Clan Wars Ranking System

I was thinking with the introduction of clan wars, a lot of people having been playing it, but there are still people who don't like the clan war system.

I have a proposal to add a ranking system for clan wars (like League of Legends). This will add a huge incentive for other clans who aren't totally into clan wars to get into it and also something for the current clans to work together on to become more competitive.

1. Add a Clan War ranking system.

2. Clans must have at least 5-10 CW's to be placed into a league.

3. The higher the clans are in their league, the higher the bonus loot becomes

at the end of each CW based on their clan's ranking number in the league.

4. The clan gets a bonus award also depending on the league they're in at the
end of each season, but those clans must reach a certain rank.

5. I was also thinking there should be some kind of promotion to get out
of their league, either like LoL or something different, something to challenge clans
before they can rank up, or maybe match up clans in the higher league to see if they qualify.

6. I just though about this and I believe there should be some kind of loot penalty in case some clans try to abuse the system for very high level clans who try to drop their ranks on purpose and get easy cw's. This would prevent those clans from benefiting if they were to drop in rank to find easier cw's and would help balance the ranking system.

(Like a milestone, like reaching gold and higher for those of you who play).

I also think it would be nice if there are options for some players to opt out of cw, because maybe their spell factories are down or their heroes are down and it's kind of a hassle to have to boot them and
re-invite them later before searching for a cw.

One of the awards for the milestone for clans could be something like new clan war icons.

Clan War points can also be spent towards a clan donation bank / vault. It is limited just like the clan castle, but can be upgraded. Also Lead and Co-lead should have the option of dictating which units are allowed to be donated in it so that people can't abuse it or troll and donate only goblins into it. It should also have a blank space next to it so Co-lead and Lead can put in the unit's minimum level required to donate in there. This will also help speed up clan donations.

So what do you guys think? I would appreciate some feedback on this idea.

Sounds good. This will make little kids rage even harder in cw. This means an increase of gem sells supercell.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ChrisVu

Sounds good. This will make little kids rage even harder in cw. This means an increase of gem sells supercell.

---

It will cause kids to rage quit, therefore decreasing Supercell's profits.

How would it decrease sells when it encourages competitive play? Like when Clan wars were introduced, people started gemming more to increase defense for cw, or to boost troops to donate for cw defense, as well as boost barracks to get in their attacks. I think this would be beneficial for supercell.

That is an awesome idea.
clan wars will be way more challenging and you are more likly to get an opponent of your level.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by evgi

That is an awesome idea.
clan wars will be way more challenging and you are more likly to get an opponent of your level.

---

Ya I agree, some matchups are just really unfair or too easy lol.

Seems fine to me

That is a great idea

Wait until SC rewards top 3 with gems.... and then it's just gonna be unfair and such...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bresn

Wait until SC rewards top 3 with gems.... and then it's just gonna be unfair and such...

---

lol I don't think they should reward people with gems, just loot. I think what would be cool is if clans can earn new clan icons as a reward. That would be cool

daily bump

hi guys

i am also a frequent League of Legends player, i do feel (and my clan mates) that clash could benefit greatly from a war ranking process like this. We have noticed that most members tend to do war just for the sake of the loot and not the significance of the win. We and I'm sure many other clashers would greatly appreciate it if more significance was given to war other than the loot and the near meaningless win count in the clan description.

We also feel that players just get higher up levels of the game just because of using gems - theres no skill in using gems in that sense-at all..... War ranking at least adds some element of competition as well as an element of clan strategy and will make the game more enjoyable and interesting for experienced gamers as well as new gamers.

PLEASE SUPERCELL - hear us out! THIS IS MORE IMPORTANT THAN SKELETON TRAPS FOR HALLOWEEN.........

another note.... please opt in/out for war...again... more needed than skeleton defence traps...o.o

Will the leauge of each clan restart with every season or will they stay at the rank they were before the season ended?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Guzman2517

Will the leauge of each clan restart with every season or will they stay at the rank they were before the season ended?

