Leaders and Co-Leaders option to remove troops from other members clan castles in war

In a way i do think that this would help to fix any grief donation (gobs,wb) but i don't think it is that important.... Because people donating to CW don't get any exp, so it will be les likely for any donation spammers to spam goblin to the CW CC because they don't get any exp.....
But if it was me, i would like that feature to be available only, and just only clan leader.... Such that clan leader is the only ome that can delete other clan castle troops.... That way there will be less griefing of people deleting cw cc

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by FireThief

No way- you'd get them removing what troops you know work well for your defence. It should be up to the owner of the village.

---

Yes but I think his point is that it's annoying when people stockpile lvl 1 giants into war castles and then people don't remove them. I remember when we lost a war because of it.

The way I see it, cô leaders have a lot of power already. Let's face it: the only thing they can't do is promote themselves to leader or kick other cô leaders. If they had the amount of power you are sugesting, I would have a heart attack every war. (No offence)

All these guys saying its part of ur village and it should be under your control must be newbs. Besides theres a message that YOU can write saying EXACTLY what u want?!

You shouldn't have this problem anyway with players that are active. If they aren't active enough to get on and remove bad troops (Which is another problem that shouldn't happen in any decent clan), then maybe they aren't reliable enough to be in your clan. Correct your poor players -- theres no need whatsoever to add more unneccessary power to co-leaders.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Caguggenmos

You shouldn't have this problem anyway with players that are active. If they aren't active enough to get on and remove bad troops (Which is another problem that shouldn't happen in any decent clan), then maybe they aren't reliable enough to be in your clan. Correct your poor players -- theres no need whatsoever to add more unneccessary power to co-leaders.

---

So ur saying that its my clans fault for not being on every hour to check and see if they got donated gobs in their war castles?! I dont think so, and for the people saying that your castle troops should be your decision, yes it is but you are relying on other clan members to fill them anyways. Adding this feature WILL NOT GIVE ANY POWER TO COs. besides even if it did and u dont trust your leaders/COs then u should find a new clan anyways!

I believe the leader being able to remove and see who donated the troops in question is a good idea. The CO's not so much simply because of the clans that give Co as a reward for donates.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Caguggenmos

You shouldn't have this problem anyway with players that are active. If they aren't active enough to get on and remove bad troops (Which is another problem that shouldn't happen in any decent clan), then maybe they aren't reliable enough to be in your clan. Correct your poor players -- theres no need whatsoever to add more unneccessary power to co-leaders.

---

I wouldn't say so. Think of it like this. You are in an international war clan. A guy plays 4 hours. 2 hours before sleeping and 2 hours after waking up before going to work/school. So you have 8 hours inactive time from that player twice. If the high level player who needs to donate is in different time zone and does his donations during this time of inactivity of other player. Then what if the cc is filled by some low Lvl troops before top player was about to fill it?

Now the prep day ends in 6 hours and you have lvl3 wiz in cc for th8 and you can't have lvl5/6 wiz because some new lowbie member who wanted to just help out clan ends up with an easy 3* on top bases.

Just an example. And this has happened in our clan when a th7 guy who was so eager about war and wanted to help. Filled all cc with drag lvl1 and lvl3 wiz. (New th7) so you can't blame him as he was just trying to help.

We won that war. But that's not the issue. We had easy war, if it was close war we had some 5-6 bases with bad cc and 2 base with no cc as they deleted close to last hour after reading mail and no one was able to donate after.

You can't keep checking every cc in like every hour.

This option of co and leader having would greatly help as its a "CLAN WAR" not some just village defense. You may be OK with lvl3 troops in cc and some don't even have anything written in request. But its a clan co and leader duty to have it filled with best troops if you are slightly serious about winning wars. So people who say its my village and its too much power for co. I can't see how it can be so. Its a "CLAN WAR". Not just your village. Clan management should be able to manage what donations is ok and what is not at least. I don't want to know who donated. It's pretty obvious that its new guy.

I agree with this idea simply because yes, new guys mess up sometimes and give garbage troops in war CC's. Most of the time everyone that gets them removes them but not everyone is able to get on in time to do so.

Leaders and co-leaders too OP??? No... the abilities given to leader and co-leaders are necessary to keep the clan balanced. Yes, some clans might have their "good ol' boys club" where they promote too many co-leaders, or give it away but a solid clan will have few trusted members in higher positions that don't want to ruin a clan or have too many chiefs and not enough Indians. I mean really, we can kick, demote, promote, have the sweet ability to send messages, and modify clan info. How is that OP? That's what leaders are supposed to do! Giving us the ability to replace weak troops with strong defense winning troops is not OP, its a small tactical advantage that could change the outcome of a battle.

Rant over, send the hate mail

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by gibby86

i agree with this idea simply because yes, new guys mess up sometimes and give garbage troops in war cc's. Most of the time everyone that gets them removes them but not everyone is able to get on in time to do so.

Leaders and co-leaders too op??? No... The abilities given to leader and co-leaders are necessary to keep the clan balanced. Yes, some clans might have their "good ol' boys club" where they promote too many co-leaders, or give it away but a solid clan will have few trusted members in higher positions that don't want to ruin a clan or have too many chiefs and not enough indians. I mean really, we can kick, demote, promote, have the sweet ability to send messages, and modify clan info. How is that op? That's what leaders are supposed to do! Giving us the ability to replace weak troops with strong defense winning troops is not op, its a small tactical advantage that could change the outcome of a battle.

Rant over, send the hate mail

---

end of subject