Elixir on Wall Upgrade: Terminate, Continue or Continue with Conditions

This is a dumb idea. I am a Townhall 9 and have no problem raiding enough gold or elixir for walls or any upgrades. In face, loot has been a lot better for me since the server update (not sure why, not sure it will continue, but am grateful for it while it lasts). Once cannot endlessly pump resources into walls as we have a finite amount of them. I'll have enough elixir for you once my lvl 10 walls are done. :rolleyes:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lannister

This is a dumb idea. I am a Townhall 9 and have no problem raiding enough gold or elixir for walls or any upgrades. In face, loot has been a lot better for me since the server update (not sure why, not sure it will continue, but am grateful for it while it lasts). Once cannot endlessly pump resources into walls as we have a finite amount of them. I'll have enough elixir for you once my lvl 10 walls are done. :rolleyes:

---

Wish you take much more than 2 weeks to upgrade all 4 army camps to maximum levels, while you are in TH10, if you dare to come to TH10 now and use no gems for resources or barracks boosting.

But I do not think you have balls to come to TH10 in near future.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ChiKnows

i feel you sire. They are INSANE. Period. 4m for a single wall. 1m is already too much for a single wall, still insane. Genius.:rolleyes:

---

Read carefully. Condition with minimum balance of 4 million elixir in storages AFTER any wall upgrade. The cost of wall remained the same.

The idea is to further differentiate elixir as compared to gold usage on wall upgrade, not just on upgrade wall at the level of 6 to becomes 7 or higher.

The figure of 4 million elixir as a balance is suggested based on a number of considerations. However, other figures like 3 or 3.5 million will work as well.

No need to change. As an active farmer I finally have use for elixir. Otherwise it would just go completely to waste.

Walls have been slightly nerfed (larva hound) so it makes sense for it to be easier to upgrade.

Really I don't really care since I get only handfuls of elixir due to my premmier status but yah donsen't really matter but if I were to choose, it would be continue incase you get tank loads of elixir.
Kind Regards

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ztb29

I'm sorry and don't wanna start a flame, but this idea has a ton of major flaws.


1. Who does this benefit OTHER than super active players? Semi actives can't hold 4 million just to simply upgrade a wall!

2. How do you expect to implement this on th7 and below???

3. This is simply making an already hard wall grind impossible. People will never upgrade walls due to the audacity of needing 4 million to upgrade a single wall.

4. This does nothing to benefit town hall 8 either! How can they expect to upgrade walls if whenever they log off they lose 300k elixer to a town hall 10?


Overall, this is a flawed idea only benefiting active town hall 9 and 10 players.

---

1. We do not want too many semi active players who just collect all gold and elixir from their own base and then dump all these resources solely on wall upgrade. They do not contribute much to the economy for raids. In fact, more nexting are required for active players to skip attack on them as you will always see less than 100k available loot from them.

2. Wall upgrades are restricted by town hall level. Town hall 6 players are restricted to maximum level 6. Hence, TH6 or lower are not affected. TH7 is restricted to maximum level 7 wall. The figure of minimum 4 million elixir balance in storages after any wall upgrade can be adjusted to let say 3 or 3.5 million.

3. Read carefully. The balance of minimum 4 million elixir in storages after any wall upgrade, NOT 4 million resource for all wall upgrade. Currently, we need to spend 4 million gold or elixir to upgrade a wall from level 10 to max 11, not other levels.

4. TH10 players can never take away 300k elixir from TH8 storages, due to penalty of higher TH level. Unless, there are loot included from elixir collectors not being collected for a long time.

Terrible idea.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wylplaycoc

1. We do not want too many semi active players who just collect all gold and elixir from their own base and then dump all these resources solely on wall upgrade. They do not contribute much to the economy for raids. In fact, more nexting are required for active players to skip attack on them as you will always see less than 100k available loot from them.

2. Wall upgrades are restricted by town hall level. Town hall 6 players are restricted to maximum level 6. Hence, TH6 or lower are not affected. TH7 is restricted to maximum level 7 wall. The figure of minimum 4 million elixir balance in storages after any wall upgrade can be adjusted to let say 3 or 3.5 million.

3. Read carefully. The balance of minimum 4 million elixir in storages after any wall upgrade, NOT 4 million resource for all wall upgrade. Currently, we need to spend 4 million gold or elixir to upgrade a wall from level 10 to max 11, not other levels.

4. TH10 players can never take away 300k elixir from TH8 storages, due to penalty of higher TH level. Unless, there are loot included from elixir collectors not being collected for a long time.

---

No, th9 and 10 mostly feed from us 8's.

Supercell knew what they were doing when they introduced the elixir for walls upgrade. Now theres less elixir to raid from anyone too because walls are still too expensive. So youre pressured into gemming for resources and lining supercells pockets. Economy shot. Thanks supercell.

Since the lix wall change I have massively struggled for gold. I don't see why this has happened, and I don't see how OP's suggestions would change this.

Even if we were to go with the continue with conditions, 4m lix is massively too high. This is far too much for some lower THs to maintain.