Roster Idea for Clan Wars

I am currently a co-leader in a clan and I find that it is very annoying that you can not choose your player lineup for a war. I always seem to have at least one member who will not be able to be on at the time of the war due to work or out of town for something.

My idea is very simple and I will use my clan as an example we have currently 18 members and only the top 15 can fight in wars. I would like to see a change that would allow for leaders and co-leaders to switch out members in their war lineup so that clans can bring active members to a war while also allowing low level members a chance to be in a war.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by watsonja4

I am currently a co-leader in a clan and I find that it is very annoying that you can not choose your player lineup for a war. I always seem to have at least one member who will not be able to be on at the time of the war due to work or out of town for something.

My idea is very simple and I will use my clan as an example we have currently 18 members and only the top 15 can fight in wars. I would like to see a change that would allow for leaders and co-leaders to switch out members in their war lineup so that clans can bring active members to a war while also allowing low level members a chance to be in a war.

---

i posted an idea about this

That would be a good idea. We always have people at school or on holidays when clan wars are on. Some people don't like clan wars in our clan so we just don't put them on the roster and they would be happy.

You've probably seen it already but I hate this idea. I don't really want to go through my logic again but im all for members to choose whether they want to participate or not. You are a team! A clan! No clasher left behind!!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Cooper123

You've probably seen it already but I hate this idea. I don't really want to go through my logic again but im all for members to choose whether they want to participate or not. You are a team! A clan! No clasher left behind!!

---

A clan have 16 member and 1 of them are inactive but still have high throphy
he should be not on war and give his chance to lower member

I have replied to similar threads but in a nutshell this is what I think (in order of importance)
1. don't post ideas already posted
2. it should never be a leader's choice, but a member's choice
3. it should be an opt-in/out button for every member
4. I personally believe an active leader can manage this without the tools
5. this could impact the war search in a negative way and makes the system more complex.