Do you accept premature Town Halls in your clan?

for us is more important what troop level they have, as long as they are active and donate, a premature TH is not so important because we will try to help them. We can't force them, the only thing we do is to warn about the penalty of a premature TH.

Yup i thought you were meant to upgrade TH as soon as possible and thought others didn't just because they couldn't be bothered saving.. I now regret it so much.

I think the only good thing about my base is the lvl 5 troops and lvl 6 morts...
as you see in my sig i have a new account now :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DAMO7

I think the only good thing about my base is the lvl 5 troops and lvl 6 morts...
as you see in my sig i have a new account now :)

---

At TH7 you can only have level 4 troops and level 5 mortars.

It varies from between peeps and I wonder what u guys hv in mind as the definition of premature th 9

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Aussi

It varies from between peeps and I wonder what u guys hv in mind as the definition of premature th 9

---

Walls lower than 6, defences (cannons/archers) 7 or lower, mortars 4/5 or lower level 3/4 troops, bad levels for basics(spell factory, barracks etc..)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheConfuzed1

As long as they're active and donate, what do you care?

---

Yes. And, of course, having lv6 troops helps a lot;)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Alticus

Nothing, that's my point. I've seen some clans really strict on it though, farming ones included.
This is for entry though, its fair enough for clans to tell their members not to upgrade town hall.

---

Specifically....

Well as a matter of fact we in loyalty dont . This is because a premature th says a lot of things about the person in game and related to his personality .
He is a pretty noob player and at 2700 can't survive with a premature th lol
2. It explains his inconsistency in the game either he was new bought gems and gemmed his th or he was impatient and couldn't wait to max out this also shows he dosent have a lot of time to play coc and hence not that active.
i think those reasons are enough ;) though there can be loads more .

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Alticus

I was wondering what the general consensus was as to premature THs in your clan?
Premature TH is about the worst trap you can fall into in game. I confess, my clan has heaps (as in like 20) TH 8's that probably shouldn't be there. The rest is made up of proper TH 8s and 7s. We have no TH 9s, but I have made so many people cancel their TH. On occasion I have threatened people by saying I will kick them if they don't cancel.

Its not fun being the killjoy, but they thank me later. The thing is, I always just assumed people who rush their TH to have an IQ of 3 and aren't really serious about the game. But I found out that we have really intelligent people ie: bankers, an anthropologist, who are pretty badly rushed. They just assume they should upgrade as soon as possible because no-one
has told them anything to suggest otherwise. And therin lies the problem.

Supercell should, (as has been requested many times),put a message in the description of the TH saying it is advisable to max out before upgrading. As well as reinforcing this message, I want to ask what other clans policy is for rushed TH? My clan has become partly a recuperation clinic/ school where I give out info on upgrade orders and base designs all the time. That's not to say we don't have normal fun conversations as well :). I give all but the most terrible TH 9s a chance in my clan, but I was wondering what other people think. Do you let rushed TH's in your clan? Assuming that they are mature and donate a lot, but may have pretty bad troops.

Alticus (sorry about the lack of paragraphing)

---

Premature TH is not an issue, how a person recovers from this is a key factor.

In my main account I skipped TH7 ( waits for Dahimi to faint ) but if you look at my base you can see it really made no difference other than the length of time of farming.

In my mini, Im fully maxing TH7 for that gaming experience despite calls from the leader and elders to hurry to TH8 and archies level 5.

Premature TH is not an issue - however, I would not be comfortable 'telling' someone to cancel an expensive upgrade such as TH, each person plays this game differently though but prem TH is recoverable !

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tiny

Premature TH is not an issue, how a person recovers from this is a key factor.

In my main account I skipped TH7 ( waits for Dahimi to faint ) but if you look at my base you can see it really made no difference other than the length of time of farming.

In my mini, Im fully maxing TH7 for that gaming experience despite calls from the leader and elders to hurry to TH8 and archies level 5.

Premature TH is not an issue - however, I would not be comfortable 'telling' someone to cancel an expensive upgrade such as TH, each person plays this game differently though but prem TH is recoverable !

---

I skipped TH7 as well. This was pre loot penalty. I was not happy when the loot penalty was added.