Elixir on Wall Upgrade: Terminate, Continue or Continue with Conditions

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wylplaycoc

Terminate: benefits more to active players. Motivate players to stay active and raid more.

Continue: benefits more to semi active players. Encourage semi active players to only collect resources from collectors and dump mostly all resources for wall upgrade.

Continue with conditions of there are still balance of minimum 4 million elixir in storages after any wall upgrade: benefits to all players. No wastage of overflow of excessive elixir in storages. No poor economy as players cannot dump all resources for wall upgrade. (This will be a solution in long run.)

---

Terminate. because since this upgrade i always face loot problems. Cant even see a single player with loots on the storage always empty and i always encounter bunch of 50-60k loots. (g3-g1) and dead bases is hard to find now.

Continue with conditions. This conditions i think is they should make the troops that survive in each raid be spared. So we can Raid fast, save time and save more elixir. This can also make up for the looting problems or NEXTing problems.



What do you think guys?

Aka sc is too stubborn and too greedy to undo the worst thing that's happened to the game in my time.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LordAmbreon

Aka sc is too stubborn and too greedy to undo the worst thing that's happened to the game in my time.

---

Yes they are. I wish they let us save the troops tht survive in each raid we make. Maybe that will make up for the problems we face specially this topic we talk about.

I have not spent one elixir on a wall yet. I want to finish walls the same way everyone else did. Plus I get gold way more than elixir.

I'm sorry and don't wanna start a flame, but this idea has a ton of major flaws.


1. Who does this benefit OTHER than super active players? Semi actives can't hold 4 million just to simply upgrade a wall!

2. How do you expect to implement this on th7 and below???

3. This is simply making an already hard wall grind impossible. People will never upgrade walls due to the audacity of needing 4 million to upgrade a single wall.

4. This does nothing to benefit town hall 8 either! How can they expect to upgrade walls if whenever they log off they lose 300k elixer to a town hall 10?


Overall, this is a flawed idea only benefiting active town hall 9 and 10 players.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ztb29

I'm sorry and don't wanna start a flame, but this idea has a ton of major flaws.


1. Who does this benefit OTHER than super active players? Semi actives can't hold 4 million just to simply upgrade a wall!

2. How do you expect to implement this on th7 and below???

3. This is simply making an already hard wall grind impossible. People will never upgrade walls due to the audacity of needing 4 million to upgrade a single wall.

4. This does nothing to benefit town hall 8 either! How can they expect to upgrade walls if whenever they log off they lose 300k elixer to a town hall 10?


Overall, this is a flawed idea only benefiting active town hall 9 and 10 players.

---

i feel you sire. They are INSANE. Period. 4m for a single wall. 1m is already too much for a single wall, still insane. Genius.:rolleyes:

I am currently a th8, so 4mil a wall doesn't apply to me.
But I am simply staying at lvl8 walls and not going any higher.
im not farming for 1mil per wall. that's just insane.

adding the elixir helps a bit, but I'm still not going above lvl8

I'm a almost maxed TH8.

Before the elixer walls, I had no use for elixer, so I was always full on elixer and got raided, and I often did all-wallbreaker raids for the replays and to waste elixer.

The elixer walls will encourage me to max my walls at TH8.

Without that, I would be lost.

EDIT: Note that I had all lvl7 walls before the update, so I don't think that its all great because it benefits me. I would've waited to use elixer on lvl7 walls if I knew about the update.

yes i was maxed lvl7 walls before the update as well.

there wasnt enough elixir upgrades before the update, imo.
i was always overflowing with elixir beforehand. now i have a use for it.

Continue with condition sounds good maybe 2mil or lower if possible :)

Why not making a poll :/