Leader duties, War assignments, Clan sharing, Builder assignments...

In no special order, but I tried to group similar ideas...

1. As leader, select which members are available for war. Often times a higher member might want to sit one out and they're forced to leave the clan or drop trophies.

2. As leader, designate each member's war targets or assign bounties on each target. If the member attacks their target, they get the bounty from the leader's resources. Other members can pay the bounty if they want to attack a target that is not their own. Maybe let the leader decide if designated targets are mandatory or voluntary. Often times we like to designate the first attack and leave the second attack open.

3. As leader, you can remove troops from other members' war castles. Often times a member isn't online during prep day and leaders/co-leaders can't do anything about it.

4. Sell items in your village. Each item has a net worth and selling it regains 50% of the net worth. For example, you've invested 4M gold into a L6 wizard tower (not exact, just numbers), you could sell it for 2M gold. Often times you're pressed for resources and realize other items are of less priority. Maybe you can downgrade an item for 50% refund of the previous upgrade cost, then you don't have to sell it completely.

5. Display your village's net worth. It'd be nice to see how much someone has invested into their village alongside their level and XP.

6. Allow members to upgrade other member's items for an extra cost. If an upgrade costs 20k gold and that member is hurting on resources, another member can perform the upgrade for 40k and get XP doing it. Similar to donating troops.

7. Lock items in your village. Often times you accidentally move an item like a wall and don't notice you've made a gap. You could lock items in place to prevent them from moving and unlock them when you want to move again. Might be easier to lock the whole village as one, then unlock it for adjustments and lock it again when done.

Hello,

My first time at the supercell's forum! I´m a lvl 102 player, stoped 2 times and back againd in game... but I think this time I will be playing for a long time...

I like your ideas, but I have some comments. Please, don't rage on me... ;)

1. Perfect!!! I´m a leader of a 20 users clan, but we are practicing in 15x15 war mode... so every time I need to kick 5 guys and invite back, giver elder or co-lider to then. Totaly agree with you.

2. I use a Google Docs sheet to set the target for first and second attack for each of 15 members in war. So everyone need to look at the GDocs to se who to attack, if we have this option in the game, will be much more easiear to work with it! (In my GDocs sheet I have some statistics to help the clan to see who are doing ok or not so ok... the rules, tips, etc... https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets...gid=1984456782)

About bounty is a cool idea, but not using personal resources... I think if the clan have a clan vault with gold, elixir and dark elixir leader and co-liders can use for bountys. The clan Vault gives a lot of options to SuperCell to implement and work in future expansions.

3. Totally agree with you!

4. I don't see this so usefull...

5. Cool idea! I love statistics!!! =)

6. The Clan vault can be used for this idea!!!!

7. Totally agreed with you again, I hate when for mistake I move a single piece of wall... Lock in game and force to use edit mode to move things! Move everything as a unique thing is a cool a idea to help to centrileze the village.

Well I think that is a great package for supercell!

(Sorry if made any english mistake, hello from Brazil!) :D

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Brandao

Hello,

My first time at the supercell's forum! I´m a lvl 102 player, stoped 2 times and back againd in game... but I think this time I will be playing for a long time...

I like your ideas, but I have some comments. Please, don't rage on me... ;)

1. Perfect!!! I´m a leader of a 20 users clan, but we are practicing in 15x15 war mode... so every time I need to kick 5 guys and invite back, giver elder or co-lider to then. Totaly agree with you.

2. I use a Google Docs sheet to set the target for first and second attack for each of 15 members in war. So everyone need to look at the GDocs to se who to attack, if we have this option in the game, will be much more easiear to work with it! (In my GDocs sheet I have some statistics to help the clan to see who are doing ok or not so ok... the rules, tips, etc... https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets...gid=1984456782)

About bounty is a cool idea, but not using personal resources... I think if the clan have a clan vault with gold, elixir and dark elixir leader and co-liders can use for bountys. The clan Vault gives a lot of options to SuperCell to implement and work in future expansions.

3. Totally agree with you!

4. I don't see this so usefull...

5. Cool idea! I love statistics!!! =)

6. The Clan vault can be used for this idea!!!!

7. Totally agreed with you again, I hate when for mistake I move a single piece of wall... Lock in game and force to use edit mode to move things! Move everything as a unique thing is a cool a idea to help to centrileze the village.

Well I think that is a great package for supercell!

(Sorry if made any english mistake, hello from Brazil!) :D

---

Thanks for the comments!!

For #4, it may not be so useful to you at lvl 102, but it might be for lower to mid level players. Also, selling items brings a dynamic to the game where you can manage what you need to protect. If you're a maxed out TH8, you have X amount of items... Y are defensive and Z are non-defensive. If you sell half of your non-defensive items, you have a higher defensive/non-defensive ratio but you're also easier to get 50% 1-starred against. This brings a new balance to the game...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Turr

In no special order, but I tried to group similar ideas...

