How To Make People Want To Donate A LOT In Clans

Idea #1. What if there was a minimum people HAVE to donate in the clan or they get kicked? Like for example you could make it so that every week every person has to donate 400 troops, if someone does not, they will automatically get kicked.

Idea #2. What if the more people donate in your clan the more the get rewarded? For example out of thin air they would get a tiny bonus for donating alot? Or if someone has been in the clan for a month, they would start getting paid with gold and elixir. This would REALLY promote donating... It would also depend on what kind of troop, so it would depend on the level of the troop, what kind of troop.

Idea #3 (Ties up with #2). People can choose what troop they would prefer, for example if I wanted archers and people give me archers, they would get those bonuses I was talking about in idea #2

Idea #4. What if you could get XP points for donating what people wanted, this also ties up with idea #3. Those XP points would let you level up to new Clan Levels. The higher the clan level the higher donating bonuses you would get.

Thank you! Tell me what you think and I will be adding more ideas whenever I think of them.

Then i would make my own clan, get my second account on it, and donate to myself for free resources

I like it should be dependent on troop quality too and łeagues

I edited the thread ;)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PinkiePie

Idea #1. What if there was a minimum people HAVE to donate in the clan or they get kicked? Like for example you could make it so that every week every person has to donate 400 troops, if someone does not, they will automatically get kicked.

Idea #2. What if the more people donate in your clan the more the get rewarded? For example out of thin air they would get a tiny bonus for donating alot? Or if someone has been in the clan for a month, they would start getting paid with gold and elixir. This would REALLY promote donating...

---

1. You can see the donators. Kick them yourself.

2. Wouldn't a tiny bonus be lower than the cost of donating the troops?

I don't understand why people are too strict about clan donation.
I request only once / day only to guard my base at night.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by vkstarry

I don't understand why people are too strict about clan donation.
I request only once / day only to guard my base at night.

---

This gives those that request troops but then never give any troops to anyone else that needs them a reason to donate...

Anyway, thanks for the comments!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PinkiePie

This gives those that request troops but then never give any troops to anyone else that needs them...

Anyway, thanks for the comments!

---

I prefer a member that communicate a lot and request troops only for defense.
Not those who request and use your troops to attack.
Once or twice is not a problem, but if you're an active player, you will saw his request frequently.
Then feel free to kick him.

If they're a pro player, they won't use clan castle troops to attack people.
By the way, what's your clan name and your game id?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by vkstarry

I prefer a member that communicate a lot and request troops only for defense.
Not those who request and use your troops to attack.
Once or twice is not a problem, but if you're an active player, you will saw his request frequently.
Then feel free to kick him.

If they're a pro player, they won't use clan castle troops to attack people.
By the way, what's your clan name and your game id?

---

You are using your CC inefficiently, unless you never raid. To limit your clan to only request for defense is severely limiting your clan as well. If you kick a player who requests frequently, you should be demoted from elder, that is unless he never donates himself. LoL, I love the use of the term "pro player", but if you think that caliber of player uses castle troops solely for defense, you are sadly mistaken. Donating as many troops as you can to everyone who requests, as often as that may be, will only help your clan and clan mates grow.

This is my post from a simular thread.

Simple fix for the slacker group. Add a filter in the CC. If there are open troop requests in clan chat, you may not request until you donate yourself. There needs to be a set criteria that would release you from the obligation allowing you to request. Would it be a single goblin? A minimum of five troop spaces? A minimum of five troop spaces to all open requests? I like that one. It forces you to give to all requests before you can request yourself.

Simply, if you want CC troops, you will have to fill all open requests.