Printable View
My idea is simple. For any clan in any war, when every attack is used, war loot is doubled, whether the war is won or lost.
I think this would be all kinds of good. It would be more loot, which everyone likes, and it would encourage people to use both attacks every time. My clan has participated in over 50 wars, and only once have we ever had perfect attendance, and our opponents never have. And I think that's sad.
Thoughts?
That's a great idea!
People in my clan almost never attack even though they are online almost all the time. That would make it so you'd want to attack regularly because it would be good for you and your whole team.
double seems a little too much
Double is a lot, but having every single attack used in war is a very rare thing. I think doubling war loot is a great incentive to make every want to use their attacks, rather than hop or not use an attack to save Elixir.Quote:
Originally Posted by ChiefJoshuaCOC
As with any idea, the numbers could obviously be tweaked, but I believe double is fair
I'm all for incentive. Getting everyone to attack in the first place is hard, getting them to attack twice is worth double loot.
I don't think there should be a bonus for everyone using both attacks. I see too many ppl getting kicked for not using an attack so everyone else gets penalized for it?
Example: 10 x 10 war
My clan uses 18 attacks 3 starring every base for a total of 30 stars. Say the first 9 guys attack twice. The last guy leaves before the war is over not using any of his attacks.
Opposing clan uses all 20 attacks and get 29 stars in the.
My clan doesn't get the bonus bc some guy left in the middle of wars? Then the opposing clan gets double the loot bc they used all attacks. I think it's unbalanced, good idea but even if the bonus was say an extra 20% it's not worth the problems.
This situation is exactly the sort of thing this idea is meant to deter. If you have a perfect score and people still have attacks left, they should be excited! It gives them a chance to try to attack high and gain some extra war loot for getting a star. If they leave, then yes, your clan loses out on the double bonus, but if you're going to win, then I would hope that every member would want to stick around and try to double their loot. This game is about playing as a team, so yes, one bad apple can ruin the clan war double loot bonusQuote:
Originally Posted by SNasian
Also, yes, the losing clan would get double loot, but double loot for a losing clan is still significantly less than non-doubled loot for a winning clan.
See that's a great idea but my only concern is loot balance. I'm sure it will affect it somehow causing problems in the performance of both clans.
I like the idea but the numbers need to be worked on.. It would give everyone an incentive to actually use both their attacks.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tiler
Well...again, even with this implemented, I would imagine this bonus would be quite rare. I don't really see why it would negatively affect the performance of each clan though, so if you could describe what you mean by that, I can account for that in my OPQuote:
Originally Posted by ElecTroShowK69