1. As leader, select which members are available for war. Often times a higher member might want to sit one out and they're forced to leave the clan or drop trophies.

2. As leader, designate each member's war targets or assign bounties on each target. If the member attacks their target, they get the bounty from the leader's resources. Other members can pay the bounty if they want to attack a target that is not their own. Maybe let the leader decide if designated targets are mandatory or voluntary. Often times we like to designate the first attack and leave the second attack open.

3. As leader, you can remove troops from other members' war castles. Often times a member isn't online during prep day and leaders/co-leaders can't do anything about it.

4. Sell items in your village. Each item has a net worth and selling it regains 50% of the net worth. For example, you've invested 4M gold into a L6 wizard tower (not exact, just numbers), you could sell it for 2M gold. Often times you're pressed for resources and realize other items are of less priority. Maybe you can downgrade an item for 50% refund of the previous upgrade cost, then you don't have to sell it completely.

5. Display your village's net worth. It'd be nice to see how much someone has invested into their village alongside their level and XP.

6. Allow members to upgrade other member's items for an extra cost. If an upgrade costs 20k gold and that member is hurting on resources, another member can perform the upgrade for 40k and get XP doing it. Similar to donating troops.

7. Lock items in your village. Often times you accidentally move an item like a wall and don't notice you've made a gap. You could lock items in place to prevent them from moving and unlock them when you want to move again. Might be easier to lock the whole village as one, then unlock it for adjustments and lock it again when done.

---

Im so amazed how you can have some great ideas with some silly silly silly ridiculously silly ideas.

Just my opinion...good and bad :)
1. Everyone in this game wants this...been mentioned a 1000 times
2. Silly
3. Great idea
4. Omg silly, your having loot problems so you want to sell defences that you have to build again with "loot".
5. Fantastic idea
6. Silly silly. Supercell wont sell gems. I farm and have max loot on most days, i could max a mates th8 base in no time.
7. Omg silly...its annoying enough moving or editing stuff...now i have to unluck stuff first cos you accidently moved a wall and didnt realise.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Naz

7. Omg silly...its annoying enough moving or editing stuff...now i have to unluck stuff first cos you accidently moved a wall and didnt realise.

---

I think you don't understood... If there is an option to lock the edit mode, you never accidently move anything more...

=)

My comments

1. Opt in/Opt out been mentioned a bunch of times. I prefer having members be able to designate themselves in or out instead of the leader

2. You are free to designate targets in chat or other ways if you want but I don't like it being enforceable. eg. As punishment you force a th6 to attack a th10 or pay 500 000.

3. A leader is to lead not to do everything for the clan, People should look after their own war castle just as they look after their own war base (unless you want to rearrange their bases too). Note for the first 3 I think you are giving the leader way to much power the role of a leader is to lead not to do everything designate every small detail.

4. Maybe fully sell but not downgrade, there is no reason to get paid to downgrade a building. That being said I doubt most people would use it and don't think it should be in the game.

5. No reason to see this. If you really want you could calculate it based on the buildings they have.

6. Ruled out (giving resources) people could easily start multiple accounts to help pay for buildings in their main account, and would drop loot levels as people have more things to spend money on and less incentive to save up lots of money.

7. I could see locking the village as a whole but certainly not individual pieces.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Naz

Im so amazed how you can have some great ideas with some silly silly silly ridiculously silly ideas.

---

I'm so amazed at how unconstructive your comments are.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by webbie

My comments

1. Opt in/Opt out been mentioned a bunch of times. I prefer having members be able to designate themselves in or out instead of the leader

2. You are free to designate targets in chat or other ways if you want but I don't like it being enforceable. eg. As punishment you force a th6 to attack a th10 or pay 500 000.

3. A leader is to lead not to do everything for the clan, People should look after their own war castle just as they look after their own war base (unless you want to rearrange their bases too). Note for the first 3 I think you are giving the leader way to much power the role of a leader is to lead not to do everything designate every small detail.

4. Maybe fully sell but not downgrade, there is no reason to get paid to downgrade a building. That being said I doubt most people would use it and don't think it should be in the game.

5. No reason to see this. If you really want you could calculate it based on the buildings they have.

6. Ruled out (giving resources) people could easily start multiple accounts to help pay for buildings in their main account, and would drop loot levels as people have more things to spend money on and less incentive to save up lots of money.

7. I could see locking the village as a whole but certainly not individual pieces.

---

Thanks for the comments and explanations!

2. Using this as punishment is the leader abusing their role... even setting targets with no bounties or no enforcement would be a plus!

3. Leader has almost no role in this game besides being able to kick out/promote anyone... it'd be nice to have more duties, not power.

5. This is a statistics-driven game... why would you not want more statistics?