Printable View
It probably has been discussed already but war donations must start counting towards XP and donation count. It sucks being one of the top guys in the clan and being expected to donate max troops to everyone in the whole clan without getting ANYTHING for it.
If you are talking about the Friend in Need achievement, it would be too easy to exploit to get the gems. Donate, Delete Repeat. Although if there were a separate achievement, w/o gems or it is set ludicrously high with gems, then it would be acceptable.
I too would like to see war donations start counting towards XP and donation count.
I disagree. As someone above said, it would be easily manipulable to have war donations that can be deleted right away to be counted as the donating achievement. Also, XP doesn't even mean anything and not giving XP or donation count for war castles decreases the incentive for bad troops being thrown in.Quote:
Originally Posted by RagnorZorg
I just joined this forum but I read about this before. If you give XP for that sort of thing, people can delete the donated troops and then the other player would get XP in a vicious cycle. It makes ♥♥♥♥♥ing too easy. I can't lie I had the same idea and I researched why it wasn't so. I found reasonable answers on these forums.
Quote:
Originally Posted by 3LJ4Y
But i believe if someone deletes your troops they can't donate again so maybe you should get the XP after the clan war prep day.
I hate donating camps full of wiz and getting nothing in return. Maybe make it so only the first donator gets xp so you cant c h e a t the system
I agree with this. Only the first time you donate will it count to XP. It kind of sucks to donate an entire army of dragons and not get anything for it.Quote:
Originally Posted by BlargityTucker
A simple donation count for war would be good. It would just be a "Hey this person is the one who gave everyone wizards and drags" or "this was the noob who gae everyone giants". Not xp/friend in need/clan donations though