Can you guys help me decide which layout is best for farming?

Choose 1-3 (from left to right), feel free to comment on the strengths and weaknesses of the layouts! Thanks!

I edited the #2 base to make it better (separated gold and elixir in different compartments) so the major difference of #1 and #2 is the outer layer design

there all good...
mabe its cause im a th8!
:D

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by mrasum

there all good...
mabe its cause im a th8!
:D

---

Thanks for the response. I think for TH10, tier 1 troops are generally no big threat, but can you guys identify if there's particular weakness against certain attack strategies (like all dragons, GoWiWi or GoWiPe)?

I didn't look very hard, but at first glance #1 looks most effective.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by KyroTheHero

I didn't look very hard, but at first glance #1 looks most effective.

---

Thanks for the input. I have edited the #2 base to make the inner design similar to #1 and re-uploaded the #2 picture. The weakness I see in #1 is that the first layer of walls are open so several wall breakers can just go in and blow up the second layer, and goblins can rush in to destroy the storages. Also the defense towers are not very compartmentalized (there are 4-5 towers in the same compartments on the outer layer), so a group of giants and tier 1 troops can just go inside and raze the towers to the ground (although giants may be weakened by the spring trap at the entrance).

Compared with the #2, the #2 base has more compartments and place three buildings in each compartment on the outer layer consistently, so it may be harder to destroy all defense towers, yet it doesn't provide the "guided" spring trap as #1.

Can anyone else give some comments on this~? Any input will be appreciated!

I like 1 but spread out those cannons in the bottom right. There are way to many in one spot.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by THEBIGCLASH3R

I like 1 but spread out those cannons in the bottom right. There are way to many in one spot.

---

Thanks. In fact 1 and 2 and not much different except the outer layer design. So are there any specific reason for choosing 1 over 2?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 123321acd

Thanks. In fact 1 and 2 and not much different except the outer layer design. So are there any specific reason for choosing 1 over 2?

---

Now that I look at it more I like number two, because on number one I just noticed that open spot at the top with spring traps and I don't really like that, so I like how number two is closed off.