Declare war on a rival clan

Had a thought on how to add a new dynamic to the game where you can Declare war on a rival Clan. I.e clan vs clan. I envisage it working something like as follows:

• The war is additional, so you can still attack random people as you do now
• War lasts for 1 week
• Each Clan member can only be attacked once by someone in the rival clan
• The clan who has wins the highest number of trophies from the opposite clan within the week wins
• Prize can be either gems, elixir, dark elixir or gold
• Create a ‘War monger’ leader board with trophies won in direct war with rival clans. Monthly prize of gems to the best war monger
• Strongest clan won’t always win the war. There is strategy involved around who should attack who to optimise the number of trophies you can win (i.e. lower rated player who can defeat a higher rated rival may earn more trophies, but risk losing the battle and trophies.
• winning wars will require the clan to work together, encourage donations and a majority of members will need to pick a target to attack
• A stronger clan ‘may’ have more trophies on offer to an attacking clan? Therefore almost acts as a handicap type event where anyone can win rather than just the top rated clans.
• Should be set up to encourage people to win trophies (i.e. people should not be advantaged by dropping a lot of trophies immediately prior to declaring war on someone)
• Only elders or leaders can declare war.
• war can only be declared on a rival clan that has an equivalent number of trophies
• limit to the number of wars you can be in at any one time - the limit may be one?

Thoughts?

I like it.

It would add a new dimension to being in a clan.

Cause now getting & giving troops and the occasional chat is the only clan aspect to the game really.

I'm sure there'd be a few issues to deal with at first, but I like how having a war would heat things up a bit!

No longer a faceless enemy; but one that can be studied and plotted against.

Might make it optional for your clan to be able to wage wars.

Also might add a chatroom for both cans to be in, for the duration of the war. Allthough a lot of kids (& adults) wouldnt be able to behave themselves I am sure lol.


I'd really welcome this.

this is a good idea, however i think anything related to this is already in the read me sticky

great idea best I've ever read for the game.

So what keeps me from working with the other clan to give us both an unlimited supply of free shields?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dahimi

So what keeps me from working with the other clan to give us both an unlimited supply of free shields?

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Holmeja

Had a thought on how to add a new dynamic to the game where you can Declare war on a rival Clan. I.e clan vs clan. I envisage it working something like as follows:

• The war is additional, so you can still attack random people as you do now
• War lasts for 1 week
• Each Clan member can only be attacked once by someone in the rival clan
• The clan who has wins the highest number of trophies from the opposite clan within the week wins
• Prize can be either gems, elixir, dark elixir or gold
• Create a ‘War monger’ leader board with trophies won in direct war with rival clans. Monthly prize of gems to the best war monger
• Strongest clan won’t always win the war. There is strategy involved around who should attack who to optimise the number of trophies you can win (i.e. lower rated player who can defeat a higher rated rival may earn more trophies, but risk losing the battle and trophies.
• winning wars will require the clan to work together, encourage donations and a majority of members will need to pick a target to attack
• A stronger clan ‘may’ have more trophies on offer to an attacking clan? Therefore almost acts as a handicap type event where anyone can win rather than just the top rated clans.
• Should be set up to encourage people to win trophies (i.e. people should not be advantaged by dropping a lot of trophies immediately prior to declaring war on someone)
• Only elders or leaders can declare war.
• war can only be declared on a rival clan that has an equivalent number of trophies
• limit to the number of wars you can be in at any one time - the limit may be one?

Thoughts?

---

I think that hows he planned on preventing that from happening besides if impleted SC will make changes to balance it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ivanmostdope

I think that hows he planned on preventing that from happening besides if impleted SC will make changes to balance it.

---

Ok so what happens if I leave my clan and join the other clan? What if I leave and rejoin my own clan?

i like it :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dahimi

Ok so what happens if I leave my clan and join the other clan? What if I leave and rejoin my own clan?

---

You can just make it so that only members in the clan at the commencement of the war can fight in the war. You could also limit how often you can declare war on the same village.

The only way this will happen if it was an entirely new app/game called "Clash of Clans Wars" or something similar. If you allowed clans to declare war on each other then the amount of villages available to the clans that aren't declaring war or to the people who aren't in clans will decrease dramatically.

You know that big complaint about loot not being available? With your proposal that problem would be exponentially worse. Also, the wars could be exploited and manipulated to be "shields".

Nice on paper, but chance of implementation is near zero.

You have clans with 50 members and others with 20
i had remember a scheme like yours, but i think is difficult to do that with clans with different member numbers

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by X11blaasbak

Also might add a chatroom for both cans to be in, for the duration of the war. Allthough a lot of kids (& adults) wouldnt be able to behave themselves I am sure lol.

---

I like the idea, but may end up in too many 'war crimes'!

Would be cool to have a battle room where you can specifically talk war tactics, engage in a little banter with the opposition and view all of the battles so you can see how your fellow clan members performed.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by hb808

You know that big complaint about loot not being available? With your proposal that problem would be exponentially worse. Also, the wars could be exploited and manipulated to be "shields".

Nice on paper, but chance of implementation is near zero.

---

not sure I understand why this would have any impact on available loot or shields? If you are in a war, you can still be attacked, and attack others. It is just one additional attack in a one week period against an opponent you can hand pick.

What am I missing?

Also, regarding the 20 vs 50 clan size comment. I think this would sort itself out by only allowing each clan member to be attacked once. If you only have 20 members, only 20 of the larger clan can attack you. I think it actually favours the smaller clan because you can be more selective about which members you attack.