Plus / Minus Donating Stats

Printable View

May 7th, 2013
weasel

Plus / Minus Donating Stats

First of all I'm sorry if this idea has been mentioned, I looked, and found nothing, for as long as my patience would allow me to search.

As the title states, I have an idea to change the troops donated stats in the clan. Plus / Minus ratio, if you are a hockey fan you know what this is, if not I will explain.

Instead of showing total troops donated, show +\- ratio. When you donate troops you get a + like the current method but when you receive a donation you get a - of equal value. This will show a clan mates true value in donations compared to what he receives. Most clans put up a minimum donation requirement, but how many troops has that person received while donating his/her minimum.

Two clan mates donate 300 troops, they look equal on the stats right. But one has requested and received 600 while the other has received 100. So in actual fact one is contributing more to the clan then the other. With this new system one will show a donation stat of +200 while the other will show -300 giving a much better value to his contributions.

Again I apologize if this idea has been mentioned before, my intention was not to waste anyone's time.
May 7th, 2013
Sommerrain

Idea

Suggestions to help the game
I love the game but there needs to be some upgrades done. I recommend the following. And please if anyone agrees maybe heyday admin will read this post
1- a market garden to buy farm tools like planks or have. Mill to turn the dead trees into wood to build things. There is not enough saws and stuff passed around and a lot of people have dead trees and are stuck.
2- expand the land on top or across the creek. That could make a good neighbours farm. Or just expand the land.
3- different types of fruit trees like bananas or oranges.
4- bee hive to make honey
5- different types of grain such as oat,clover, etc, it will help on making different things.

Quote:

Originally Posted by weasel

First of all I'm sorry if this idea has been mentioned, I looked, and found nothing, for as long as my patience would allow me to search.

As the title states, I have an idea to change the troops donated stats in the clan. Plus / Minus ratio, if you are a hockey fan you know what this is, if not I will explain.

Instead of showing total troops donated, show +\- ratio. When you donate troops you get a + like the current method but when you receive a donation you get a - of equal value. This will show a clan mates true value in donations compared to what he receives. Most clans put up a minimum donation requirement, but how many troops has that person received while donating his/her minimum.

Two clan mates donate 300 troops, they look equal on the stats right. But one has requested and received 600 while the other has received 100. So in actual fact one is contributing more to the clan then the other. With this new system one will show a donation stat of +200 while the other will show -300 giving a much better value to his contributions.

Again I apologize if this idea has been mentioned before, my intension was not to waste anyone's time.
May 7th, 2013
weasel

Unbelievable

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sommerrain

Suggestions to help the game
I love the game but there needs to be some upgrades done. I recommend the following. And please if anyone agrees maybe heyday admin will read this post
1- a market garden to buy farm tools like planks or have. Mill to turn the dead trees into wood to build things. There is not enough saws and stuff passed around and a lot of people have dead trees and are stuck.
2- expand the land on top or across the creek. That could make a good neighbours farm. Or just expand the land.
3- different types of fruit trees like bananas or oranges.
4- bee hive to make honey
5- different types of grain such as oat,clover, etc, it will help on making different things.

Valid points I'm sure but there are a couple flaws.
#1 this has nothing to do with the original topic that I've posted and...
#2 you are in the wrong forum. This is clash of clans not hay day.

This is the first thread I have made and I would prefer if it were not hijacked. Constructive feedback only please.
May 7th, 2013
JJSCHMITTY

I want this

I want this; and it wouldn't be hard to put into the game. You could also have more specific stats avalible in a different window, like 50 archers, 2 balloons, 100 giants, and 5 dragons. (that's only 630 slots).
May 8th, 2013
Wingzero

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sommerrain

Suggestions to help the game
I love the game but there needs to be some upgrades done. I recommend the following. And please if anyone agrees maybe heyday admin will read this post
1- a market garden to buy farm tools like planks or have. Mill to turn the dead trees into wood to build things. There is not enough saws and stuff passed around and a lot of people have dead trees and are stuck.
2- expand the land on top or across the creek. That could make a good neighbours farm. Or just expand the land.
3- different types of fruit trees like bananas or oranges.
4- bee hive to make honey
5- different types of grain such as oat,clover, etc, it will help on making different things.

1- I dont get it why a hayday came up here XD
2- why post a suggestion on another suggestion , doesn't even makes sense XD
May 8th, 2013
turtle2013

Quote:

Originally Posted by weasel

First of all I'm sorry if this idea has been mentioned, I looked, and found nothing, for as long as my patience would allow me to search.

As the title states, I have an idea to change the troops donated stats in the clan. Plus / Minus ratio, if you are a hockey fan you know what this is, if not I will explain.

Instead of showing total troops donated, show +\- ratio. When you donate troops you get a + like the current method but when you receive a donation you get a - of equal value. This will show a clan mates true value in donations compared to what he receives. Most clans put up a minimum donation requirement, but how many troops has that person received while donating his/her minimum.

Two clan mates donate 300 troops, they look equal on the stats right. But one has requested and received 600 while the other has received 100. So in actual fact one is contributing more to the clan then the other. With this new system one will show a donation stat of +200 while the other will show -300 giving a much better value to his contributions.

Again I apologize if this idea has been mentioned before, my intention was not to waste anyone's time.

I also would like this idea but no need to make it so complicated. Just add a column count for troops received. Done!