Printable View
As the title says spell damage should not take resources. It should do damage to buildings but take the resources inside. Logically speaking spell damage should not have the ability to carry away resources whereas troop damage would. Also damage done to the Clan Castle building does not kill the troops inside. It the same premise.
Doing damage to storages is how you extract resources from them. The Lightning spell does damage. Therefore spell damage to storages should take resources.Quote:
Originally Posted by lordmayhem
Logic!
Your comment regarding the clan castle is in fact decidedly illogical. It's not like troop damage kills the troops inside either and I think you'd be hard pressed to successfully argue that troop damage to storages shouldn't take resources.
Your respond makes no sense. How is troop damage going to kill the troops inside the clan castle without pulling the troops first? Hence it can't happen. Illogical argument.Quote:
Originally Posted by dahimi
How is spell damage to a building with troops inside that don't damage the troops illogical? If spell damage can damage a resource building enough to take resources inside that building. You argue for one and against the other but they are the same thing. Illogical reply.
And no one said that troops damage should not take resources in fact my statement says they should. But Hey thanks for spamming my post with another illogical reply.
Maybe someone will come along and explain it to you. I tried in the simplest way I know to explain how the way the game currently works with regard to damage is logical and consistent.Quote:
Originally Posted by lordmayhem
i'm acctually in agreeance with him lightning should be use to take out high defences instead of pre-battle lootingQuote:
Originally Posted by dahimi
You guys who want storages to be immune to lightning spells or that there should be a lightning rod are never going to win the argument. What you're basically trying to do is to take away the ability to do damage from something that was created for that one purpose.
Dahimi is correct, it's the castle taking damage regardless if it's lightning spells or troop damage. If you're inside a bunker and somebody's firing bullets at it, you don't get hit the bunker does, exact same for the clan castle.
Quote:
Logically speaking spell damage should not have the ability to carry away resources whereas troop damage would
-Spells can't take resources away
-Dead troops also cannot take resources away
-Argument invalidated
SC themselves have said that they are not doing anything. Get that in your head.
I'm guessing the op is complaining about being zapped for dark lol.. So I'll say this..
There is nothing and I mean nothing, stopping you from doing the same thing to other people. There is also a revenge button. Hit that button. Zap the base right back.
Its not hard people.. Use your heads.
Ok. This has little to do with logic however.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ukoval