New Features

Idea 1: Enable players to use more than 1 builder to complete a building or upgrade. For example, a player with two builders could complete a building at half the time if he selects two builders to complete the task. It would still take the same amount of time. i.e. 1 builder = 12hrs for 1 building / 2 builders = 6 hrs for 1 building but yet 12 hrs for 2 buildings as the game allows as many upgrades as the number of builders. This is due to the need of completing certain upgrades faster for example before a war starts.


Idea 2: Allow targeting by players at least for the human like units. As the player is the Chief of the village, and the commander of the troops in war, since it is a strategy game, it would be less frustrating when the player has some control over the troops. It is very frustrating when a unit is breaking a hut instead of a bigger building which could earn him a better percentage while the unit is being bombarded and just acts like a robot.


Idea 3: Create an upgrade for the balloon bombers to have anti-rockets defense, like jet fighters.


Idea 4: Create a way that the villagers would be transporting the resources to storages when it reaches a certain level, like 5,000 or 10,000. It is a better idea to allow players to save more resources, as players can't defend their villages under attack and you can't even access the villages while it is being attacked.


Idea 5: Allow exchange of resources between Clan members. Some times, the Clan would like to help a weaker player upgrade his defenses before a battle. This would help weaker players instead of the Clan loosing a battle due to a weak member. Usually, the leaders and co-leaders coordinate the wars, so this would allow them give some resources and instruct the weaker players on what to upgrade, since every percent counts.

Ideas 1 and 5 are ruled out. Read the sticky.

Idea 2 would severely offset the game's balance which is already in favor of the attacker. Learn how to deploy your troops properly.

Idea 3 is simply silly. Using your plane analogy, balloons are like bombers. Minions are more like fighters. Don't send in your bombers without additional air support.

Idea 4 is bad. Really bad. Think about this one for a bit.

Kindly elaborate on the sticky.

Idea 2: The game is already not balanced an is in favor of the attacker as the defender can not defend with troops. So, why make it frustrating. The attacked player could always revenge. Idea 2 would severely offset the game's balance which is already in favor of the attacker. Learn how to deploy your troops properly.

Idea 3: this Idea is meant for further upgrade.

Last but not least, these are ideas, some players may support it, some may not. Idea 4 is simply for working people who don't have the time to keep going online to collect the resources from the mines. I only get online a couple of hours a night whenever I have time.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gigamer

Idea 1: Enable players to use more than 1 builder to complete a building or upgrade. For example, a player with two builders could complete a building at half the time if he selects two builders to complete the task. It would still take the same amount of time. i.e. 1 builder = 12hrs for 1 building / 2 builders = 6 hrs for 1 building but yet 12 hrs for 2 buildings as the game allows as many upgrades as the number of builders. This is due to the need of completing certain upgrades faster for example before a war starts.


Idea 2: Allow targeting by players at least for the human like units. As the player is the Chief of the village, and the commander of the troops in war, since it is a strategy game, it would be less frustrating when the player has some control over the troops. It is very frustrating when a unit is breaking a hut instead of a bigger building which could earn him a better percentage while the unit is being bombarded and just acts like a robot.


Idea 3: Create an upgrade for the balloon bombers to have anti-rockets defense, like jet fighters.


Idea 4: Create a way that the villagers would be transporting the resources to storages when it reaches a certain level, like 5,000 or 10,000. It is a better idea to allow players to save more resources, as players can't defend their villages under attack and you can't even access the villages while it is being attacked.


Idea 5: Allow exchange of resources between Clan members. Some times, the Clan would like to help a weaker player upgrade his defenses before a battle. This would help weaker players instead of the Clan loosing a battle due to a weak member. Usually, the leaders and co-leaders coordinate the wars, so this would allow them give some resources and instruct the weaker players on what to upgrade, since every percent counts.

---

1 - ruled out
2 - boom beach
3 - why??????? balloons are fine as they are
4 - I like finding inactive bases :( (ad I think this may be ruled out)
5 - ruled out

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gigamer

Idea 1: Enable players to use more than 1 builder to complete a building or upgrade. For example, a player with two builders could complete a building at half the time if he selects two builders to complete the task. It would still take the same amount of time. i.e. 1 builder = 12hrs for 1 building / 2 builders = 6 hrs for 1 building but yet 12 hrs for 2 buildings as the game allows as many upgrades as the number of builders. This is due to the need of completing certain upgrades faster for example before a war starts.


---Ruled out unfortunately. I think it is good because not being active enough to keep them all busy at oce shouldnt benefit you to use it all at one building.


