A troops received counter.

Just like we have a counter that indicates how many troops you have donated to your clanmates, there should be a troops received counter as well.

The purpose of this idea is to detect those clan hoppers that simply request and leave. I know this is not much of an issue at high levels, but at lower levels, people join our clan only to requests troops and leave. Our clan is invite only, and we do add only TH7+ now. But still some TH8 joins us, requests for troops and as soon as he gets them, leaves the clan.

Any clan hopper that donates is always welcome, but those who don't and only leech other clans are not. A counter that indicates how many troops a person has received vs how many that person has donated would be awesome.

Feedback requested.

Nah just make them donate 100 troops before they can donate. Problem solved

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bukie

Nah just make them donate 100 troops before they can donate. Problem solved

---

Will it work?

New member: Hello all
Clan Member: Welcome
New member: Archers or anything good (0/20)
Clan member: Our policy is, you donate 100 troops first before you receive any.
New member: I need some CC troops as I will be logging off and I also have some loot in my storages
Clan member: Nope, you won't get any - not until you donate 100.
New member: has left the clan

Now he may be a genuinely good guy who donates, we don't know. It's the reason we need that counter.

This is a very good solution to hoppers without changing the game. I like it. :)

Dont we already have a troops received stat? If it says ZERO that means they havent donated squat. What am i missing here?

When u jump clans ur counter goes bak to zero. He wants it to stay showing all the time

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AxionXD

Dont we already have a troops received stat? If it says ZERO that means they havent donated squat. What am i missing here?

---

Within the clan, yes. It gets reset every season. What is being suggested is something like the friend in need achievement to count received troops through out your time on clash.

My clan has a rule to prevent this: Donate 20 troops before requesting.
If a player joins and immediately requests troops, then he gets kicked.

No stats which can be percieved as negative will ever be public similar to attacks lost, and also the game most likely doesnt count it so it would start from zero.

What if the clan Leader (and perhaps COs as well) could set requirements for how many troops someone new to the clan would have to donate before they were able to request troops? Perhaps the requirement options could be something like 5, 10, 15 or 20.

I wouldn't think being able to require something much above 20 (before they could then start requesting troops) would be all that good really.

Just low requirements to help ensure that people joining understand that being a part of a clan should require your contribution / donating to help your fellow clan mates and promote more even exchange.

What do you guys think?

Just check the life time donation compare it to Town hall level/Level. and Voila you have an idea of who your dealing with :)

The problem with that is my clan doesn't request a hole lot of troops so if it ever fell apart it would look like im not very active/don't donate.

I think they should just make a anti-clan-hopping rule lol

Something like: If you leave a clan, you have to wait 12-24 hours to join another one (Depending on the last time you left a clan). This way people will eventually stop hopping and stick to a clan they like.

Also, it might stop people from scouting the enemy war bases while in preparation mode.

PS: I know it's easier to set the clan to closed during preparation days (our clan does this)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by vekool

Will it work?

New member: Hello all
Clan Member: Welcome
New member: Archers or anything good (0/20)
Clan member: Our policy is, you donate 100 troops first before you receive any.
New member: I need some CC troops as I will be logging off and I also have some loot in my storages
Clan member: Nope, you won't get any - not until you donate 100.
New member: has left the clan

Now he may be a genuinely good guy who donates, we don't know. It's the reason we need that counter.

---

That was civilized. We get cussed and stuff before they go. That has us not feeling to concerned that they went though so I guess its a good thing.

A '100 before you request' might be a bit steep. What if you did as you describe but shortened it to just a donate first rule. They join and they need to fill a request before they get anything. And if they give 2 barbs then request. Give them 2 barbs back, it s fair. if they show up and give a dragon give a dragon back. Even if yours is higher level I think they showed enough spirit. But in any event, have them give first, any amount, then mirror in what you give back, After a couple to a few days you can get looser about it with him too.

Its not foolproof, here is an exchange how they sometimes come in our world.

