Printable View
I think CoC should allow upgrading heroes to be used when attacking in wars. They allow defenses and heroes to be used on the defensive side while upgrading or building, why not allow them to be used for attacking as well?!
Agree, disagree? Please let me know your thoughts.
Thoughts?......
My thoughts? No!
Defenses are able to def your village in cw ye, but spell factory, laboratory and barracks aren't able to use for attacking... The King/queen (I think) does def your base however they're getting upgraded!
Fair enough. I just think your BK/AQ are so vital to an attack that they should be available even while upgrading. The spell facotry/lab/barracks only have a few upgrades until maxed so that isn't a big deal. The BK/AQ have 40 levels to upgrade, so you can't compare the two as they are apples and oranges. I didn't quite understand your last sentence, sorry.Quote:
Originally Posted by Dunghaufen
Well, there are different opinions about this...Quote:
Originally Posted by stormsendben
To my last sentence: (sorry, I'm not an english guy, look at my location)
I mean, that heros are able to def your base in cw while upgrading! So they behave like other defenses in defense!
I understand it, I just think they should always be available in clan wars on the attacking and defending side. That's just my personal opinion. I want to get more views on this, so please comment and share your thoughts.Quote:
Originally Posted by Dunghaufen
Bump.............................
100% agree, it's lopsided that they are there for def bunt for attacking. Severely cramps who you can target, especially when going against developed th10s.
Great! That was my thinking entirely. If I am without my BK I literally lose about 10-15% damage per attack on a developed TH10. And considering there are 40 freaking levels to upgrade I will be without my BK for quite some time as I am doing back to back upgrades on him and my AQ.Quote:
Originally Posted by blaugh
Bump.....................
bump..........
Seriously, only two people have opinions on this?
Bump...................
There's one key fact that you've forgotten in making this point: upgrades don't exist in Clan Wars.Quote:
Originally Posted by Dunghaufen
You have to remember that Clan Wars occurs, effectively, on a different plane or dimension of the game than your regular base; hence, you can alter your war base without affecting your normal one. Clan Wars doesn't take into account your defensive upgrades, as part of that branch of the game, which is why they are all active. The fact that Heroes are still defending in CW even while they are upgrading on your home base has no bearing on your argument, that they should be available for all attacks while upgrading.
To which I also say no. Any building that contributes to offense (Barracks, Spell Factory, and I include heroes) must shut down in order to upgrade. It's a natural cost of improvement. Think of this like moving a propane tank from one grill to a newer, nicer grill; you can absolutely do it, but the old grill can't still function after you remove the tank to power the nicer grill.
Quote:
Originally Posted by stormsendben
Quote:
Originally Posted by stormsendben
Quote:
Originally Posted by stormsendben
Quote:
Originally Posted by stormsendben
Quote:
Originally Posted by stormsendben
First of all have you read the stickies!? NO BUMPINGQuote:
Originally Posted by stormsendben
second, this is a "new troop and spell ideas" forum, this post is not about a new troop or a new spell. It belongs elsewhere so please just let the thread die or delete the original post.