Easy clan hopper deterrent

Everyone has trouble with clan hoppers. Im not sure there are any real solutions, but I have a simple and effective way to deter hoppers from the request and run.

Make it so that when you leave a clan, you lose all your Clan Castle troops.

Simple and effective.
Sure, you can request and raid, but that takes time and effort. Also gives clans time to "catch on" that they didn't donate.

[Edit:] With feedback, instead of making this automatic, create as a feature the leader can choose for his own clan. Wipe troops upon leaving clan [on]\ off.

This should help those that leave to visit/help feeder clans and friends.

Sounds a bit.... strange but is probably the only way of stopping them. What if they leave a clan they must wait some hourse before joining one?

Our clan usually won't donate until a new member donates first. I do like the idea of losing donations when you leave.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Steved13

Our clan usually won't donate until a new member donates first

---

But remember your clan isnt every clan...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Boris1

Sounds a bit.... strange but is probably the only way of stopping them. What if they leave a clan they must wait some hourse before joining one?

---

I don't understand what is strange about it. It seems pretty simple to me that if you try to use a clan once for donations and leave, then you lose those troops.

The problem with your solution is when players are trying to find good clans. If someone joins and the clan is cursing, racist, immature, etc...you leave and join another clan. You shouldn't be penalized for that.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Irish2Ice

I don't understand what is strange about it. It seems pretty simple to me that if you try to use a clan once for donations and leave, then you lose those troops.

The problem with your solution is when players are trying to find good clans. If someone joins and the clan is cursing, racist, immature, etc...you leave and join another clan. You shouldn't be penalized for that.

---

Maybe people should just learn to deal with it?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Boris1

Maybe people should just learn to deal with it?

---

That could be the response for every suggestion or request in the entire forum. But not much help.

However, Im looking for solutions and deterrents to obvious problems within the game.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Boris1

But remember your clan isnt every clan...

---

No kidding? Really? Wow thanks for the insight, where would we be without your wisdom?

the point is its an idea to bring up to the rest of your clan if they can't figure it out for themselves.

by the way, if someone joins a clan, gets troops from the clan, why should they be allowed to leave with the clans troops? This is a very sensible suggestion, try thinking about it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Steved13

No kidding? Really? Wow thanks for the insight, where would we be without your wisdom?

the point is its an idea to bring up to the rest of your clan if they can't figure it out for themselves.

by the way, if someone joins a clan, gets troops from the clan, why should they be allowed to leave with the clans troops? This is a very sensible suggestion, try thinking about it.

---

Just saying there are serious noobs who will donate sir sarcasam. I just think they should make it so that people cannot donate within the first so long of joining or something.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Boris1

Just saying there are serious noobs who will donate sir sarcasam. I just think they should make it so that people cannot donate within the first so long of joining or something.

---

Thay can't donate when they first join? That would be worse! .???

irish21ice has the best solution, just admit it and move on!