Clans wars needs these improvements. maybe...

Here are some several things that I expect related to wars:

1. Incentive (extra bonus) if we can 3-star all opponent warbases. Maybe gems or 50% addition to collected bonus.
   
2. Incentive (extra bonus) for player who gets most heroic attack and defense.
3. Ability to choose which members that will join the war so we don't have to kick and re-invite members who cant participate in certain war due to vacation, factory upgrade (people will mostly be useless in war when they cant use spell), or maybe queen upgrade (the most helpful hero).
4. More perfected clan matching to reduce unfair wars
5. Hide replays so that opponent cant see our attacks strategies until the war ends
6. A new "War" chat tab where we can use that specifically for war. Maybe only leaders or co-leaders who can only post instructions to that chat area. This tab will only be accessible when we have war and reset/cleared when the war ends.
7. Automatic new war search as the war is ended if we set the war frequency to "Always"
8. "Recommended target" is actually useless
9. Value the donations to warbase. It makes people lazy to donate since this does not add to their donation achievements nor exps.
10. ​maybe more later.... :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ATHCOC

Here are some several things that I expect related to wars:

1. Incentive (extra bonus) if we can 3-star all opponent warbases. Maybe gems or 50% addition to collected bonus.
   
2. Incentive (extra bonus) for player who gets most heroic attack and defense.
3. Ability to choose which members that will join the war so we don't have to kick and re-invite members who cant participate in certain war due to vacation, factory upgrade (people will mostly be useless in war when they cant use spell), or maybe queen upgrade (the most helpful hero).
4. More perfected clan matching to reduce unfair wars
5. Hide replays so that opponent cant see our attacks strategies until the war ends
6. A new "War" chat tab where we can use that specifically for war. Maybe only leaders or co-leaders who can only post instructions to that chat area. This tab will only be accessible when we have war and reset/cleared when the war ends.
7. Automatic new war search as the war is ended if we set the war frequency to "Always"
8. "Recommended target" is actually useless
9. Value the donations to warbase. It makes people lazy to donate since this does not add to their donation achievements nor exps.
10. ​maybe more later.... :)

---

1. Unless your clan is all town hall 5s and good at wearing that's never gonna happen, specially at top clans.

2. How do you decide most of the time multiple people won't lose a star and will 3 star both Attacks in low level clans.

3. Obviously it's a good idea but maybe if you spent 5 minutes reading some threads you would find this suggestion a lot.

4. It takes ages to match clans now, do you want it to take like a day?

5. Well they want to know how to improve their base and they can't do anything during the war so that's pointless.

6. Immature players would talk trash and use offensive language.

7. Decent idea.

8. Not really as it means that if everyone attacks their recommended it means they always attack someone of a similar level and then if they can't do it attack lower down for 2nd attack or if it's a push over higher up.

9. What?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Randomtreestix

1. Unless your clan is all town hall 5s and good at wearing that's never gonna happen, specially at top clans.

2. How do you decide most of the time multiple people won't lose a star and will 3 star both Attacks in low level clans.

3. Obviously it's a good idea but maybe if you spent 5 minutes reading some threads you would find this suggestion a lot.

4. It takes ages to match clans now, do you want it to take like a day?

5. Well they want to know how to improve their base and they can't do anything during the war so that's pointless.

6. Immature players would talk trash and use offensive language.

7. Decent idea.

8. Not really as it means that if everyone attacks their recommended it means they always attack someone of a similar level and then if they can't do it attack lower down for 2nd attack or if it's a push over higher up.

9. What?

---

1. Nope. Our clan has few TH10s, several TH9s, several TH8s, and others... (mostly we keep it 30 members). We managed to 3star all opponent bases once. And other several chances but remaining players used their attacks to go for loot instead of 3 starring remaining targets because of no extra bonus/incentive

2. I saw that it's hard to get most heroic defense at the moment. They can simply change this selection

5. Lol, they can't do anything to their base during a war. So, how can you expect them to improve their warbase during the war? They should only be able to see replays (opponent attacks) when the war is ended. Otherwise, they can steal/replicate our attack strategy during a war.

6. As I said, only leader and co-leaders can post to that area. What leader that wants to promote immature player as a co?
Also, as you said, immature player tends to talk trash. This is annoying when some players are talking or giving instructions related to ongoing war.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ATHCOC

1. Nope. Our clan has few TH10s, several TH9s, several TH8s, and others... (mostly we keep it 30 members). We managed to 3star all opponent bases once. And other several chances but remaining players used their attacks to go for loot instead of 3 starring remaining targets because of no extra bonus/incentive

2. I saw that it's hard to get most heroic defense at the moment. They can simply change this selection

5. Lol, they can't do anything to their base during a war. So, how can you expect them to improve their warbase during the war? They should only be able to see replays (opponent attacks) when the war is ended. Otherwise, they can steal/replicate our attack strategy during a war.

6. As I said, only leader and co-leaders can post to that area. What leader that wants to promote immature player as a co?
Also, as you said, immature player tends to talk trash. This is annoying when some players are talking or giving instructions related to ongoing war.

---

1. Yeah but as you say it happened once!

2. Attack aswell were you thinking like most stars with fewest troops?

5. Obviously I meant they would change their base after the war.

6. Then that would be better yeah but if only cos and leaders could use it only they would benefit, what if it was like a chat but in a new tab that everyone can view like a clan description only viewable to those inside the clan?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ATHCOC

6. As I said, only leader and co-leaders can post to that area. What leader that wants to promote immature player as a co?
Also, as you said, immature player tends to talk trash. This is annoying when some players are talking or giving instructions related to ongoing war.

---

Sorry for jumping in here but what if the whole clan is full of immature kids?

1. That would be a good idea! 3 starring all bases in a war is a tough feat no matter what TH levels in the clan or the opponent.

2. That would be cool as well. I'm not personally sure how the two are calculated, but it would be nice to see a reward for those people who achieve those.

3. This is a good idea as well. It would obviously be a (co)leader feature, and it would help for people who don't want their donation count to reset in the middle of a season.

4. This is a bit of a toughie. Obviously war matching isn't perfect, but consider how much has to go into calculating a matchup. Something does need to be fixed obviously, though.

5. I don't think this is too big of an issue. The ability for a clan to see their enemy's attacks is a good indicator of whether or not the clan can go for loot, based on how well they think the enemy is doing. I also love the "watch live" option a lot.

6. I like this too. It would allow (co)leaders to instruct the clan without getting lost and confused in regular chat. We can sort of do this with clan mail, but the ability to post only every 12 hours and the limited length get in the way of this.

7. Not so sure about this one. For example, the clan that mine feeds into has their war frequency set to "always," but they only war three times a week with a break on Sunday. Perhaps more options to the frequency could be added such as "3 times per week" or "back to back" would make this idea more implementable.

8. TRUE DAT. I am always #1 on my clan's war map, but my "recommended target" is actually 6 or 7, which makes no sense, especially when I never have a problem 2 or even 3 starring my equal war counterpart.

9. YASSS. My donation count would be significantly higher if this were to be implemented. I honestly can't think of a good reason for this not to be implemented, other than the fact that people could donate, have the person they donated to delete the troops, and then have them donate again. This could be easily fixed though by having only the initial troops you donated to the CC count, so for example, if I donate a dragon to a CC that has a capacity of 20, and the person deletes it, I could donate again, but only the initial 20 from the initial dragon would count towards my donation ratio. But this issue is seriously one of my biggest pet peeves with war.

10. Can't wait to hear 'em.(: