Cannot attack because the village owner is online or because the village has a sheld

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by isdjfnsdjfnskdjfnskdjnf

Arguably the most annoying thing about this game. I very rarely am able to revenge attack because of either of these messages

So here is how you fix it... if you want to...

"Village owner is online"

1. Allow revenge to take place at anytime if the owner is online by pausing their gameplay with a message - "sorry you're being revenged by someone you pineappled previously"

2. To prevent constant revenge attacks whilst you are online a (maybe 10) minute background shield which prevents two revengers attacking you in that short amount of time. Also a message could be displayed if that says "You will be revenge attacked in 1 minute".

3. If you want to revenge attack and your enemy are within that window then you get a message that says - "Owner is online and will be available to attack in xx minutes

4. If they are in a battle then the revenger gets a message - "Your revenge attack will load in (counting down) seconds as your opponent is currently attacking someone else" with a cancel option. As soon as the revengees battle finishes the gameplay pauses and they get the message as seen in (1)


"Village has an active shield"

1. They retain their active shield however are allowed to be revenge attacked.


The real drawcard to this game was the ability to revenge the clowns that attack you but it's almost at the point where you need to either remove the revenge feature or make it usable as shown above. I wait in anticipation

---

I think you put as much thought into your idea as you did your account name.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zannan

Nope, for people who raid a lot in a hour, they'd be destroyed every second not allowing them to play the game and I'd be peed if I'm online and getting ready to upgrade and someone attacked me before I upgraded and took that loot and it happened while I was online.
I wouldn't be able to do anything, this could make the game unplayable.

And if I have a shield and am riding it, I'd expect it to work. There's no point of a shield if it doesn't prevent attacks.

And this is bad for the economy, because this would make someone attacked constantly, and make the loot go down.

---

There's no point of revenge if shield prevents revenge attacks...people just conserve elixir or gold or dark elixir without fear of being revenge.

To anyone who mentioned shields becoming worthless...I can see your point even though I hate how worthless the revenge feature is because of the amount of time all players spend on shield. The OP's idea could be tweaked by adding a stacking "revenge shield" for each time a player gets revenged. Basically the game would have to keep track of the typical opponent search shield and the revenge shield which would get bigger each time a player gets revenged. It wouldn't solve the shield/revenge problem totally but it would help a bit I think. This isn't really the problem, though.

THE REAL PROBLEM...the village owner being online should not stop them from being revenged. If you don't have a shield, you shouldn't be hidden from being revenged...or even searched for a typical village attack for that matter! All those horrible players that sit on their account without shield to try to hold their loot hostage until a builder becomes available are garbage. I see the 'player has active shield' just about the same amount as the 'player is online' when trying to revenge and I would be willing to bet that half or more of those that show as online are just sitting on their account swirling their finger around on the screen every few seconds while waiting for a builder and that is TOTAL ♥♥♥♥! This ♥♥ way to keep from getting attacked has got to go. I tried to attack some silly little rushed TH9 that came after me once and fell on his butt. However, I spent the entire lunch hour tapping revenge and saw the same 'player is online' message the entire hour. There is nothing on clash that takes an hour to do without pause. The new cool down boot off thing is a good start but it isn't enough. Your loot should be open to being stolen the second guard is up...period. Just another hokey workaround that needs to be gotten rid of...just like exposed bases (got tweaked), zapping (which so many people defended as legit and the game got rid of because it wasn't even close to legit), engineered base owners (which still hasn't been fixed but it obvious ♥♥♥♥ and is the reason people who aren't in war can't donate to people who are because the game can't control that lopsidedness...so you have to know this is ♥♥♥♥ too), and AQ/Healer walk (which everyone so vehemently defends as legit but the game is making steps to get rid of it because healers are "too safe" and all of you know it). These hokey little h.acks are not how the game was intended to work and they have or will all die a deserved death in time. It is time being online no longer protects you from getting attacked...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by isdjfnsdjfnskdjfnskdjnf

Arguably the most annoying thing about this game. I very rarely am able to revenge attack because of either of these messages

So here is how you fix it... if you want to...

"Village owner is online"

1. Allow revenge to take place at anytime if the owner is online by pausing their gameplay with a message - "sorry you're being revenged by someone you pineappled previously"

2. To prevent constant revenge attacks whilst you are online a (maybe 10) minute background shield which prevents two revengers attacking you in that short amount of time. Also a message could be displayed if that says "You will be revenge attacked in 1 minute".

3. If you want to revenge attack and your enemy are within that window then you get a message that says - "Owner is online and will be available to attack in xx minutes

4. If they are in a battle then the revenger gets a message - "Your revenge attack will load in (counting down) seconds as your opponent is currently attacking someone else" with a cancel option. As soon as the revengees battle finishes the gameplay pauses and they get the message as seen in (1)


"Village has an active shield"

1. They retain their active shield however are allowed to be revenge attacked.


The real drawcard to this game was the ability to revenge the clowns that attack you but it's almost at the point where you need to either remove the revenge feature or make it usable as shown above. I wait in anticipation

---

Probably not going too happen. Plus, it's going too make more ppl complain

This is a thread of annoyance. Who PINEAPPLE your Base? ♥♥♥♥.... tell me and I will pineapple his Base too with a war grade attack.

meh, i get attacked and creamed a lot. i also consider myself a superfarmer. i get attacked and raided for 400k elixir nearly everday sometimes even twice a day. it doesn't really bother me if I can't hit "joe" back. if i can, great, if not, I just continue on my path of equal opportunity destruction. any given day visit my village the tanks are more often than not over half full. stopping game play for a revenge attack is just a bad idea. if you can't hit me today try again tomorrow otherwise I'm sure there's a thousand other villages you can sift through perhaps even richer than mine lol.

Sorry this is a horrible idea and would make progress in the game very difficult with constant attacks and a reduced ability to build up enough resources.

it just baffles me why people are so hung up with the idea of revenge. hitting someone like this on coc is just the ultimate troll lol.

By adding a "window time" which players can revenge those who hoard elixir for upgrades would never hide from humiliating revenge so players can gurantee revenge.

terrible idea if u keep a shield coz no one would revenge so all attackers would hide their resources.

then if its time for revenge then the loot was lower than the player loot previously.

and it is bad for the game's economy since they hoard their loot for upgrades and others.

no one would revenge so revenge attack would be pointless if there is no revenge shield (allows revenge and prevents regular attacks) or window time.

---

Hi! Banban here!
Tanki online username:Janus143|Rank:Warrant officer I|Coc name:Jan2016FTW|Level:71|
My clan:United boholano|Clan tag:#LP988Y29|Clan level:7 almost lv8
pm me if u have questions bout me and my proposed revenge shield idea/revenge fix proposal!
Wow! Im a trainee now!