ATTN SUPERCELL: How to stop issue of people joining, donating and leaving.

Hi Guys

Im the leader of NSW FTW. We have an issue where people keep joining and leaving. Most of the time they give a few barbarians or giants that no one asked for. The reasoning behind this is so the can gain quick experience.

This has become a major issue in my clan and no matter what we do to try and filter these people out it doesnt work.

My idea is to limit the amount of clans any one person can join. This could be set to one clan per 2 weeks? Make it so people can still leave but cant rejoin a clan for a designated period of time. The extra benefit of this is people would then stay in a clan for longer. They also wouldnt wont to be booted.

Please follow this up as i know this is an issue for many.

Thanks,
dale dudley.

Limiting clans seems great in theory but there are sister clans and it takes time to find the right clan.

Limiting people keeps them trapped in a bubble and punishes the majority because of the minority.

It's hard enough for people to find the right clan already, and limiting to 2 clans will make it even harder as their forced to wait, they probally could have found the right clan (sometimes it does happen in global.)

set clan to invite only.

Accept only members that you have talked with before hand either through global or forums.

Problem solved.

That was easy

Never had the problem you are reffering to unless we set clan to any can join low trophy count. Which is usually only done for fun. If you are a serious clan you should really be invite only.

As i had stated in my previous post "I HAVE TRIED EVERYTHING," this includes invite only. After a month of invite only most clans still need to change to "anyone can join," to replenish the ranks.

I agree with zannan that this is a minority but i disagree that it punishes people. It doesnt need to be 2 weeks, thats just my suggestion. I think most people would understand. Instead of just saying no, why not give an alternative suggestion?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by daledudley

As i had stated in my previous post "I HAVE TRIED EVERYTHING," this includes invite only. After a month of invite only most clans still need to change to "anyone can join," to replenish the ranks.

I agree with zannan that this is a minority but i disagree that it punishes people. It doesnt need to be 2 weeks, thats just my suggestion. I think most people would understand. Instead of just saying no, why not give an alternative suggestion?

---

It does punish people trying to find a clan even with a one hour wait as people should be able to try all sorts of clans until one fits. Sometimes it takes 1 million clans. (Although, that's unlucky.)
Why not is because it's pretty obvious to set your clan to invite only and be patient. Not many people will wait for you to accept the invite if they plan on leaving anyway. You'll still get some but that's the game.
Patience is key.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by daledudley

As i had stated in my previous post "I HAVE TRIED EVERYTHING," this includes invite only. After a month of invite only most clans still need to change to "anyone can join," to replenish the ranks.

I agree with zannan that this is a minority but i disagree that it punishes people. It doesnt need to be 2 weeks, thats just my suggestion. I think most people would understand. Instead of just saying no, why not give an alternative suggestion?

---

We are always invite only.. Anyone can join maybe a few times a year for laughs. Gave our suggestions. Do with them what you will.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RangerRussell

We are always invite only.. Anyone can join maybe a few times a year for laughs. Gave our suggestions. Do with them what you will.

---

To the OP, if you have your clan set to "anyone can join" why are you upset that anyone joins? Change to " invite only" You have to be more selective.... Post a recruitment thread here so you can find new members without dealing with global crazies, and yes, we all know there are lots of them....


To RangerRussell. Im in someone's sig.........I may cry tears of joy........

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by daledudley

As i had stated in my previous post "I HAVE TRIED EVERYTHING," this includes invite only. After a month of invite only most clans still need to change to "anyone can join," to replenish the ranks.

I agree with zannan that this is a minority but i disagree that it punishes people. It doesnt need to be 2 weeks, thats just my suggestion. I think most people would understand. Instead of just saying no, why not give an alternative suggestion?

---

Recruit better or lead better.

A bad idea... What's stopping clans from being horrid. Then being forced to play with one, because you ran out of terrible clans to filter though. There is always going to be more baddies than good players in any game you play, so limiting people to a clan they don't want to be in is worse.

If someone got stuck in a clan they didn't like, a lot of people would sabotage clan wars or donations to get kicked. I think that's worse than dealing with hoppers.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by daledudley

Hi Guys

Im the leader of NSW FTW. We have an issue where people keep joining and leaving. Most of the time they give a few barbarians or giants that no one asked for. The reasoning behind this is so the can gain quick experience.

This has become a major issue in my clan and no matter what we do to try and filter these people out it doesnt work.

My idea is to limit the amount of clans any one person can join. This could be set to one clan per 2 weeks? Make it so people can still leave but cant rejoin a clan for a designated period of time. The extra benefit of this is people would then stay in a clan for longer. They also wouldnt wont to be booted.

Please follow this up as i know this is an issue for many.

Thanks,
dale dudley.

---

This is not a great idea. The way to stop people from joining, donating and leaving is by changing your clan status to Invite only instead of Anyone can Join. Limiting players to 2 clans per week has a great theory behind it but it does take a long time to find the right clan you fit in with. I honestly couldn't see Supercell Doing this.

Hopefully this reply/post has helped you out!
If it has make sure to add me as a friend on the forums and check me out on
Youtube here! www.youtube.com/MarcusPlaysClash