Printable View
Dear All,
This is an idea coming from an analysis : Lot of players are not loyal to their Clan. To reduce the Join/Leave effect
it Will be great to develop a feature that allow people to Join/Leave a clan in precise conditions.
Some examples of conditions:
1/ Pay to Join/Leave a clan (example 50k/100k)
2/ Wait for a period to Join/Leave a Clan (1 month or more not less)
3/ 1 minimum fight before moving to another clan.
Many other ideas are welcome !
Please vote to push to devs
thanks
But if you are in an clan were nobody is online and you don`t have enough gold to leave. It`s not good. Ps: one day is ok but one month is too much
People don't stay in clans because they either think the clan is bad and doesn't suit them or they found another better clan.Quote:
Originally Posted by Johnq007
What if the player is a low lvl and can't afford 50k gold just to join and/or leave it?
1 day to a week is quite long if the player is searching for a clan to stay in but 1 month seems a little long.
Imo, this isn't a good idea
Quote:
Originally Posted by Johnq007
It's not always hoppers, some clans are just horrible. This prevents people from finding a suitable clan.
Upgrades cost gold (which I pour all my gold in as well as other players), which will keep people from joining or leaving a clan.
Waiting to leave a clan traps people in a clan. 1 month or a day is too much, some clans aren't a right fit and you join clans to find out until one suits you.
What do you mean by fight? Raid. Some people don't raid except for the beggining of the season and let their defenses do the work while they rely on collectors for upgrades.
Do you mean war by fight? If so some clans never have war. This prevents members from ever leaving.
Thank you for the reply,Quote:
Originally Posted by frmmmblj
According to existing rules (one of the 3 described), you will not have the configuration you are describing because these rules will motivates and keep people connected due to the fact that they paid to be there as you !
I maintain 1 month.
Another argument is This kind of clan(with no one online) will disapear naturally with competition effect.
Keep posted
Thank you for your reply.Quote:
Originally Posted by JJason
Maybe the price IS to high or the Time IS to long, This is to measure with devs team for example. It looks lire 1 week IS a good range, 25k ?
there will Always be exceptions to handle. To Answer your question about Low level players they will need to Work more (Luke up grades It is the same situation)but that Will level up the game and naturally boost and select audience.
keep posting thanks
But I'm in a non warring clan, does this mean I can never leave?
hi !Quote:
Originally Posted by Zannan
by this system lazy Clans will disapear naturally because people will be interested by the succes of their Clans as It is an investment. I assume 1 month could be long. Let us say one week. Fight meant Clan wars ok for your point the third one wars optional.
A compromise :
1/. One week
2/. 25k to Join/Leave
thank you All
Forcing ppl to stay in a clan for any amount of time is bad idea imo. Lets say a player in a clan & cant leave. All he will do is come up with a creative negative way to get kicked. For Example - Donating wrong troops to castle request(wb) profanity derogatory remarks in clan chat.Not attacking in war, rejecting all troops in his war castle, putting his town house outside walls in war, or removing all wall fom defense in war,etc. Trust me bad idea.
Hoppers are easily dealt with I really dont see changes needed. If a player joins for 30minutes or 5minutes & leave no problem. If you see a player not active before wars most likely he will leave once wars start so kick b4 hand. Set your Clan to invite only and quit accepting any & everybody just because they reach your clan requirements & you want a full clan.
Start a poll if you want votes...Quote:
Originally Posted by Johnq007
Also, these are terrible ideas.
1. Who gets the money? SC? If it is a player, than that could be exploited easily, if it is to SC, we dont need more loot gone from the game. Also, moving among clans in a family shouldnt be penalized, nor should req and leave clans be penalized.
2. One month? Again, req and leave + family clans shouldnt be penalized with this stupid rule
3. What if a clan never wars? Or if you are talking about a normal raid, then this is hardly a restriction at all.
Best advice? Keep your clan on invite only and stay active. Maybe if your clan is actually good people will WANT to stay instead of requiring you to think of ways to trap people in your clan
No, if this happens all clans will disappear cause no one will be willing to pay gold to join and leave a clan. Espically th6 and up. (Upgrades get expensive after th6)Quote:
Originally Posted by Johnq007
What if the clan mates bully you. Or the clan lies to get you to join. Request and leave clans. Sometimes clans aren't a good fit.
Quote:
Originally Posted by blackcaesar
I agree with the two quotes above.Quote:
Originally Posted by Benson822175