To Restrict hoppers ,from getting free troops

Since in Clan lot of new players join randomly( which can be restricted) but even if they are invited(in case of Closed Clan). There is a trend people ask for troops and then leave the clan. They do this hopping never donate just request free troops.

So in order to stop this, we can have a new field like troops donated:- Troops Requested (when a person joins a clan)
And the clan leader will have option to set a Ratio of Troops Requested to Troops Donated.

This way the Hoppers will not be able to Request troops always.


(for First time since it will be 0/0, so we this can be ignored)

Frnds plz post your views ..Will it help?

I don't know if this is what we need.

I'm a clan leader and I know that you must be angry of those who request and leave your clan.
Last week someone joined my clan and request at the same time.
I donate to him 5 level 4 wizards and then he leave my clan, not a big loss.
I had no problem dealing with this cause he just wasted his chance to stay in a good clan.
We had no minimum donate / week, we communicate a lot, at least our clan board is all text, not donate button.
So what do you think?

Edit :
I forgot to mention that 90% of my clan member is my university classmates.
And that's the reason they're very loyal.
Now that they're rarely active playing, I'm planning to join a good clan rather than manage my ghost clan.
DTP is my target, what a sweet sweet clan that communicate a lot.

i have no issue with troop donations regarding hoppers cause they help me attain that friend in need gems. and you could always choose the units you will donate with your newbies.

What i don't like with hoppers is that they take up clan space

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by viveksin

Since in Clan lot of new players join randomly( which can be restricted) but even if they are invited(in case of Closed Clan). There is a trend people ask for troops and then leave the clan. They do this hopping never donate just request free troops.

So in order to stop this, we can have a new field like troops donated:- Troops Requested (when a person joins a clan)
And the clan leader will have option to set a Ratio of Troops Requested to Troops Donated.

This way the Hoppers will not be able to Request troops always.


(for First time since it will be 0/0, so we this can be ignored)

---

me I don't care about the few archers lost, they are not so expensive :)

meanwhile elder players have experience with clan hoppers and they can be recognised quickly:

1. they do not introduce themself to the clan
2. they send right away troop request
3. they do not donate troops
4. they always ask for clan elder

when someone joins our clan, we send troop request first just to see if the player is donating. if not, then he will be kicked out.