Surrender option in wars?

This idea isn't based off of too much right now. Probably has some flaws, but I'm hoping we can build off of it.

so the idea is simple. I was thinking of the addition of both teams having a "surrender" option after a certain amount of hours in a war (amount of hours can be determined later). I mean, when you're winning a war 99-30 and the enemy teams only has 8 minutes left and has obviously given up hope, why can't they surrender. This IS what happens in real life and throughout history. One side would either get obliterated, or the other would surrender.


how the team can go about surrendering

To prevent people from trolling the clan I've come up with a system that can be used to prevent this. surrenders have to be voted on by a percentage of co leaders and a percentage of elders and then there can be a 5 hour waiting period until the surrender is confirmed, just in case people have changed their mind about surrendering. The leader has the final say in whether the clan surrenders or not.

rewards/penalties for surrendering

just like real war the side that gives up gets nothing. No war loot, nothing. The winning team gets their loot, a win, and those who didn't attack can get a small loot reward of 50000 in gold and elixir, and 50 dark elixir. (Loot bonuses for those who didn't participate can vary by th level.)

well ill that's all I've got for now guys. Hopefully this is a good idea. If you like it, please post any feedback.

- :3

Idea additions
- the winning team has to accept the surrender
- If you want to surrender, it'll cost you. If you can't afford to surrender, well, then you can't surrender. This applies to each member of your clan. Anyone that has already been raided twice gets a free pass and won't owe anything.

I dont play clash but that sounds like a fine idea

If you want to surrender, simply do not attack any more.

We do not surrender at all. Everybody has to use his attacks even if we are 20 stars behind 5 Minute before the end. If we loose it is time to improve something in the clan and the best way for this is kicking everybody that did not fight, because I do not Need no members that only fight if they get loot.
The only exception is if somebody has no enemy any more.

I do not like this idea. A full 24 hours is given so that everyone has a chance to attack. If my clan is up by like 50 stars with an hour or two left we will use remaining attacks up high to get a lot of war loot. If the enemy surrendered we would not have that chance. Also with the new update the losing side still gets 30% of the war winnings anyways. So im sure all of the people on the losing side who have used attacks would not be too happy losing their war loot. even if it is only 30% of what they would have received it is way better than nothing.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by andrgin

If you want to surrender, simply do not attack any more.

We do not surrender at all. Everybody has to use his attacks even if we are 20 stars behind 5 Minute before the end. If we loose it is time to improve something in the clan and the best way for this is kicking everybody that did not fight, because I do not Need no members that only fight if they get loot.
The only exception is if somebody has no enemy any more.

---

I disagree. I don't want to wait 13 hours for another war to star because the enemy team doesn't want to attack. If they surrender, we can go on to the next war.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Hickster83

I do not like this idea. A full 24 hours is given so that everyone has a chance to attack. If my clan is up by like 50 stars with an hour or two left we will use remaining attacks up high to get a lot of war loot. If the enemy surrendered we would not have that chance. Also with the new update the losing side still gets 30% of the war winnings anyways. So im sure all of the people on the losing side who have used attacks would not be too happy losing their war loot. even if it is only 30% of what they would have received it is way better than nothing.

---

There re is a choice to surrender or, the enemy team doesn't have to surrender and can wait the war out for the loot. It's a surrender OPTION. But I see what ur saying.

Haven't you learned by now that 95% of this game is waiting?

The only way i could see it being remotely fair is if the winning side had to accept the surrender

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Hickster83

The only way i could see it being remotely fair is if the winning side had to accept the surrender

---

It has its merits, as then both sides could attack for what loot is left, but then the losing side is still obligated to stay until the Winner is finished.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Hickster83

The only way i could see it being remotely fair is if the winning side had to accept the surrender

---

Awesome idea! I'll add it!

Only way I'd allow a surrender option is that if you haven't been attacked and say your opposite from the other clan didn't get his attacks in, you owe him what he would have won had he had the chance to raid your base. All from YOUR storage.

If you want to surrender, it'll cost you. If you can't afford to surrender, well, then you can't surrender. This applies to each member of your clan. Anyone that has already been raided twice gets a free pass and won't owe anything.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AxionXD

Only way I'd allow a surrender option is that if you haven't been attacked and say your opposite from the other clan didn't get his attacks in, you owe him what he would have won had he had the chance to raid your base. All from YOUR storage.

If you want to surrender, it'll cost you. If you can't afford to surrender, well, then you can't surrender. This applies to each member of your clan. Anyone that has already been raided twice gets a free pass and won't owe anything.

---

Added. Great idea!