---

I think that the league of each clan should still be kept, but still evaluated hence the loot bonus / award at the end of each season. Making the league of each clan restart after every season kind of defeats the purpose of climbing into a higher league. It's kind of how the current Clash of Clans works after each season, they have you attack to evaluate which league you're in.

Sure I want it.

No, I don't get the point of this at all

To increase competition, promote clan paricipation, balance loot distribution and matchups (my clan never lost a cw btw), and give incentives for clans to work towards a common goal and season awards meaning clans need to be consistent.

Updated with more clan awards idea such as the donation bank which can be purchased by clan war points from wins.

I love it!!
Please do this supercell!!!

I can see your points but I doubt it will have the full affect you want/think.

For example - the majority of people that dont like wars - dont like them for a variety of reasons but mostly they do not like the loot in them. Or they do not like all the dram and kicking that goes along with wars. Your system only makes it worse and will in fact stop even more people from warring.

I am typically paired with an opponent that offers me 350k each of gold and elixir and usually something around 850 DE. That was before the recent boost so its probably closer to 425 each and 1000 DE. A dragon army with 4 rage spells runs me about 550k elxir. A hog army with heal spells runs me over 2000 DE and 130K elixir. *IF* I win - I lose on either elixir, DE or both. Yeah - the gold is good but not worth the hassle and loss of other resources. If I lose - well - obviously its a massive loss in loot. None of that counts the many many troops I donate which may be another 400k in elixir and hundreds in DE. And a war mostly ties me up for much of the 2 day war as I am not attacking so much but building troops

If I raid for 2 hours solid using an army composition that costs me about 60k elixir each raid - I can usually find an average base of 200k each and probably an average of 400 DE. In two hours I can do about 10 of them for a net gain of about 1.5 million each gold/elixir and 4k DE. All without any war drama.

Do the math - wars are a waste of resources, time and frustration. Your proposal will not really help that and for people like me - only makes it even less likely we will war more than we do now - which is once a month strictly for fun.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by gamul1

I can see your points but I doubt it will have the full affect you want/think.

For example - the majority of people that dont like wars - dont like them for a variety of reasons but mostly they do not like the loot in them. Or they do not like all the dram and kicking that goes along with wars. Your system only makes it worse and will in fact stop even more people from warring.

I am typically paired with an opponent that offers me 350k each of gold and elixir and usually something around 850 DE. That was before the recent boost so its probably closer to 425 each and 1000 DE. A dragon army with 4 rage spells runs me about 550k elxir. A hog army with heal spells runs me over 2000 DE and 130K elixir. *IF* I win - I lose on either elixir, DE or both. Yeah - the gold is good but not worth the hassle and loss of other resources. If I lose - well - obviously its a massive loss in loot. None of that counts the many many troops I donate which may be another 400k in elixir and hundreds in DE. And a war mostly ties me up for much of the 2 day war as I am not attacking so much but building troops

If I raid for 2 hours solid using an army composition that costs me about 60k elixir each raid - I can usually find an average base of 200k each and probably an average of 400 DE. In two hours I can do about 10 of them for a net gain of about 1.5 million each gold/elixir and 4k DE. All without any war drama.

Do the math - wars are a waste of resources, time and frustration. Your proposal will not really help that and for people like me - only makes it even less likely we will war more than we do now - which is once a month strictly for fun.

---

I suggestion is that you do the math, I tend to barch 200k+ per raid, but a cw mainly requires that your clan works together to doante and contribute troops to cc defense, so it's not just a burden on a few people. Also what I suggested is mainly to raise competitiveness. CW's require what, 2 attacks per day?

