Printable View
I have no idea how supercell would do this,but what if the game attacking system thing could find clan hopper and get people who have a higher lvl by just a bit to attack them.Then there trophies would lower and stop them from clan hopping cause there trophies would be to low to join.
tell me what you thinking about it.
I'm not 100%sure this is a good idea.but a lot of people don't like clan hopping
Clan hopping is just a part of any game where you have clans, alliances, whatever. No game mechanics can promote loyalty.
Clan hopping doesn't bother me, if i lose 5 archers so be it.
I don't think that Supercell will stop clan hopping.. It's indeed normal that there are people that are hopping
Clan hopping doesn't bother me two the only reason I made this was because so many people where complaining about clan hopping
It's pretty much impossible to make something to counter hoppers.
I lost a dragon that won't even serve me a purpose in real life!!!1!1!1!!1
So be it, like scanners said.
it does bother me sometime.. it is a waste of time, i got an idea and posted it in feature requests
i hope supercell or you guys can check it out tell me what ya think
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...ining-another-
They could avoid it if they really want..
Simply put a delay to joining a new clan after you left the last one. Something like.. Wait 2 days before you can join a new clan.
Pretty simple logic and easy to implement.
IF they want it or not.. Thats another talk.
That wont happen because alot of people visit friends in other clans then wouldn't be able to get home for 2 days.Quote:
Originally Posted by mlmfilho
No, dumb idea there is clans like DTP that have trophy pushes and if members don't participate they get sent to aDTP so 2 days clawless would suck.Quote:
Originally Posted by mlmfilho
I didnt say I would like it. I just said it would stop clan hopping.Quote:
Originally Posted by xXDABEAS798Xx
The thread is about stopping clan hopping. I gave a possible solution.. Never said I would like it nor SC should do it.
People are so eager to look smart in forums they forget the part where they understand the context. Jeez.
Why should clan hopping be stopped?
People should be free to join and leave any time.
And your clan can choose to be open/close/invite.
And that's exactly how it should be.
I think the only way to slow down clan hopping is through a reporting method, kind of like the global chat reporting. Clan members could report someone as a hopper and after the hopper has had enough reports then they are banned from joining any clans for a time. A week maybe.
Worst idea ever. Something to stop clan hopping would be you can only join a clan every 24,36,48 hours (whatever that number may be)
There's a simpler way; add an adjustable toll (controlled by guild leader) which a new player must pay to enter the clan. People with invites join for free.
Most hoppers are doing it for the troops so the simple solution is give them crappy troops. Most new comers to my clan are gonna get their castle filled with goblins and wall breakers lol. This is not universal, if they come in, chat with us, fill any pending requests and politely ask if they can request they will get good troops and yes some of them still leave but the ones who come in, don't even say hi and request are gonna get the crappiest troops we all have to give. If every clan did this hoppers would stop cause they wouldn't be getting their fix of good troops. The people who are sincerely looking for a clan either don't say anything or they make a joke about it, the hoppers either leave immediately or get kicked in seconds when they start to complain.
If this is a problem in your clan then it is likely that you don't have a great clan. A really good clan has enough active elders that they can make people request to join, and anyone they don't like the looks of can just be refused. I joined aDTP a few days ago, and while I have probably sent a few archers to people who had just joined and later left it's not very common.
I am terribly sorry, but if your clan doesn't have to recruit than this is none of your business. You imply because our clans are not full they are awful clans, I have been in the same clan since I started the game, there are 30 of us who are solid members who have been together since the beginning and I have no problems getting my troop requests filled so don't try and tell me my clan sucks. Every time we make an attempt at filling those last 20 spots we are flooded with hoppers and yes we are set to invite only. This is a problem for the majority of clans if it is not a problem for your clan, keep your nose out of it.
end rant
Thats one view of a "great clan". My clan does not keep flooding the global chat to recruit anyone. We accept anyone who seems a decent player and I still think my clan is great.Quote:
Originally Posted by wolfling
I dont care how many trophies my clan have in total.. The way I see it (and it seems very different than what you see) the fun is based on the members personality.. not trophy count.
Not going to happen.
due to its what I do...
Warm regards,
sneaky ( hopper ) maori
Here is what they should do. Have an option configurable by the clan leader that sets the amount of time after joining that a person must wait before they can request troops. Make it go from 0-24 hours.
Quote:
Originally Posted by sneakymaori
Not really. I see a distinct difference between a visitor and a hopper. A visitor comes in and engages in clan chat, donates a few troops, requests a few troops, checks out our bases and hands out compliments or design advice, maybe talks strategy or troops and then says bye when they leave. A hopper comes in says nothing, requests troops and is gone 30 sec after their castle is full. We have a couple regular visitors and always welcome them back, the hoppers are another story.
Yes but the OP is requesting some sort of system that would determine which is which automatically, which is um...insane. The idea I posted fixes the problem and allows people to do it based on what is best for their clan.Quote:
Originally Posted by Stefm211