Cannon Giants! The fire power of a cannon + the resistance of a giant

Here is a wild COC fantasy (not that wild though):

1. Name of Troop: Cannon Giant

2. Training Cost: 9000 Elixer

3. Training Time: 10 Minutes

4. Housing Space: 10

5. Damage Per Second / Damage Per Shot: 40 / 32 (Same as the Level 7 Cannon)

6. Hit Points: 630 (Same as the Level 7 Cannon)

7. Movement Speed: 12 (Same as the giant)

8. Description: A Cannon Giant is a giant with a cannon on wheels. Once deployed, a Cannon Giant will begin pushing the wheeled cannon towards the enemy base and will primary aim and fire at defensive structures including walls. Any enemy counter fire will affect only the giant but the cannon will get destroyed automatically once the giant gets killed. So, how long the cannon can fire its shots will depend on how long its giant can survive enemy fire.

This troop will prove useful especially when breaking into enemy fortifications as cannons can shoot at walls from a distance.

9. Upgrade: Upgrading a Cannon Giant will only improve the giant's resistance to enemy fire and will make him survive longer, but it will not increase the cannon's strength.

10. Access and Unlocking: Town Hall 7

11. Reference Art: I am sorry. I couldn't come up with a reference art.


Edits:

There is a similar troop concept here: http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...ew-troop/page6
While the 'Destroyer' (suggested in the page mentioned above) looks similar, you will see that my troop idea is different in a few ways.

1. We already have two wall breaker troops (regular and the balloon mounted).
2. Wall breakers cannot take much damage, while giants can.
3. A 'cannon giant' would also look like a typical battle troop; we have many fantasy-like troops already.

This is a repost?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Fluxidity

This is a repost?

---

I do not think so.

I don't believe SuperCell has any plans to make a Barracks Level 11. You might want to consider making this a dark elixir troop.

http://i46.photobucket.com/albums/f1...ps8483392d.jpg

This idea had been added to my thread "so you wanna make a new troop" and had a few adjustments made to it's stats.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Asmdus88

http://i46.photobucket.com/albums/f1...ps8483392d.jpg

This idea had been added to my thread "so you wanna make a new troop" and had a few adjustments made to it's stats.

---

Once again.No advertising.I am not a big fan of this idea.

A) this idea is awful, should not even come close to a new troop
B) asdmus if you're going to pick up every original idea with over 3 replies for your "elite" so you wanna make a new troop thread, don't use threads that everyone knows shouldn't be a new troop, maybe have a separate additions one or something to put this nonsense.
C) Its not advertising btw, its alerting everyone that the troop has been placed onto an elite thread (by asdmus' hand picking) which can now be voted upon by other players as to what they think the best 4 troops are. Advertising is saying everyone look at the links in my signature (which you should all totally do) and check out MY troop ideas (as you all should :D)
D) This exact idea was already posted as the cannonneer with really similar stats, not to be annoying but its true
E) Cmon peeps, recognize whats worth commenting about and whats not, i comment on every single decent looking troop but never any spells cuz i feel we need new and better troops (unlike this one) and if you make a revision to a troop as i have, put revision [insert troop name]

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Venomben

A) this idea is awful, should not even come close to a new troop
B) asdmus if you're going to pick up every original idea with over 3 replies for your "elite" so you wanna make a new troop thread, don't use threads that everyone knows shouldn't be a new troop, maybe have a separate additions one or something to put this nonsense.
C) Its not advertising btw, its alerting everyone that the troop has been placed onto an elite thread (by asdmus' hand picking) which can now be voted upon by other players as to what they think the best 4 troops are. Advertising is saying everyone look at the links in my signature (which you should all totally do) and check out MY troop ideas (as you all should :D)
D) This exact idea was already posted as the cannonneer with really similar stats, not to be annoying but its true
E) Cmon peeps, recognize whats worth commenting about and whats not, i comment on every single decent looking troop but never any spells cuz i feel we need new and better troops (unlike this one) and if you make a revision to a troop as i have, put revision [insert troop name]

---

I have no intentions of making artwork for EVERY troop idea; but for the ones that i do make art for its generally because a certain aspect of the troop catches my attention. Since the giant is a favorable troop to alot of clashers I figured that the possibility of having another variation would be worth consideration; and as there are currently no range based troops that target defenses it qualifies as something different that may (or may not) interest you all. Based off of your reactions it would seem to be the latter; but there are plenty of users on these forums and they are each individually free to make up their minds for themselves; and the whole point of my thread is to encourage that.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Asmdus88

I have no intentions of making artwork for EVERY troop idea; but for the ones that i do make art for its generally because a certain aspect of the troop catches my attention. Since the giant is a favorable troop to alot of clashers I figured that the possibility of having another variation would be worth consideration; and as there are currently no range based troops that target defenses it qualifies as something different that may (or may not) interest you all. Based off of your reactions it would seem to be the latter; but there are plenty of users on these forums and they are each individually free to make up their minds for themselves; and the whole point of my thread is to encourage that.

---

Good counter argument asmdus! I like this idea, we need some ranged defense attackers! Make it cost dark elixer though, because we dont need any more elixer troops.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by jobro

Good counter argument asmdus! I like this idea, we need some ranged defense attackers! Make it cost dark elixer though, because we dont need any more elixer troops.

---

I agree totaly