Clan Loyalty

As a clan leader, I sometimes find it hard to make the clan's members loyal. I also I have very little options if i want to reward my loyal friends who have always been here since forever. Of course, reinforcements can be very beneficial for attacking and defending but other clans can also provide the same benefit. So why loyal?

The current clan concept lacks the ability to make the members specially benefit from their loyalty so they should choose to be loyal to the clan.

I suggest ideas like a clan loyalty bonus, so the longer one stays in the clan, the better they will be rewarded somehow. Loot like in the league? Specially upgraded clan castle to hold more troops or 'defend' the village during raids? Faster troop request cool down? Daily rewards like free spells or a special troop?

Clan hoppers are really common, they are everywhere and they are just simply annoying. Some came in and disrupt the donating flow of the clan by donating junk troops. Some came in and use inappropriate language to others then just leave right away, I know there's a report button in this game but this is seriously common and seriously annoying.

So, just something to make them want to stay loyal to their clan would work well to improve the clan chemistry and of course, providing better opportunity to improve the clan system in the future.



I hope CoC will reconsider my suggestion.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Yuttarach

As a clan leader, I sometimes find it hard to make the clan's members loyal. I also I have very little options if i want to reward my loyal friends who have always been here since forever. Of course, reinforcements can be very beneficial for attacking and defending but other clans can also provide the same benefit. So why loyal?

The current clan concept lacks the ability to make the members specially benefit from their loyalty so they should choose to be loyal to the clan.

I suggest ideas like a clan loyalty bonus, so the longer one stays in the clan, the better they will be rewarded somehow. Loot like in the league? Specially upgraded clan castle to hold more troops or 'defend' the village during raids? Faster troop request cool down? Daily rewards like free spells or a special troop?

Clan hoppers are really common, they are everywhere and they are just simply annoying. Some came in and disrupt the donating flow of the clan by donating junk troops. Some came in and use inappropriate language to others then just leave right away, I know there's a report button in this game but this is seriously common and seriously annoying.

So, just something to make them want to stay loyal to their clan would work well to improve the clan chemistry and of course, providing better opportunity to improve the clan system in the future.



I hope CoC will reconsider my suggestion.

---

Supercell can't make an endless series of blind dates productive. Have a screening process.

Reward your lifers by encouraging them to stay, by donating and having fun in the chat. Kick the others. Don't judge your success by turnover or your ability to keep a near-full 50 members.

I don't think SC should accept responsibility for in-game fixes to solve the problem that could be mitigated effectively by clan leaders who try.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MoriartyLives

Supercell can't make an endless series of blind dates productive. Have a screening process.

Reward your lifers by encouraging them to stay, by donating and having fun in the chat. Kick the others. Don't judge your success by turnover or your ability to keep a near-full 50 members.

I don't think SC should accept responsibility for in-game fixes to solve the problem that could be mitigated effectively by clan leaders who try.

---

I'm advising that there should have been a better cause for a member to stay loyal. Some clans provide eldership to nearly everyone ( -.-' ) which ruins what eldership should have meant.

Honestly, I don't understand most of what you were talking about xD .

I do think that loyalty is a good idea, then it can really have a team spirit in clan

I'm surprise that the game didn't think about that in the first place.

You're invited to our clan, lol.

The hoppers keeps increasing in amount.. This has to be stop, somehow.

I actually think this is a really good idea. Some sort of reward for staying in the same clan for a long time should be good. It will most likely lower the amount of clan hoppers.

Something like a little siggy in your name should even suffice.

I like the idea behind this, but will leave the specifics to others. For a game called Clash of Clans, there's not much clan clashing going on. There needs to be more to clans than donating troops.

I'm guessing a lot of the clan hopping occurs because the clan chat doesn't suit them for one reason or another. There's just not a lot to hold you to a specific clan atm.

Yes, Clash of Clans, there should be something more to do with the 'Clan'. I think this should be looked into before any other contents of the game: Teamwork.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Yuttarach

I'm advising that there should have been a better cause for a member to stay loyal. Some clans provide eldership to nearly everyone ( -.-' ) which ruins what eldership should have meant.

Honestly, I don't understand most of what you were talking about xD .

---

Yes, I too dislike providing eldership to nearly everyone, but I do (in this instance) the very thing I dislike, and I reject the reasons given for not doing it because of the way things are structured. I am limited in my ability on how much power I can give an elder, and because of that, our precious and carefully selected God-tested long term elders can and sometimes do go rouge on us, and in doing so, they can wipe out a clan. As a leader, I do not simply give away eldership (it has to be earned), but I make it easy to earn, and because of my awesomeness in the way I do things, not only do I make up for the limitations of this game, I protect my people--we'll, except for those that come in, say nothing, and donate about as much.

Why would Supercell care if people stay in one clan, or not? I don't see a point in Supercell giving some clan loyalty reward when clan loyalty doesn't benefit Supercell in any way. They don't care what clan you're in, as long as your playing.

It's not like loyalty to a clan gives them any profit.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by chrisnastybro

Why would Supercell care if people stay in one clan, or not? I don't see a point in Supercell giving some clan loyalty reward when clan loyalty doesn't benefit Supercell in any way. They don't care what clan you're in, as long as your playing.

It's not like loyalty to a clan gives them any profit.

---

It's not always the direct benefits that matter; sometimes, the indirect benefits can be just as important. You said it yourself, "as long as [you're] playing." A happy clan (a clan with happy members) are more likely to stick around longer than they might otherwise than if members remain unable to find a more fulfilling sense of enjoyment with the game.

If you have an issue with clan loyalty it means your clan is less attractive to your clan mates than other options. You should address that.

Interesting... not a bad idea. I don't know how it would effect feeder clan systems... but interesting nonetheless.

Happy Clashing!

Clan loyalty~

One of the only things we can do as leaders is try to control elder status, and there are fundamental flaws with that. Since there is only one flat level for elder status, you either have it or don't, and there are no configurable options for it. I don't think any 'elder' should be able to grant any member elder status. That doesn't make sense. That would be like your manager promoting you to manager along with him. That's not how any organization in the world works.

I'll be honest, because of this above, I tend to keep all of my clanmates with elder status. The reason for this is because new members will come in, and since anyone in the clan who is elder can promote them, when they ask for elder someone tends to do it without thinking first, and I can't tell you how many times that new elder has turned around and kicked out all non elders in the entire clan. Since I can't stop people from promoting others to elder, I keep everyone at elder to prevent these trouble makers from destroying my clan.

A new feature around this would be great. Maybe 2 tiers to elder? Tier 1 elder can invite members in and kick members out, but no promotions. Tier 2 can promote members to Tier 1 elder, demote Tier 1 elders, or kick out members. Only Leader can promote all, kick out all, etc. and because this is fairly limiting if the leader doesn't sign on ALL of the time, maybe because they have a day job or some other non-CoC responsibilities, create an official co-leader type role with options as to what that person can do.

If you did this it would be an amazing difference in being leader of a clan.

And last thing: thank you for implementing a clan message function. Now that we have that, can we either open up the number of characters allowed in it, or at the least, allow for more frequent messaging? And why not allow for individual clanmate messages? As leader, I want to be able to lay down the law, but I don't always want to call someone out in front of the entire clan, and at present time, that is my only option.