If there was no beach, people wouldn't ask for naval units. Quit leading these people on Supercell.
Remove the beach from the village screen.
Printable View
If there was no beach, people wouldn't ask for naval units. Quit leading these people on Supercell.
Remove the beach from the village screen.
I like your new avatar:)Quote:
Originally Posted by dahimi
Im curious about this, if SC removes the beach, what do you propose they place there instead?
They already removed the waterfall...now you want the ocean removed? How lame. Going to look so bland with just a green forest surrounding your base.
I think the beach is useless, if nothing related to it is getting implemented soon. Take the beach, get the waterfall, add a fish-climbing the waterfall mini game :cool:
Bigger base? Would be niceQuote:
Originally Posted by Tiny
More space for buildings.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tiny
Gee I wonder who found that avatar. Hehe :cool:Quote:
Originally Posted by Tiny
Moor boats please ;)
Would be good to remove the beach to stop threads of people asking for ships.
Replace it with more space for us as the map is tight enough .
ok, that seems fair. To be honest I don't care for the beach but I do miss the waterfallQuote:
Originally Posted by dahimi
I've done all of these things.Quote:
Originally Posted by dahimi
Really - if your an Indian we already have the policeman, doctor, construction worker ( our own village people )Quote:
Originally Posted by hb808
Do you by chance prefer Dos Equis even though you don't always drink beer?Quote:
Originally Posted by hb808
B-b-but... If they removed the beach, Pommie can't run back & forth Farming4Gold & Elixir chopping the heads of all her misbehaving clannies..
HAIL PRINCESS POTATO!!!!! <--- forgive me, I just learnt how to program shortcuts into my iPad keyboard
-----
The little (axe weilding) Potato
I would remove it if I know that there will be no naval units but a boys got to dream right
mmmm I would like to change my vote. Without the beach how do the pirates invade? We need pirates yaarrrrrr!!!
I love going to the beach, in fact I just got back home from one. No let it stay, since waterfall is removed there is no other way for the village people to take a bath.
See my other idea:Quote:
Originally Posted by silentwill
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...-the-waterfall
I would trade it all for the waterfall...
Yes, without the beach how would the pirates saalllddddiiiiirrrrrr!Quote:
Originally Posted by Tiny
(In clan joke)
Haha, Dahimi... funny poll.
I didn't vote as I didn't realize there was even a beach. Facepalm, my bad.
Illy
P.S. @you-know-who who told me about this thread, I thought this poll was about the, err, um, beach picture in the clan GB that was being discussed, duh... not a beach in the game, haha... my bad.
More space please!
I had to give up alcohol.Quote:
Originally Posted by dahimi
Not Indian, but do have tanned skin and my gluteus is up to the standard of YMCA.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tiny
It would look bad without it KEEP IT
Don't the donated archers always go to the beach in order to swim to your clan member's bases? Without the ocean they have to wander through the dark, deep, dangerous forest!! :eek:
to be honest the beach is a good scenery. if supercell were to remove the beach i dont know what they would substitute it with. mountains or a lava border maybe? or perhaps a dessert? honestly what i want is a water scenery. who cares about the newbs who request for water troops, supercell wont listen to them anyways.
Oooohhh, SPACE!! Perfect, SC can we have spaceships and maybe some new alien units too!!Quote:
Originally Posted by dahimi
Replace the beach with space and lets get a millenium falcon up in hurr!
Water defense is not ruled out yet, what makes you think suggestions for it need to be stopped?
No keep the water so I can keep my dream of water gettin a purpose in the game! Lets be honest the idea of water being put into the game is exciting
They keep the water and add water based defenses like battleships or something like that where it fires at units from the water
i don't understand why you don't like the idea for boats in coc it would make the game more fun
It would be another unnecessary, unwanted feature.Quote:
Originally Posted by kids160
Naval units are not realistic because how do they get there? They sail from your village all the way there and where would you train and house them, but I do like the beach because it is boring enough with three sides of forest.
