Printable View
i hate hopper and i feel there should be a system in place to stop this or people who want to be in a war and never atk or just leave. i feel like their profile should be label as a hopper so people are aware of them. you guy should make it that if you join a clan you must donate like 100 troop before you are able to request and if you leave a clan during a war you shouldnt be able to be in a war for a week. maybe this will stop ppl from hopping
Clan leaders can enforce this as they choose.
As there are specifically join-req-leave clans, I'm sure that not everyone holds your sentiments. Run your clan as you deem fit. If someone rushes into my clan and makes a request, the best they can hope for is archers and barbarians. Demands for dragons, dark elixir troops or things that they are unable to donate to other clan members are ignored, and sometimes these players are just immediately kicked out.
If you are a leader or a co-leader, take a look at the player's "Friend in Need" achievement. It paints a pretty lucid picture when you compare it to the player's level and TH level.
Nah, there's no need for this. If hoppers are a big problem that probably means there are bigger issues with your clan. I can't remember the last time someone joined just to take troops. Missing war attacks.... well, that happens. It's really odd too when someone goes to great lengths to join one of our awesome war clans, which are not easy to get into--we get a lot of applicants and we like to stay at 35 or fewer members, and then doesn't bother attacking. But one person doesn't decide the course of a war. No big deal.
This ^^Quote:
Originally Posted by ilkaisha
To expand on it, with regards to war hoppers, never accept people on war countdown, that's also in their profile. If all clan leaders didn't accept people with low FIN and people with war countdown, then that would send a message to people on how they should or shouldn't play if they want to join clans.
I know this doesn't solve your issue with people not attacking in wars, but then again that can't be solved unless the profile also displays how many wars that player has been in and how many attacks they have performed, and somehow I can't see supercell doing something like that.
Agree to a certain extent that it would be good to have more profile details including how many times people leave mid war without attacking, but this would equally be solved by a stat on how many attacks per war players do. If the number is low then you know they are more likely to ditch a clan mid war.
You can already use your clan description to set a minimum number of donations before they are able to request although this wont stop players hopping.
Best of luck
Friend in need isn't always the best example. I'm in a clan with less then 15 people, and have been for a long time. This means mine will be lower then someone who plays the same amount, but is in a full clan.
To those who say that 1 member shouldn't change the course of a war, I say that you haven't been in a close matchup ever before. When you face a strong war clan, every attack counts. People who join us and immediately request get immediately kicked. The issue of people bailing in war is frustrating, and often we have new members sit out a war or two just to make sure that they will stay loyal. I think that there should be some sort of punishment for war-hopping, but I would rather see more new troops, upgrades, and other important fixes first. There is a band-aid fix, and if you can't make it work, then don't lead a clan.
My full agreement on that, last 3 wars 1 or 2 stars made the difference between a win or loose and therefore every member and every single attack counts!Quote:
Originally Posted by Hypotenuse
It is a real pain when people leave during war. I hope in the future we'll be able to give player reviews as one does on Xbox.Quote:
Originally Posted by IsaiahTorres585
There are two types of hoppers:
there is the one which refuses to engage in any sort of communication
the other one wants - no demands - your attention and leaves suddenly if his/hers demands arent met
But you have to remember that there are so many clans in global begging people to join them, and so many clans to choose from. It might just be a part of clash life you need to accept.
I always kick players with zero donations after a couple of days with the message "no free parking". It also helps to do a bit of a clean up of the clan before war starts.
But most of the time you will see about 5 players who wont participate in war or who leaves. Thats why it's important for everyone to participate and not to make exceptions when kicking those who dont attack twice.
Hope that helps.