Idea: Clan Tax

Allow each clan leader to define or configure the Clan Tax (similar to the way they change trophies required to join). The tax (a percentage value) would be applied to the loot clan members collect during each of their raid (gold, elixir, and dark elixir), and distributed evenly among each clan member.

For example, let's say a the clan tax is configured at 1 percent. When clan member X attacks a village and gets 100000 gold, 50000 elixir and 1000 dark elixir, the clan tax would be 1000 gold, 50 elixir, and 10 dark elixir. Those are distributed evenly, starting from the top position to the bottom. The resources could be deposited within the clan clan castle.

This feature would create a stronger bond within the clan.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Warmaster1

Allow each clan leader to define or configure the Clan Tax (similar to the way they change trophies required to join). The tax (a percentage value) would be applied to the loot clan members collect during each of their raid (gold, elixir, and dark elixir), and distributed evenly among each clan member.

For example, let's say a the clan tax is configured at 1 percent. When clan member X attacks a village and gets 100000 gold, 50000 elixir and 1000 dark elixir, the clan tax would be 1000 gold, 50 elixir, and 10 dark elixir. Those are distributed evenly, starting from the top position to the bottom. The resources could be deposited within the clan clan castle.

This feature would create a stronger bond within the clan.

---

Yes but when I attack I use a lot of elixir and I don't want my clan mates, even if I love them, to take part of my loot

I don't like that idea. A lot of people would go clanless or create their own because of this.

Can we stop with these tax ideas? They're really dumb. I don't want to share my loot, and believe it or not, I don't want any part of my clan's loot. They earned it, it isn't for me

My attack, my loot. If this was put to use, players would do nothing and still become rich.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tiler

Can we stop with these tax ideas? They're really dumb. I don't want to share my loot, and believe it or not, I don't want any part of my clan's loot. They earned it, it isn't for me

---

You don't want to share your loot... But you are willing to use My loot for reinforcements? Is 1% of a 100K haul worth my 30K Dragon?:confused::confused:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mallan

You don't want to share your loot... But you are willing to use My loot for reinforcements? Is 1% of a 100K haul worth my 30K Dragon?:confused::confused:

---

First of all, it's a donation. A donation, by definition, is not compensated for. It's in good spirit that you should be donating troops, not because you expect a return favor (which you'll likely get anyway in the form of a return dragon or whatever troops you want)

Second of all, it takes a special kind of situation for me to even use my Castle during a raid, it is SO much more useful as defense.

So no, I don't expect to have to pay you for your dragon, and if I donated a level 5 PEKKA to you and it single-handedly took down half the base you were looting, I wouldn't expect anything back

Yes. When loot is at an all time low it would be a good idea to take some of it away from the lowest ranked players and give it to the leaders. Taking from the poor and giving to the rich will solve the problem for sure!!! Horrible, bad, stupid, lousy idea. Just icky in every way.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tiler

First of all, it's a donation. A donation, by definition, is not compensated for. It's in good spirit that you should be donating troops, not because you expect a return favor (which you'll likely get anyway in the form of a return dragon or whatever troops you want)

Second of all, it takes a special kind of situation for me to even use my Castle during a raid, it is SO much more useful as defense.

So no, I don't expect to have to pay you for your dragon, and if I donated a level 5 PEKKA to you and it single-handedly took down half the base you were looting, I wouldn't expect anything back

---

Pay more attention to the idea. It's not teh intention to donate to the leader, but to ALL within the clan. It doesn't hurt to give away just 2000 divided by 49 worth of gold/elixir/etc (assuming the clan has a max of 50 members). You will be benefit too. Everybody wins. It could be significant when adding up all those little sums. And the tax could be as low as zero. So those who don't want taxing can configure it to zero. It would work as of today. But let other more "social" clans benefit from a small tax, especially when resource are scarce ;) ...that's really the point.