Trophies as Clan War Loot bonus

Currently War loot is based on winning a single battle with 1 star at least, and if the clan wins.

Adding in Exponential number of trophies based on stars in addition to the loot, can be a great component for aiming for more stars.

If attacked on the enemy at the same position or above in the other clan. For Each Battle:
1 star : 5 trophies
2: start: 25 Trophies
3 star : 125 trophies
Total of 250 trophies in a war : Good enough boost for some one taking 6 stars, he can jump to the next league.

if attacked at a person 1 position lower:
1 star: 4
2 star: 16
3 star: 64 trophies.
Total of 128

if 2 lower: 3, 9 27 , and so on... Total of 54, 3 lower, 2, 4, 8; 4 lower: 1,2,4 .

The number of trophies awarded can be started from 4 for the same level, if the devs think 250 in a war is high.


Also this will only reward some one if he takes at-least 5 stars. taking 4 stars will at max give 50 trophies, which can be earned by usually defeating 2 players in multi player battle.

At 4000 it can take 6 hours to make 5 trophies.

But hey, 250 trophies for 3 starring 2 people seems legit.

Nope.

Then strong players would attack weak players, get the stars and jump up and up and up. Same level doesn't mean it's the same strength. A clan with a super strong number one and super weak others can be matches with a more moderate clan.

Besides the trophy system doesn't work like that. You get the trophies that the defender loses. You lose the trophies that the attacker gets. Thus there are no new trophies created( mostly). So this would destroy that system

And you must be from a low league or something because 25 trophies in Crystal I and above is a lot of work. Even if I were number 2, my opponents number 2 can be 3 starred for 125 trophies ( sooo much reward).

Sorry, it's too unbalanced

I am at 1600 trophies so yes, I didn't considered at the 4000 mark. And it does create trophies.

Just to keep it more balanced, Adding the town-hall level in the equation can balance the equation out. Just like the loot from storage work. If you are town hall level 7 or below, the trophy multiplier will be 5. town hall level 7, it will be 4, town hall level 8 and above it will be 3.

So the max possible is 54 trophies for some one in crystal league and above. (if some one is in lower than town-hall level 8, winning more trophies wont unbalance the game by a lot)

Th trophies will only be awarded if the clan wins and the stars contribute to the victory. So Big players attacking lower members wont be helpful. As it is more probable that it will result in a loss.

Secondly, the Trophies only benefit, if you win a multi player battle. So it will still not unbalance the game.

The position on the war base, doesn't reflects the exact comparison, but its a rough estimate. Also attacking lower members wont give you lot of trophies. A player attacking some one more than 2 places below him will just get you 8 trophies in 2 days. I guess, that is reasonable enough for 6 war stars (Contributing to victory).

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by saad749

Secondly, the Trophies only benefit, if you win a multi player battle. So it will still not unbalance the game.

---

How so? Arent you getting this from clan wars?

And I didn't say it would unbalance the game, it would disrupt the current trophy system completely. This is why Supercell can't refund trophies for any reason. To implement this, you would need to rework the entire trophy system.
It is too much work on supercell's part.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by EmeraldRange

How so? Arent you getting this from clan wars?

And I didn't say it would unbalance the game, it would disrupt the current trophy system completely. This is why Supercell can't refund trophies for any reason. To implement this, you would need to rework the entire trophy system.
It is too much work on supercell's part.

---

You will get trophy from the clan war, but the main benefit of trophies is the loot bonus you get by winning a multi player battle. right?

Although it will make an inflow of trophies, and increase the current maximum level of trophies, which has been hovering at 4000 level. But, In my opinion, it will bring more interest into the game.

Yes, it will be a lot of work, but I dont mind, if we get this in next 3-6 months. It will stop the top players from getting bored, and can allow them to get away from the game for some time and return, not to have lost tooo much ground against the competition. The competition would have progressed, but they wouldn't have lost too much, and can recover with a little less work.

The main reward being the league bonus is true. more trophy being always positive isnt true, if I put you in the 4000s range, your loot and base would be ravaged easily (same goes for me and many other players).

Furthermore, there are clans who choose not to participate in war (or war infrequently) and this would be encouraging them to fight regularly. supercell would like to keep clan war an option and keep the pressure to war be low. This is found in Supercell's explanation of clan wars on Help and Support.

War is also meant to be seperate from the main multiplayer as your shield is not broken and you gain no trophies (currently)

Example: For the moment, as we are pushing, my clan has stopped its clan wars for a month. After the first day after the announcement, nobody complained (except new members).

And town hall limiting of loot suggestion could encourage extreme trophy pushers (such as town hall 6's in Crystal to just win wars and advance really easily). By doing this penalty by league, we would upset farmers as they would have to remain useless in war to stay in low leagues.


With that being said, personally I would be thrilled to get easy trophies :D

Well, As far as farming is concerned, Losing trophies is easy and also gives chance to explore more things, as you can easily lose trophies, without the fear to lose ur hard earned trophies. I went up to 2200 trophies, and then came down to 1000 for looting.

And lev 6 trophy pushers, In and after crystal league, I personally find being way too ahead in league relative to your town hall is just plain bad idea, and you lose more than you gain. Also it will be 50- 64 trophies in 2 days. So Not a big difference for biased play strategies.


For myself, I try to balance things, out, Gold league 1/ Silver league 3 being appropriate for TH 7, CL 1/GL 1/ GL 2 appropriate for TH 8 and so on... For me it will be additional motivation to go for 3 stars in clan wars, then just get a single star and be content with the loot bonus.


Although, if Supercell doesn't wants to give much attention to wars, and keep them separate, its an entirely different scenario.

Personally, I have found wars a lot more engaging and interesting. You get to play as a team, have continuous conversation, and it keeps you from getting bored, as every war provides you with a unique experience. Our Clan is constantly in war. A war ends and we start a new one.

Multi player battles can be more rewarding, but the randomness, and an army that will probably not match for most of them, gets boring over time. But this is my personal opinion.

I think having more dimensions in the game, will make it more interesting and make people with different play styles feel more interested.