There should be expansions for free all you have to do is reach a certain lv like lv 40 first expansion lv 60 second expansion level 80 expansion all around the base
I like the beach but naval units are stupidQuote:
Originally Posted by dahimi
I agree, but I would totally trade having the beach for getting rid of the naval unit posts.Quote:
Originally Posted by Qwertyuiop
i dont remember the waterfall :(
Yeah I don't like the whole water feature but there needs to be something different on at least one side.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tiny
Haha both made me laugh!!:DQuote:
Originally Posted by hb808
I say get rid of the forest! Islands for everyone!!! Troops hop in a row boat when donated... :cool:
the beach is for decoration
Lets remove the forest. Cmon we are all expecting ninjas to come out of trees right?
Would be better if we had variety of scenery!
Hey guys how about in the sea, a ship occasionally drops by to trade. Like you give the pirate a minion and if you have enough space he gives you something else. The idea seems pretty useless but i would like to know if you want to build on it.
Make the scenery so it is in relation to the actual day time for example if it is day time it would be day time in the game and so on
That sounds cool! Another thing a think they could make to do with the water is to make new water troops such as a pirate, mermaid (pretty much a water troop healer), sea monster, and piranhas. They could also make a new resource called gold doubloons that you could use to train troops with and use to give to your pirate.Quote:
Originally Posted by cocohawk
That sounds cool! Another thing a think they could make to do with the water is to make new water troops such as a pirate, mermaid (pretty much a water troop healer), sea monster, and piranhas. They could also make a new resource called gold doubloons that you could use to train troops with and use to give to your pirate.Quote:
Originally Posted by cocohawk
dragon this whole thread is about stopping stupid ideas like that one to come, this is not the place to talk about them!!
How about we make a sea god hero too who has nukes for us and we can use them to automatically 100% a base and we give sea god praise and build water things for the sea god so there will be no tsunami at or village and if atleast once every day you don't give sea god praise and bring sea god 2million gold coins sea god will tsunami your village and make you TH1 and take all your defences and resources
great idea projektz :D he should also be able to take away our gems when his tsunami comes!
Would be cool for summerQuote:
Originally Posted by Wa11er98s
yeah thats an awesome idea haha but we would get more stupid threads about water troops than ever lol
i want it. its wanted!!!!Quote:
Originally Posted by Djemerson13
Based on the votes, you aren't on the majority so they probably won't listenQuote:
Originally Posted by dahimi
i think they have to create a port see my post :http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...496#post614496
Quote:
Originally Posted by Djemerson13
I want that feature
Water based troops are useless as people can put their base in the middle and no water troops could attack it rendering them useless.
You could make a harbour or something on it and therefore bring water units into the game
You could also make streams running through village do that you could attack people with water units...
No, that would make base defense strategy much harder to plan (takes up space where you can't place buildings, so if there's one running straight through the middle...) and the village harder to defend.Quote:
Originally Posted by Wilko864
Removing the beach would stop everyone from constantly asking for stupid water stuff, so I do approve of this idea.
i was thinking that supercell could change the western side of the map to match with their updates. for example, when Halloween approaches and supercell edits the game to make it match the spooky theme, they should swap the ocean/beach with a dark forest. you may also purchase the same decorations from last years Halloween theme. any ideas? this idea interested me. this would also mean that for Christmas, a pine forest covered with snow could also be implemented with a path going through. there would be a sign pointing down toward the path labeled "south pole" for fun.
Some threads just never die..
So very trueQuote:
Originally Posted by iikes12
And sea stuff would be pretty cool but there's no need
Everybody that's an experienced player knows that's unviable, complex and not worth to do update. The only ones that actually want are noobs.Quote:
Originally Posted by Swimmer
Fishing whales for gold like in Aoe!!!
If I want to play CoC with a beach, I just switch to Boom Beach.
The map in offline campaign doesn't even show the base next to water!
Safe to say Supercell doesn't plan on adding naval units.
Its not doing any harm
Well, this thread was created before Boom Beach came out, so it's a little outdated now...Quote:
Originally Posted by Qnomei
It's crazy the things people find to complain about. Are you serious? The beach is in no way present to lead anybody on! It's part of the scenery. Without it, the village would look boring, and if instead of the beach there was another wall of forest, cramped. SC isn't leading people on with any coastal or water-based troops or buildings, I've never seen them actually state that there are going to be such additions for certain.Quote:
Originally Posted by dahimi
Should the forest be removed as well so that we aren't disappointed when they don't add in tree troops??
