only one star.

5 star system would be great for differentiating attacks better. A 50% and 99% shouldn't be considered the same, there's a huge outdated gap there. 50% for 1, 75% for 2, 90% for 3, 100% for 4 would work- TH providing the 5th. Then people wouldn't just quit after 50%.

This idea wouldn't supprt BARCHing for barley 50%- and with all the updates lately BARCH has been stabbed in the heart by all the nerfs and added features.

Think about it (20 cups acaliable on all bases listed):
Current System
1 star = 6 cups
2 stars=12-14 cups
3 stars=20 cups

Your Idea
1 star=5 cups
2 stars= 10 cups
3 stars= 15 cups
4 stars= 20 cups

The small minor difference in trophies earned per star adds up for trophy pushers.

1/3 is greater than 1/4 (if that makes sense to you)

or

33% > 25%

EDIT: AndI rarely end up getting 99% with only one star. You have to have talent to end up with 99% without the TH ;)

For wars however this may work, however it makes it easier to get a higher amout of stars. (Although this would balance out as it gives both sides this benefit)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Izaiah

This idea wouldn't supprt BARCHing for barley 50%- and with all the updates lately BARCH has been stabbed in the heart by all the nerfs and added features.

Think about it (20 cups acaliable on all bases listed):
Current System
1 star = 6 cups
2 stars=12-14 cups
3 stars=20 cups

Your Idea
1 star=5 cups
2 stars= 10 cups
3 stars= 15 cups
4 stars= 20 cups

The small minor difference in trophies earned per star adds up for trophy pushers.

1/3 is greater than 1/4 (if that makes sense to you)

or

33% > 25%

EDIT: AndI rarely end up getting 99% with only one star. You have to have talent to end up with 99% without the TH ;)

---

I agree completely......Its not the idea is BAD, it just wouldn't help a lot.


I was once pretty talented then. :rolleyes:

Great idea... not sure that three stars are 'rare'... still like the idea

I like this idea. 4-5 stars would be more appropriate than 3 -- especially in war.

I had suggested that idea in September. Pls feel free to comment on that thread :)

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...ar-game-system