Idea 2: Allow targeting by players at least for the human like units. As the player is the Chief of the village, and the commander of the troops in war, since it is a strategy game, it would be less frustrating when the player has some control over the troops. It is very frustrating when a unit is breaking a hut instead of a bigger building which could earn him a better percentage while the unit is being bombarded and just acts like a robot.

---No, this will destroy strategy as troop deployment is part of the strategy.

Idea 3: Create an upgrade for the balloon bombers to have anti-rockets defense, like jet fighters.

---Too OP. Balloons are the most common flying troops and it would make them too OP

Idea 4: Create a way that the villagers would be transporting the resources to storages when it reaches a certain level, like 5,000 or 10,000. It is a better idea to allow players to save more resources, as players can't defend their villages under attack and you can't even access the villages while it is being attacked.


---This will several, terribly, harshly, terribly destroy the loot as there won't be any colelctor raids that many farmers rely on. It is your fault for not being active enough to collect them often.

Idea 5: Allow exchange of resources between Clan members. Some times, the Clan would like to help a weaker player upgrade his defenses before a battle. This would help weaker players instead of the Clan loosing a battle due to a weak member. Usually, the leaders and co-leaders coordinate the wars, so this would allow them give some resources and instruct the weaker players on what to upgrade, since every percent counts.


---Ruled out.

---

. Answers are in the quote after "---". Read the stickies please.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gigamer

Kindly elaborate on the sticky.

---

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...rum-guidelines

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gigamer

Idea 2: The game is already not balanced an is in favor of the attacker as the defender can not defend with troops. So, why make it frustrating. The attacked player could always revenge.

---

It's only frustrating for you because you don't know how to attack properly. Both the defenses and troops work in a specific way and always target in a similar manner. Learn the game's mechanics and use them to your advantage. Your scheme without substantial defensive changes would make attacking trivially easy.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gigamer

Last but not least, these are ideas, some players may support it, some may not. Idea 4 is simply for working people who don't have the time to keep going online to collect the resources from the mines. I only get online a couple of hours a night whenever I have time.

---

You don't have to keep going online to collect. Shields last for 12 hours. That means you only need to collect twice per day. Collect once in the morning. Then collect again in the evening.

This idea would have a disastrous effect on available loot, however since most of the easily accessible loot is in the collectors of inactive bases.

FYI buildings contain the same battle percentage regardless of size. Destroying a builder's hut will get you just as many percentages as destroying the town hall.

Guys this is a Forum for ideas and discussions. It is for players before developers. We keep the games going. All the three immediate replies are very strong. Ruled out! However, thanks for sharing your thoughts, but others will do as well. Don't forget one important thing. Many games have been developed and played worldwide. Many are also out dated. I have played online games for the past 18 yrs. Red Alert, Counter Strike, Heroes, etc.. Soon, games will get boring, players would move on to other games. It would be nice to keep an open mind, and try things for the players to stay interested.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gigamer

Guys this is a Forum for ideas and discussions. It is for players before developers. We keep the games going. All the three immediate replies are very strong. Ruled out! However, thanks for sharing your thoughts, but others will do as well. Don't forget one important thing. Many games have been developed and played worldwide. Many are also out dated. I have played online games for the past 18 yrs. Red Alert, Counter Strike, Heroes, etc.. Soon, games will get boring, players would move on to other games. It would be nice to keep an open mind, and try things for the players to stay interested.

---

Supercell has already developed the game around things that they know they can improve on and will keep the game interesting. Things such as automatically transferring loot to storages and controlling troops on your own...it's just not how the game is. The intent is for you to play more often. Examples: if you want your loot to go into your storages, go online, collect, raid, and voila. There is loot in your storages. Secondly, it just isn't practical to be able to control each individual troop. Yes, you are the Chief and Commander and Captain or whatever, but realistically, once troops are charging towards the enemy base, how likely is it that they will reverse direction and run somewhere else to do something else as they are being shot at? So there's logistics, and then of course, they want you to play more. Raid often and learn how troops act in certain situations, and you won't need to be able to control them

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gigamer

Guys this is a Forum for ideas and discussions. It is for players before developers. We keep the games going. All the three immediate replies are very strong. Ruled out! However, thanks for sharing your thoughts, but others will do as well. Don't forget one important thing. Many games have been developed and played worldwide. Many are also out dated. I have played online games for the past 18 yrs. Red Alert, Counter Strike, Heroes, etc.. Soon, games will get boring, players would move on to other games. It would be nice to keep an open mind, and try things for the players to stay interested.

---

Than people can get ideas other than this. Ruled out means supercell will NOT add it period. I agree that clash needs to stay fresh but with original ideas not ideas that everyone has seen many times before. Thank you for your time