World top 3 PALYER new feature SUGGESTION

Printable View

May 9th, 2013
Garyjin

1 Attachment(s)

World top 3 PALYER new feature SUGGESTION

Hi all,
As a top 3 player in world and I would say the "cheap shield" do ruin the game for non-farm players. No defense and all do like Yao style. We all like the game as it is fun to raid others and defense but now in TOP theres no defense at all. Stay online or just shield others. I know there would not influence the profit from Supercell thus supercell ignore it but this make me thinking that whether this game still a game? Or just make the trophy at top with whatever method and show off in Twitter or someplace. In the thread I post in General forum, most player has explain their opinion about the cheap shield and state that it is likely a C,H,EATING. http://forum.supercell.net/showthread.php/47000-Golem-attack-in-VERY-HIGH-lv-top-3-GARYTAO-defenseAttachment 7579

Here I attach Yao's defense in my league and it is not possible at all that he defense all win. Is this mean all top player should do same like him? We all like strategy game so we choose COC but not like this kind of strategy. If in this case, why do we upgrade the Defense??? The wall???

Here I state my suggestion to solve this problem: set the rule not allow same classmate in 2 week (Each T round)to attack each other. That would make Yao decide to choose the shield or help to support his clan's T. In most case we would choose last and then he would not likely ask his clanmates help him and then process "true" defense. This would motivate others to reach top through their real effort. Don't like the current way. Thanks.

Garytao
May 9th, 2013
Tuvya

Try to be as good as him instead of whining
May 9th, 2013
Tuvya

btw you are rank 4 not in top 3
May 9th, 2013
Garyjin

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tuvya

btw you are rank 4 not in top 3

Did u see I defense lose n drop 1?
May 9th, 2013
Garyjin

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...ARYTAO-defense
In general thread, lots of players have same opionion
May 9th, 2013
Baconman

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tuvya

Try to be as good as him instead of whining

He's not good. He has clanmates give him a cheap shield whenever he logs off, eccentially removing him from the matchmaking que. As long as he wins all his attacks, he can't lose trophies. This, in my opinion, is ♥♥♥♥♥ing.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tuvya

btw you are rank 4 not in top 3

Does it make a difference? Number 4 out of 8 million is still pretty impressive.
May 9th, 2013
AngrehBard

I agree with you Gary. Even though I might be Bonbee, you are my favourite top player :). (Don't tell VIZIA!)

I guess that idea you proposed could possibly work. Here is my take on how we could stop it:

In 3000+ trophies, once x leaves a clan, the clanmates in the clan cannot see x on their attack search for 2 weeks, nor can x see the people in the clan for 2 weeks.

The only flaw with my idea is that x could join multiple clans in the top bracket and not be attacked at all.
May 9th, 2013
Tuvya

ok gary i respect you and your gaming skills. giving %40 damage and recieving free 12 hr shiled may not be fair but why dont you do it too?
May 9th, 2013
Baconman

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tuvya

ok gary i respect you and your gaming skills. giving %40 damage and recieving free 12 hr shiled may not be fair but why dont you do it too?

Because as you said, it's unfair.

2 posts til 3k!!
May 9th, 2013
vkstarry

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tuvya

btw you are rank 4 not in top 3

He is top 3 in league. :)
May 9th, 2013
AngrehBard

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tuvya

ok gary i respect you and your gaming skills. giving %40 damage and recieving free 12 hr shiled may not be fair but why dont you do it too?

So your logic stands by if you punch me in the face I punch you back? And then we keep rinsing and repeating?
May 9th, 2013
cucubing

They should simply take away sheild if you didn't lose trophy.
Sheild only comes when you lose defense.
May 9th, 2013
babu

Quote:

Originally Posted by AngrehBard

So your logic stands by if you punch me in the face I punch you back? And then we keep rinsing and repeating?

No, It's Punch Me, I'll Punch You, Kick Me, I'll Kick You, H@ck me, I'll H@ck you!. Or tell on someone. Kill Me, I'll Have an assasian ready for yoU!
May 9th, 2013
AngrehBard

Quote:

Originally Posted by babu

No, It's Punch Me, I'll Punch You, Kick Me, I'll Kick You, H@ck me, I'll H@ck you!. Or tell on someone. Kill Me, I'll Have an assasian ready for yoU!

Hahaha thanks for making me laugh :)
May 9th, 2013
Stitch

You're right, something clearly isn't right at the top of the charts.

The thing is, it would take SuperCell less than 5 minutes of investigating to see what these players are doing and what they're up too. They will easily know if anything is shady and I would expect it to be addressed in the next update.

SuperCell owe Jorge nothing, he's not a paid spokes person. Yes he's put a lot of money into the game, but so have a lot of the top players. So they shouldn't fear implementing something that exposes him.

It would actually be better for SuperCell if the top players could battle more and if the top of the charts changed players more frequently.
May 9th, 2013
Eldin

Don't you get free Gems at the top?
I might be wrong, but it would explain it all.

Kind Regards,
Eldin.
May 9th, 2013
Tuvya

Quote:

Originally Posted by Eldin

Don't you get free Gems at the top?
I might be wrong, but it would explain it all.

Kind Regards,
Eldin.

lol.. they really think those gems fill top players pockets.
May 9th, 2013
AngrehBard

Quote:

Originally Posted by Eldin

Don't you get free Gems at the top?
I might be wrong, but it would explain it all.

Kind Regards,
Eldin.

Explain what?
May 9th, 2013
bbehaghel

Quote:

Originally Posted by Eldin

Don't you get free Gems at the top?
I might be wrong, but it would explain it all.

Kind Regards,
Eldin.

As Jorge Yao said in his interview with flammy, the gems they win do NOT help them in any way... The gems theu revieve cant even fill their storages by half... Whereas for lower non gemmers, 600-1000 gems would be a great deal of help... And only the top 10 of the top3 clans win free gems
May 9th, 2013
Ramin

I think 12 hr shield needs a cool-down time , it brings challenge to top players and restrict normal players from putting their town hall out side the walls :)
May 10th, 2013
Tuvya

free gems are like a pocket change to stay in top