Clan Member: Welcome
New member: Dragon
Clan Member: Uh, hi
New member: Dragon
Clan Member: We have a donate first rule here
New member: I promise I will donate but I need a dragon
Clan Member: Understood, you can have one after you have donated first
New member: Pleeeeze, I really need a dragon right away.
Clan Member: I will be happy to give you one after you follow our clan policy
New member: Pleeeeeeeeeze, I need it now, Its an emergency.
Clan Member: Oh, is someone dying?
New member: %&*! you you %&*!ing $&*!
New member: has left the clan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mike182bcr

When u jump clans ur counter goes bak to zero. He wants it to stay showing all the time

---

Hi, all. New here, have been playing 8 months, now co-leader. Everytime I look at a requests profile, I wish I could see that. It should stay with the player thru the league season, across clans.

i don't want to kick someone just for requesting troops.

Thanks for letting me add my voice. :-).

Merry Christmas.:-)

Not a bad idea having it when a person leaves a clan they must wait before joining a new clan. But I have a few problems with that one. Sometimes when I join a clan even if I have been there for some time what if I want to leave? After I leave I want a new clan but I have to wait a day or 12 hours. Make it when you leave and join new clans often ,which will be defined by supercell, will have the 12 or so hours of no clan to enjoy.


"strategy without tactics is the slowest route to victory. tactics without strategy is the noise before defeat"
-Sun Tzu

Please don't revive dead threads.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by vekool

Will it work?

New member: Hello all
Clan Member: Welcome
New member: Archers or anything good (0/20)
Clan member: Our policy is, you donate 100 troops first before you receive any.
New member: I need some CC troops as I will be logging off and I also have some loot in my storages
Clan member: Nope, you won't get any - not until you donate 100.
New member: has left the clan

Now he may be a genuinely good guy who donates, we don't know. It's the reason we need that counter.

---

Then maybe just 20 troops or something and no giants.

good idea perfect

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Alex78

My clan has a rule to prevent this: Donate 20 troops before requesting.
If a player joins and immediately requests troops, then he gets kicked.

---

What he said

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gama321

No stats which can be percieved as negative will ever be public similar to attacks lost, and also the game most likely doesnt count it so it would start from zero.

---

This is correct. Although it is not expressly lsted in the ruled out list anything that violates SCs stated policies is considered ruled out without needing to be itemized on the list.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by vekool

Will it work?

New member: Hello all
Clan Member: Welcome
New member: Archers or anything good (0/20)
Clan member: Our policy is, you donate 100 troops first before you receive any.
New member: I need some CC troops as I will be logging off and I also have some loot in my storages
Clan member: Nope, you won't get any - not until you donate 100.
New member: has left the clan

Now he may be a genuinely good guy who donates, we don't know. It's the reason we need that counter.

---

This was stupid. If a guy joins your clan and his first focus is getting troops without any interest in giving any then you have your answer right there. The situations where that will actually be a good guy are going to be very rare.

Here is what would be acceptable and what the 'genuinely good guy' should have figured out to do if he was in fact a genuinely god guy..

New member: Hello all
Clan Member: Welcome
New member: Can I get something for defense? I have loot to protect.
Clan member: Our policy is, you donate troops first before you receive any.
New member: That's cool. I figured as much so I made stuff to give out to show my good intent, please request.
Clan member: Thanks, if you need a defense we are happy to help, please request.
New member: Thanks.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bukie

Nah just make them donate 100 troops before they can donate. Problem solved

---

What???:rolleyes:

Donate before you donate....cool...

Actually we dont mind hoppers too much..

I actually instruct our members to request as often as the game allows them. That is to not waste the every 15 minute donation perk.

The reason is to help us out in the friends in need.

What I am guilty though is hopping to strange clans while my barracks are boosted pumping giants endlessly, then donating them to whatever requests I see

I have my feeder clan to assist in wars... :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by iDrakon

I think they should just make a anti-clan-hopping rule lol

Something like: If you leave a clan, you have to wait 12-24 hours to join another one (Depending on the last time you left a clan). This way people will eventually stop hopping and stick to a clan they like.

Also, it might stop people from scouting the enemy war bases while in preparation mode.

PS: I know it's easier to set the clan to closed during preparation days (our clan does this)

---

All hoppers should be educated of a clan called "Req n ♥♥♥♥"