Printable View
Hi dear,
It seems that u upgraded lots of things about COC games during I started to play this game. It is awesome now.
Do one last update for people who play n love COC.
Make some penalty for those players who leave clan during war.
U can banned them for joining other clan for next 2 days or cut 50 gems or 0.5 million elixir. It's my suggestion to you.
You can choose your decision.
Good day
Kaaff
Stay & Enjoy
horrible idea
what if they leave because their 'fellow' members are being rude to them? way too many variables to enact a punishment beyond the war cooldown.
just be more selective as to who you accept into your clan and make sure they are game for war before hitting that search button
What if people leave for good? So this is a no from me
This is a horrible idea. If people are leaving your clan, your clan is probably ♥♥♥♥.
If people are leaving your clan you probably have a 0 trophy anyone can join clan.. If not you have a pretty un-loyal one.Quote:
Originally Posted by bonshaix
P.s. anyone in a 0 cup anyone can join clan.. Leave..they suck too much
I think clan hoppers would be ♥♥♥♥♥♥ off if this is integrated into the game, which in the end Supercell would also lose income as lesser players will be playing COC.
Unfortunately, I think we just have to deal with the clan hoppers. :(
Quote:
Originally Posted by bonshaix
That's true-that is annoying.
But SuperCell will need many work to create penalties(I think).
But anyway it should be any penalties for players that leave a clan during the Clan War.
No thanks. In my clan family, we bounce around between clans, often during war. Why should we be punished because others can't manage their clan(s)?
Very easy to deal with actually. Give them less % of their war bonus in their next war. They more they skip, the less they get or until they make up their attacks that they skipped
Now thats an idea outside the box.Quote:
Originally Posted by Duckbill77
Dont do your 2 Fights, next war your loot is less with explanation,
this should not effect people who visit back and forth.
Quote:
Originally Posted by bonshaix
how how about they just get their war loot hehe.
With this rule he will simply drop 1 barbarian each fight or snipe an enemy th. Also he might start insulting others until he is kicked out.
Also not giving him war loot does not help much because if he does not attack he will not get loot anyway. Also most players leave after 2 or 3 wars if your clan looses the war.
Simply dont accept too many new players at once. This always causes troubles if they do not fight or fight bad.
So what if someone leaves because of another reason, other than to clan hop? Tbh, I think the only way to fix this is to be able to choose who participates in a war, and I would want that. Put some more thought into it
If people are leaving a clan during war, it's a sign that they shouldn't have been there in the first place. If you are just accepting anyone, then don't be surprised if they act randomly. You gotta weed out the kids upon entrance.
The leaving player should just give up their two attacks to the leader or a co leader. No harm done to anyone, besides the leaders loots. But they lead a clan for a reason right?
There's NO WAY that's going to be easily exploitable.Quote:
Originally Posted by Boardname
That may be, but they can make it so that you can only use the troops and their level the leaving player has unlocked.Quote:
Originally Posted by loveless2213
Lol then I kick out all Players during war that have less skill than me. I must be a really bad attacker at lvl100 if any of the th4s and 5s that is not a second account would stay in the clan :P
Horrible idea...
Hahaha! So I load up my clan with noobs, for matchmaking, and the strongest players attack in their place!Quote:
Originally Posted by Boardname
Terrible idea.
This is a terrible idea. No constructive criticism, this is bad.
Read the following up post of mine...Quote:
Originally Posted by TheConfuzed1
I think you need to be really careful about punishing anyone. Instead how about a stat that sticks with them to tell us how many times they have bailed in the past on clans during war? Right now I use the current eligibility to determine if a new member bailed on his last clan during war... and they dont get to stay with us. If a player does not want to be in my clan thats fine, no hard feelings, but dont quit during war... thats just rude and disrespectful.
Perhaps if people HAVE to use both their attacks before they leave
A 2-3 day penalty to not war with the new clan they decide to join will be ok. Since they know they just finished screwing one over. The game should detect when that person attacked both times.. thus no penalty will be had. But say they leave and not attack 2x, then maybe give them a 48-72 hour penalty to not be eligible to war. That way they don't screw some other clan over... in less than 24 hours.
Hi Guys,
Thanks for your participation and sharing your ideas.
We hope Suppercell will do the next.
It's appreciating that some want to do something good but sorry for those who is looser, specially hoppers, most of them don't like the idea.
Whatever happened we still love to play COC, we enjoy...
GOOD LUCK FOR ALL
Stay & Enjoy
Kaaff
The idea to have a historical portion a user profile detailing whether (and if so, how many times) the user has bailed on a clan [during war] would be an excellent way to assist clans in determining whether they wish to accept the new member or not.
This would avoid the need for an additional punishment outside of the cool down period, and would make it much less desirable for users to hop from clan to clan as they would be identified as such in their profile.
Now, that said, this "counter" keeping track could possibly be reset upon end of each season (similar to donation counts, badges, etc)
I've suggested this numerous times, and would be an amazing addition to the game.
Thanks,
--
AdamN[x]V