Easy clan hopper deterrent

Printable View

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page

May 7th, 2013
Boris1

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steved13

Thay can't donate when they first join? That would be worse! .???

irish21ice has the best solution, just admit it and move on!

Just trying to help love... calm your man ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥
May 7th, 2013
MintberryCrunch

So if I go to our feeder clan to say hi to a couple friends, and fill a few CCs while I'm over there, I lose the 5 level 5 wizards in my own CC for doing so? No thanks.
May 7th, 2013
Boris1

Quote:

Originally Posted by MintberryCrunch

So if I go to our feeder clan to say hi to a couple friends, and fill a few CCs while I'm over there, I lose the 5 level 5 wizards in my own CC for doing so? No thanks.

Someone on my side!! Thankyou. You are so right
May 7th, 2013
Steved13

Yes you would lose them for leaving the clan you got them from. Do battle before going to visit your friend, and you lose nothing.
May 7th, 2013
Irish2Ice

Quote:

Originally Posted by MintberryCrunch

So if I go to our feeder clan to say hi to a couple friends, and fill a few CCs while I'm over there, I lose the 5 level 5 wizards in my own CC for doing so? No thanks.

Yes, you would.

The simple solution to your individual plight would be to raid before you leave.... Or go visit when your Clan Castle is empty. Seems that would be a minor inconvenience to solve a major problem.
May 7th, 2013
MintberryCrunch

Quote:

Originally Posted by Irish2Ice

Yes, you would.

The simple solution to your individual plight would be to raid before you leave.... Or go visit when your Clan Castle is empty. Seems that would be a minor inconvenience to solve a major problem.

Its hardly just me as an individual, there are lots of people who move around from clan to clan to help with recruiting, donating, and just to say hi to people. I get wizards for defensive purposes, and its a big favor to ask of a clan member to tie up barracks for that long, I'm not going to waste them on an attack.

Also, if you're saying that raiding before I leave the clan is the best way for me to deal with it, how is this actually going to stop clan hopping among the people you're trying to target? If its the work-around for me, wouldn't clan hoppers just do the exact same thing and raid before they leave?
May 7th, 2013
AngrehBard

I honestly think we should just ignore clan hopping. So what if you donated a dragon, PEKKA, or whatever. It's your fault for getting fooled into giving him good stuff. It's not a big deal.
May 7th, 2013
MintberryCrunch

Quote:

Originally Posted by AngrehBard

I honestly think we should just ignore clan hopping. So what if you donated a dragon, PEKKA, or whatever. It's your fault for getting fooled into giving him good stuff. It's not a big deal.

Exactly this, losing 5 archers is hardly the end of the world... and you get 5 donations toward the "Friend in Need" achievement in the process, and XP.
May 7th, 2013
Irish2Ice

Quote:

Originally Posted by MintberryCrunch

Its hardly just me as an individual, there are lots of people who move around from clan to clan to help with recruiting, donating, and just to say hi to people. I get wizards for defensive purposes, and its a big favor to ask of a clan member to tie up barracks for that long, I'm not going to waste them on an attack.

Also, if you're saying that raiding before I leave the clan is the best way for me to deal with it, how is this actually going to stop clan hopping among the people you're trying to target? If its the work-around for me, wouldn't clan hoppers just do the exact same thing and raid before they leave?

I addressed this earlier in the thread and offered more than one solution for you. But one idea will never fit everyone. Also, I am quite certain there are more clan hoppers and people with clan hopper problems than feeder clans and those that jump from one to the other for the purpose of good.

Quote:

Originally Posted by AngrehBard

I honestly think we should just ignore clan hopping. So what if you donated a dragon, PEKKA, or whatever. It's your fault for getting fooled into giving him good stuff. It's not a big deal.

No offense, but thats pretty easy to say for a bonabee clan. I imagine your member retention is quite high. For the MANY clans trying to recruit, treat new recruits well and show good donating habits, we are being taken advantage of. It is a problem and quite annoying problem at that. Ignoring it just isn't a deterrence or solution.
May 7th, 2013
Irish2Ice

Quote:

Originally Posted by MintberryCrunch

Exactly this, losing 5 archers is hardly the end of the world... and you get 5 donations toward the "Friend in Need" achievement in the process, and XP.

But neither is losing 5 wizards, so it seems you proved my point. Are your donations or received donations so much better than someone else's?

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page