A Gem Box Twist!!!!!!

We all love the Gem Boxes?! I mean, free gems! Who wouldn't like that? This idea aims to make the Gem Boxes better, by making the amount of gems you get RANDOM!! (Based on probability). No more just 25 Gems, instead you could get 15, 25, 50, 75, 100, or even 500 Gems!!!!!! Now, since SEE probably doesn't want you getting 500 Gems each gem box, there is a chance chart.

15 Gems: 25%

25 Gems: 45%

50 Gems: 15%

75 Gems: 10%

100 Gems: 4%

500 Gems: 1%


Each Gem box shows up once a season in any place it can, as normal. The only difference is the amount of gems! Thanks and leave your feedback in the comments!!!! I do not mind criticism unless the commenter is rude about it.

Responses please!

Seriously? You bumped this after half an hour??

It won't be implemented because of this: a Think of all the whining on the forums. Then multiply it by ten, since people would be mad they only get 5 gems out of a gem box. I like the idea, but not the 5 gems, that needs to be wayy higher.

It would be pretty cool.

i think its ruled out

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Shiryu47

i think its ruled out

---

Cite pls?
10 chars

I agree with the first responder in that there will be a lot of complaining from those who only get 5 gems. It's not something that I think should be worried about. I'd like to stick to our reliable 25 gems.

Of course a guaranteed 25 is good and I'm not disagreeing with you here but the reason 5 gems is on there is because it has to balance out the higher rewards. One 500 gem winner would equal 20 of the current boxes, so giving out 5 in some of them is to make it even

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheCheese

Of course a guaranteed 25 is good and I'm not disagreeing with you here but the reason 5 gems is on there is because it has to balance out the higher rewards. One 500 gem winner would equal 20 of the current boxes, so giving out 5 in some of them is to make it even

---

I know why the 5 gem box is on the list, but what I'm saying is someone is gonna hit the 5% 3 or 4 times in a row and they're gonna whine about it (I sure would, haha), and these people did nothing to deserve such a weak amount of gems compared to someone who hits boxes for 50+ gems for several weeks. I don't think that in an upgrade game with strategic attacking, anyone should be penalized by random chance, especially where premium currency is concerned, ya know? That's why I don't like this idea

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Shiryu47

i think its ruled out

---

There is nothing on the sticky that says so.
OP- Good idea, but crank the 5 gems to 10 or 15.

In supercells case 500 gems is more like .1% chance of getting it

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ClashLegend02

Seriously? You bumped this after half an hour??

It won't be implemented because of this: a Think of all the whining on the forums. Then multiply it by ten, since people would be mad they only get 5 gems out of a gem box. I like the idea, but not the 5 gems, that needs to be wayy higher.

---

I understand this idea but it should start at 15 THEN increase. Gem boxes are already pretty rare, I'd be mad to if I got 5 gems from a gem box.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Shadowkungfu

There is nothing on the sticky that says so.
OP- Good idea, but crank the 5 gems to 10 or 15.

---

I will change it to 15 gems.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Hascerflef

I will change it to 15 gems.

---

See, now 5 is too few gems.

If you were to do this for a long time, you would average 37-38 gems per gem box, statistically. You're effectively asking for more free gems. I really don't think this is a good idea

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tiler

See, now 5 is too few gems.

If you were to do this for a long time, you would average 37-38 gems per gem box, statistically. You're effectively asking for more free gems. I really don't think this is a good idea

---

But wouldn't you like to get that small chance of getting 500 Gems? I think I've learned my lesson with the Clash IFR.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Hascerflef

But wouldn't you like to get that small chance of getting 500 Gems? I think I've learned my lesson with the Clash IFR.

---

Well of course I would like free gems. But more free gems are ruled out, and as far as I'm concerned, that's basically what you're asking for

Based on luck, someone can get 15 OR 500 gems!!??

This would only result in 1% of the people being satisfied (the 500 gem bunch) and the 99% being jealous of and hating on the 1% and blaming SC.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tiler

Well of course I would like free gems. But more free gems are ruled out, and as far as I'm concerned, that's basically what you're asking for

---

He's asking for the gem box to have a chance of having different things as, let's be honest here, you don't like the 25 gems only and want more.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by X7386

Based on luck, someone can get 15 OR 500 gems!!??

This would only result in 1% of the people being satisfied (the 500 gem bunch) and the 99% being jealous of and hating on the 1% and blaming SC.

---

Why would you get jealous over dumb luck?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Shadowkungfu

He's asking for the gem box to have a chance of having different things as, let's be honest here, you don't like the 25 gems only and want more.

---

I love the gem box as is, and I repeat:

Of course I would like more gems! I am not saying that I wouldn't!

However!

More free gems are ruled out, and that's what this is. If it were something like 1/3 chance of 10, 25 or 40 gems, then I would have a different opinion, but it's not. As far as I'm concerned, the Gem Box, as is, is more than we deserve, as regular obstacles already provide a reasonable supply of stuff we would normally have to purchase with real money.

It is my opinion that this is a greedy request, and if it were implemented, the forums would be full of people getting the bad luck draw, not to mention SC losing money on gem purchases.

How many gems do you people need before you are satisfied?

I love this idea! Crank up the gems from 5 to 10-15! Also, add a poll!

I think we should be happy that Supercell added gem boxes, and we don't really need more gems from them. This would be helpful for us but it's unlikely to happen. :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Hascerflef

We all love the Gem Boxes?! I mean, free gems! Who wouldn't like that? This idea aims to make the Gem Boxes better, by making the amount of gems you get RANDOM!! (Based on probability). No more just 25 Gems, instead you could get 5, 25, 50, 75, 100, or even 500 Gems!!!!!! Now, since SEE probably doesn't want you getting 500 Gems each gem box, there is a chance chart.

15 Gems: 40%

25 Gems: 30%

50 Gems: 15%

75 Gems: 10%

100 Gems: 4%

500 Gems: 1%


Each Gem box shows up once a season in any place it can, as normal. The only difference is the amount of gems! Thanks and leave your feedback in the comments!!!! I do not mind criticism unless the commenter is rude about it.

---

so its 70% chance to get 25 or less gems?
I'd rather the current 25.

I think you should remove both getting 15 gems and 500 gems because I think that is too much. Overall I think this will improve clash of clans economy, just like the time supercell added clan wars

Lower the gem values.