Rushing!

Aside from the donations skewing the xp, isn't it easier to just look at their defenses and troop levels? If they have stuff that was not maxed at their previous TH level, then they rushed. Easy.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by STEVENX

Exactly my point

---

3000 xp is a level ok we remove donations from the equation...what if we take lifetime donations multiply it by 0.003 and subtract it from level and then start again at step 1...this would remove donations?

its a good point and worth discussing and thx for the input

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by FireSauce

Aside from the donations skewing the xp, isn't it easier to just look at their defenses and troop levels? If they have stuff that was not maxed at their previous TH level, then they rushed. Easy.

---

ok fair point but how do you quantify it? who is more rushed then whom? and what level of rush will you take?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by badfish1979

Experience level is not a good indicator of how rushed or on par a base is since donations give experience.

---

ok whats a good way to get a number? to quantify it?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by STEVENX

Well that just made me laugh.

There is a player named SneakyDave that I saw on global who is currently lv250+ mostly from donations. Heck, I'm lv102 and I haven't been playing that long on my main account at all.

---

Ok lets see what the number comes up with for you ? whats your th level?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by David5751

ok fair point but how do you quantify it? who is more rushed then whom? and what level of rush will you take?

---

I guess that one's up to the clan leadership, but if the prospect is kind of questionable, I like to let em in, and see if they make up for their mild rushing. Because skill, donating, chat quality (subjective, I know), all play a part.

As a weird example, a guy in my old clan maxed each level, but once he got TH8, he rushed TH9 pretty hard, in order to unlock the queen and xbows. He then farmed hardcore and basically maxed TH9 in a few months. So, I'd probably let that guy in XD

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by FireSauce

I guess that one's up to the clan leadership, but if the prospect is kind of questionable, I like to let em in, and see if they make up for their mild rushing. Because skill, donating, chat quality (subjective, I know), all play a part.

As a weird example, a guy in my old clan maxed each level, but once he got TH8, he rushed TH9 pretty hard, in order to unlock the queen and xbows. He then farmed hardcore and basically maxed TH9 in a few months. So, I'd probably let that guy in XD

---

I don't disagree at all. We have a few who's number has dipped. I'm not in any way suggesting how each clan should interpret the number. I'm just saying it quantifies it (rush/max) with errors as ya'll pointed out. But better then anything else I've seen. The taking donations out of the equation isn't difficult and we need to look at that for sure.
Good feedback and thanks

TH9 lvl 106.

9*9 = 81

81 - 106 = -25

-25 / 9 = -2.7...

Did I pass? :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by elpresidente47

TH9 lvl 106.

9*9 = 81

81 - 106 = -25

-25 / 9 = -2.7...

Did I pass? :)

---

it should have been 2.7 ..its xp minus step one..either I posted wrong or you did math wrong..oops
subtract the number "from step 1 from the xp points"
106-81=25 ?
25/9=2.7

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by elpresidente47

TH9 lvl 106.

9*9 = 81

106-81 = 25

25 / 9 = 2.7...

:)

---

my question is with 3 being full max does that number sound about right in your honest opinion?