Printable View
I think that supercell should add a box at the top of every players profile that shows:
#1 how many troops the player has requested.
#2 how many clans the player has joined.
These 2 items could help a lot with keeping hoppers out of our clans. If you see that someone has been in 81 clans and requested 300k troops, and are lvl 30, that should give you a good guess on whether or not you should donate to them.
Our clan just has a rule that if you request before you donate a full CC worth of troops, you get the boot. But those stats would be fun to see!Quote:
Originally Posted by jallen6
My clan will kick you if you request immediately, or more than 5 times a day(outside of war),but I believe this will help others.
No, this idea is terrible, sorry but it is, Due to privacy reasons I couldn't see this clash...
Your clan would kick you if you request more than 5 times a day? Yeesh, being a farmer would be hard in your clan. Anyways, that was just a little thing I wanted to say, onto the actual topic of the thread.Quote:
Originally Posted by jallen6
This would definitely invade people's privacy in a way. I also like to jump around a lot of clans to visit some of my friends so would every join count as one or just one join for the whole clan no matter the number of times I join? I don't think SuperCell needs to add this mainly because there's no real point to it. What's the most a hopper can do anyways? Take a couple of wizards, drop an F Bomb and leave? I don't really know why people make a huge deal out of them, I don't.
I made that rule because any time I looked at the chat there were 10+ requests on there and not many people donation. And my idea does not invade privacy, it does not give any personal information or information that people shouldn't know. the only people that should even care if these numbers appear on their profiles are hoppers. And you may not think much of loosing a couple wizards, but they add up, and this can help save people from wasting their hard earned loot.
Actually I care and I am a leader of a loyal clan, here's the thing this WILL invade peoples privacy I sure wouldn't want people seeing how much troops I received and how much clans I been to in my whole life of playing clash which I'm sure was quite a lot before, the leaders need to set rules to protect there clan from hoppers but as the cheese said they are no big deal if you cant handle donating a few wizards or other troops because they "add up" you shouldn't own or be in a clan. I donate about 2,000 to 4,000 troops each season doesn't bother me at all....Quote:
Originally Posted by jallen6
I have no problem donation to loyal members, but it is a waste for me to donate do people who don't even have the courtesy to say hi before they request or thank you before they leave. And why is there a problem with people seeing how many troops you have received? How is it any different than people knowing how much you donate, how much loot you have stolen, or the highest trophy amount you have gotten too? All those numbers are there for people to determine if you are a good player, and they don't have any form of a privacy issue.
Well first off why would you even donate to a person that request without even talking first....Those people get kicked right away in my clan.... I would not want people to know how much troops I have received, thats my business and mine only, and how many clans you been in before? Cmon really.....That part is the worst suggestion I have probably read ( no offense ) That has tons of privacy issues, I think I would be speaking for most of the clash community when. I say I would not want anyone knowing how many clans iv been in the past.....Quote:
Originally Posted by jallen6
I have noticed the problems in #2. I have joined my fair share of clans recruiting my friends, but I still do not see a problem with seeing how many troops you have requested. And if that has privacy issues to you then you should have stopped playing long ago. Your profile already shows how many troops you have received in your clan during each season, my idea just extends upon that. And also like I have said, it is no different than your profile showing the amount of troops you have donated total.