Also I understand using mass resources as I am a TH9 myself, not a 10 and I understand the consumption of the resources involved in a CW. This is where your math is wrong. My suggestion was to increase loot bonus per season along with bonus that comes with your clan's ranking, the more points you get the more loot bonus you'll get in the current CW. This will give an incentive for clans to work towards this common ground. In doing so this will also help motivate people to join CW's as people tend to think they lose more resources than spend in a CW, but they are typically wrong. I have been in a once a week CW clan vs a daily CW clan and I can tell you there's actually a huge difference when you're looting about 1 mil gold / elixir + 4k de every 2 days. You do the math. I win 4 times the elixirs I spend in CW's.

When Supercell added in CW they understand what adding CW would do to clans and the game. Their goal was also to raise competitiveness, but then again, CW is also optional. You're still stuck in the current CW mindset which hinted that you did not read about the bonuses which I suggested otherwise you would not be bringing up about how much resources you're using in a CW. My idea was to help improve the loot in CW's, not weigh it down. This also suggests that you're thinking on an individual basis rather than having a common goal which you can improve your clan with.

People join clans for the social network / donations, as well as to improve. By having CW's, win or lose. You can help your clan in more ways than just loot. CW's will tell you about your clan's strength / weaknesses and how you can improve as a clan / strategize and help them realize what they can do to raid better. If you're complaining about the drama that comes with CW, I believe that's more of a leadership issue than an issue with your clan, not the system.

I agree with this for one reason only... matchmaking will make more sense when having fought your way up a rank ladder... the higher you go the tougher the opponents.

I've gotten bored of being matched up like for like in TH's but having inspected the opponent bases found that our 5 mid maxed TH10's are matched up against 5 totally Maxed TH10's run by a champion.

We lose more wars than we win and there's no fun in always being out weighted.

Hoping for change

Like the idea! Though...

Couple things to consider...

How many leagues will there be? How many clans per league?

I have a mate who when he first started playin, joined a clan that was ranked somein like 300,000th! Now this is going by memory, from a couple months ago, but it was a very high number like that. It wouldnt really surprise me if theres more clans than that!

Lets say there is just 100,000 clans. How would you distribute the amount of clans, an into how many leagues?

Like ive said..I really like the idea :cool:

This is an awesome idea, increasing competitive play and somewhat adding more reward. great idea!

btw, you shouldn't be bumping your own thread. (it's against the forum rules)

"I also think it would be nice if there are options for some players to opt out of cw, because maybe their spell factories are down or their heroes are down and it's kind of a hassle to have to boot them and
re-invite them later before searching for a cw."

That is the easiest part (I would think) for them to impliment. There are times when I want to sit one out. Plus it would give the lower guys a chance to war. (clan runs a 20 man war currently has 23 players)

to the main idea. While setting up the leagues would be tough, once implimented could run as smoothly as the individual league system.

I am a soccer nut so my tendancy is to want a relegation and promotion type of system. This will also help with the clans that want to stay in a winning form against lower clans. Here is why:
1) set up the leagues with the current rankings of clans. Thos who dont war will drop to the next league until they fall to the bottom. once there the bottom league will fill up with those not warring and you can just delete that league altogether.
2)top 3 (or whatever number) in all lower leagues get promoted up after each season. So if you win all the time you will get moved up to tougher competition. Promotion will grant you a reward as well as give you an increase in your League Bonus for every win. (Gems/gold/elixer/Dark Elixer/moniker to add in clan desription/etc...)
3) Bottom 3(or whatever number) get dropped a league so they are closer to their competition level. But being in a lower league will significanlty decrease the League bonus% for wins.
4)top league will give a big bonuses to the top winners. or something of the like to make it worth it to be the best (in case loot is your reasoning for playing) as well as monker in your clan description. Plus a special clan shield for the overall winners. You retain the shield for as long as you are champions.
5)league bonuses- every war won grants you a percentage of loot from the bases you defeat. Now every war won will also add a fill your collectors by __% token. if there are 100 leagues. and you are in league 100 you get a 1% fill of your collectors added for every war won. (just an idea, I am sure there are probably better loot bonus ideas) But an overall bonus that varies depending on the league you are in is what I am after.

those are just the things I could think of off the top of my head.

daily bump