Punishment for the Clan Hopping Troop Leachers

For a while now my clan has been in open recruitment. During this about 90% of our new recruits join take a dragon or pekka and go on their way. To combat this we have started only donating T1 troops to new joins, until they show some interest in the clan. However, this issue is still occurring very frequently. Which brings me to my idea.

NEW FEATURE: Exile

Exile- will allow the clan to permanently ban anyone who joins the clan for one troop request and then leaves.

ADDITIONALLY- One member of the clan, that was taken advantage of, would be allowed to raid the clan hopper, ONE TIME. This raid would be executed under the normal rules of a revenge attack. Village must not have a shield. The attack will grant a shield.

Result: This feature will cause clan hopping for free troops to be stopped quicker, and create a punishment making it detrimental to the hopper to continue this selfish action.

First time on the forum, sorry if my formatting on this post isn't that great.


TL/DR: Allow clans to permanently ban hoppers and get one vengeance attack against them.

Its not possible to ban hoopers as many players have the same name and also, its part of the game, wat u could change is accept it. Will help u keep calm. They r going to be here and will come occasionally 😊

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mann23

Its not possible to ban hoopers as many players have the same name and also, its part of the game, wat u could change is accept it. Will help u keep calm. They r going to be here and will come occasionally 😊

---

If you clicked their name in the clan chat after they left and clicked an Exile button, it could ban their specific instance of the name, as all accounts have a unique identification code.

Invite only would solve all of this.

Also, what's the big deal? You lose what a few thousand elixir to a hopper? How often does it happen to you. Seems like a coding overkill.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 3lorian

Invite only would solve all of this.

Also, what's the big deal? You lose what a few thousand elixir to a hopper? How often does it happen to you. Seems like a coding overkill.

---

I literally just had this happen four times while invite only was on, which inspired this post. We have very high level troops so maybe we get targeted more. It's not that much of a burden currency wise, but it makes clan chat look sloopy, and the principal of it all.

Maybe its not inconvenient enough to warrant a solution, but it is fairly frustrating when it happens time and time again.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by veritas434

ADDITIONALLY- One member of the clan, that was taken advantage of, would be allowed to raid the clan hopper, ONE TIME. This raid would be executed under the normal rules of a revenge attack. Village must not have a shield. The attack will grant a shield.

---

Result: People deliberately simulate clan hopping in order to transfer trophies and resources between accounts.

Fixed that for you.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dahimi

Result: People deliberately simulate clan hopping in order to transfer trophies and resources between accounts.

Fixed that for you.

---

I can see how that could be abused, ill have to think on that for a while, not sure if its preventable.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by veritas434

For a while now my clan has been in open recruitment. During this about 90% of our new recruits join take a dragon or pekka and go on their way. To combat this we have started only donating T1 troops to new joins, until they show some interest in the clan. However, this issue is still occurring very frequently. Which brings me to my idea.

NEW FEATURE: Exile

Exile- will allow the clan to permanently ban anyone who joins the clan for one troop request and then leaves.

ADDITIONALLY- One member of the clan, that was taken advantage of, would be allowed to raid the clan hopper, ONE TIME. This raid would be executed under the normal rules of a revenge attack. Village must not have a shield. The attack will grant a shield.

Result: This feature will cause clan hopping for free troops to be stopped quicker, and create a punishment making it detrimental to the hopper to continue this selfish action.

First time on the forum, sorry if my formatting on this post isn't that great.


TL/DR: Allow clans to permanently ban hoppers and get one vengeance attack against them.

---

To solve your issue do what I make new recruits do - donate 25 b4 they req & no specific request if they not elder unless its for a war attack.

Ok I can totally see the sloppiness of it. The only way I could see a fix working though would be to put a cool down timer after leaving a clan (which could actually solve some champion problems as well). Perhaps like 48 hours? This would totally ruin req and ♥♥♥♥ clans though.

The ID ban wouldn't reallynwork because a hopper isn't going to come back to your clan and you probably couldnt get away with banning a hopper from all clans :/

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by veritas434

For a while now my clan has been in open recruitment. During this about 90% of our new recruits join take a dragon or pekka and go on their way. To combat this we have started only donating T1 troops to new joins, until they show some interest in the clan. However, this issue is still occurring very frequently. Which brings me to my idea.

NEW FEATURE: Exile

Exile- will allow the clan to permanently ban anyone who joins the clan for one troop request and then leaves.

ADDITIONALLY- One member of the clan, that was taken advantage of, would be allowed to raid the clan hopper, ONE TIME. This raid would be executed under the normal rules of a revenge attack. Village must not have a shield. The attack will grant a shield.

Result: This feature will cause clan hopping for free troops to be stopped quicker, and create a punishment making it detrimental to the hopper to continue this selfish action.

First time on the forum, sorry if my formatting on this post isn't that great.


TL/DR: Allow clans to permanently ban hoppers and get one vengeance attack against them.

---

Req and leave clans...