I just don't like how it clashes with the "forest" thing. "Clashes" ha ha ha
It's crazier that you can't tell.Quote:
Originally Posted by iDANglin
Quote:
Originally Posted by asasnator
there was a waterfall... Add it back!!!!!!!!!!!!
Ever think about the beach being there for a future reason?
If you only care about sand in this game, then...wow.
guys if you want naval units, play boom beach. and please don't get rid of the beach. your base would look so bland without some water
I dont get why sc put a beach there, there are no naval units.
Same reason God put dinosaur bones into the ground. To test us.Quote:
Originally Posted by Jacksonian
If you only care about replying to my posts with silly comments on the forum, then...wow.Quote:
Originally Posted by Jacksonian
If they remove the beach how will the pilgrims ever find my village to share their turkey and pie?
YOur right, instead of asking for a naval battle, people would ask for a beahc
If SC got rid of the beach then a nice side effect would be the ability to create a contiguous clan map, like what I suggested in my thread http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...n-overview-map :D
So yes, that gets my vote!
If there wasn't a beach then my stinky barbarians wouldn't have an opportunity to take a bath :p
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tiny
in reply to that here is a list of ideas: put a customizable area, a holiday themed area, just more trees or maybe another village that u can see in the distance, or maybe the goblin campaign map that u are currently on with and if u have beaten the goblins an exploded or beaten goblin map in the distance, or a town in the distance that your base is protecting…... i can go on for days what should be there as long as it isn't the beach get back to me if any of these sound good :) what if that the beach changed every day or every season so just to change things up ;) like maybe u see troops in it taking baths lol that would be a cool little spoof or decorations that can go in the ocean
If the beach is removed people will just find something else to ask for.
No it that would make it plain and boring ♥♥♥♥♥♥
Where can I find a Picture of the waterfall...Quote:
Originally Posted by Asasnator
I wasn't playing that long ago
I did some research as to why the waterfall was removed. based on this, I have a feeling the beach might not be around forever.
Long story short: The waterfall was a much loved decorative feature that was removed in the 2.111 update, released on November 19, 2012. The reason cited by Supercell for its removal was for performance reasons. As defenses became more numerous and more animated, it became necessary to remove the waterfall so that the game would continue to function properly on older devices.
The waterfall was animated and could be found on the NE side of the village.http://forum.supercell.net/images/icons/icon14.png
I wonder where that text came from?Quote:
Originally Posted by ShamWeick
http://clashofclans.wikia.com/wiki/The_Waterfall
I can't believe some idiot actually created a wiki article for the waterfall.
I know the beach might look blan to ppl but supercell can add stuff like washed up crates with gold or gem boxes can wash up the beach or special paper in a cracked bottle that has a quest in it they're bunches of ideas just don't take away the beach
They could add all of this without one.Quote:
Originally Posted by XQuantumParadoX
Well it gives the game a bit of landscape and scenery, yeah but it is pointless, why are people still posting after a year?
Well it's my thread and I'm still here.Quote:
Originally Posted by johnnybro1234
Ty for reminding me that my Smurf's Village has a message in a bottle quest line that needs to be completed.;)Quote:
Originally Posted by XQuantumParadoX
No more water!
I just voted no since it seemed like an awesome option...Quote:
Originally Posted by dahimi
EDIT: Plz don't necro old threads!
Lol! Best necro'd thread ever! :D
Keep necro'ing this tho :3
♥♥♥♥....keep necroing and get the thread closed :PQuote:
Originally Posted by HydroPenguin
The beach is zoomed in on and then that is boom beach so if you want navel troops go to boom beach :P
Replace the beach with forest or base area, It doesn't make sense for every village to face the same way, the land would have to be infinitely long with salt water that has a source that never runs out.
Correct, that's exactly how it is. And its great. keep the beach.Quote:
Originally Posted by firestar123
Yup, i sure as heck did necro it!Quote:
Originally Posted by Kirrily
It is a scientific impossibility.Quote:
Originally Posted by rwelshjr