I have max heroes but this would have made the slog so much more fun.
/signed
I have max heroes but this would have made the slog so much more fun.
/signed
I have maxed heroes, but I think that it would be great have them available for a little amount of gems (example 5 gems for a pause of upgrading so you can do the attack) or with a penalty of their level (example, you're upgrading to lvl 16 but you can use it as a lvl 6).
/signed
/signed
Awesome idea hate being out of cw coz of upgrade on heroes
You start to build a building on your base and it's already done and useable on your war base. You upgrade a building and it's still useable on the war base.
Why is Heros being down even a thing?
If SC just followed their own logic when it comes to upgrade and the war base this would never have been a thing.
SC make this change!
Signed.
Long overdue.
/signed
This would be great
I want fight with my hero but every Time are they Upgrading
Defense buildings are active and heroes are active for defense in wars. You just can't use them to attack. So there logic is the same.Quote:
Originally Posted by ClashWithCut
/singedits sobad
Signed. 😎
OK then let's compare it to troops then. There is a lab where troops can upgrade in. While they are upgrading you can still use them to raid and war with.....why not Heros? There should be a hero lab then......Quote:
Originally Posted by Tollboothwillie
There is only one King and one Queen, they are immortal and cannot be killed. They can be injured and have to heal. Troops are not the same when they go into battle they die. The lab is upgrading the next troop that will come out of the barracks after the upgrade. When a barrack produces troops, those are not the same troops that you used before.Quote:
Originally Posted by ClashWithCut
/signed...
again
You need to take your logic all the way back to the start, rather than comparing things that aren't quite the sameQuote:
Originally Posted by ClashWithCut
The reason that your heroes aren't available in war while upgrading is that Supercell don't want them to be
This is a major revenue stream for them... people gemming a little hero time to get them back for war
They aren't going to remove this revenue stream until they can see a similar revenue stream by adding a gem cost somewhere else
The fact that this thread has close to 5000 comments, most (but not all!) in favour and SuperCell haven't done it proves this isn't something they want to do.
Signed
Or make them temporarily available for use in cw, while pausing pausing upgrade, for a fee in gems. for example 10 or 20 gems to use them in an attack.
Signed sincerely supercell fansQuote:
Originally Posted by Doiugu
Dear fans give up some time
1y ear later
Signed
10 signatures
/signed
please make it!
I liked the idea, but this has been suggested for MONTHS.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sluffy
Also, by replying to this, didn't we all kinda necro this thread?
Me and my clan of 25/signed
I don't exactly see the point of this, yes it would be convenient for us to have heroes upgrading and still use them in war. But besides the point it doesn't take that much patience of a person to wait till their hero is done to do a few wars and upgrade them again. Compare it to this, you have all of your regular barracks upgrading and go into war, regularly we'd be able to only use dark troops and cc, but this is like saying we could also use elixir troops in that situation.
Clan wars is what makes coc so much fun and having to be sit out cause you can't afford gems and it takes so long to level up your hero makes so many people loose interest in the game. At least make it a pause button that cost 5 gems for an hour so you can use your hero is war. Cause everyone should have gems like that just from shrubs and gems boxes that you get. SC will still make tons of revenue from all the people who are impatient which I'm sure there's alot. All I'm saying is SC remember the little guys!
@chunkmaster can u delete this thread
Only moderators can delete a thread and they do not do it on requests.Quote:
Originally Posted by Talha317
Why would we delete this thread? It's still a very commonly requested idea and this thread has served as the primary point of reference for several years.
Means it will not be closed? Right?:DQuote:
Originally Posted by Smolson
/Signed
10Signs
Signed....
\signed
They should b alowed to use
Thumbs up
Definitely love to use heroes just for war even when upgrading..
There was this game on Facebook just like coc. its out of business now it had a good feature of heroes. It had hero building of its own and had 3 heroes so u can upgrade one and use other 2 . But since clash of clans is in business and going pretty strong they can introduce many heroes and put limit cap to 3 which is right now consider it as an idea from boom beach but a little different. In this regard there will be very wide choice one hero can upgrade and 3 can defend the base the ones players like from the heroes building and as people want the heroes can be used in war. Btw we could only use 2 for attacking and defense purposes.
Your point is right but more heroes will bring them more gems wont they? And some people just want to upgrade things whether they r usable in war or not.Quote:
Originally Posted by PhilISuppose
/signed /signed /signed
/signed /signed /signed forever and after
/signed
hope this is still considered
I support it
Signed for forever and ever.
A 3 year old thread that has been signed by many, but still hasn't been implemented. C'mon guys, you know gemming Hero upgrades is one of Supercell's top money maker. Never going to happen.
Yep
Supercell concerns "money making".
This thread is a big proof. But no problem. The idea is good
/signed
You say that like it's a bad thing. Supercell is a business, you know. Businesses have to make money. And people gem rushing heroes is a good place for them to get itQuote:
Originally Posted by madman53190
Yes, it makes sense
This needs to be done in upcoming update
/signed this is a nice idea
✔️✔️✔️✔️✔️✔️✔️✔️✔️✔️
Ppl gemming hero time to stay in wars is the cash cow of supercell. They will never change that. Your preaching to the people splashing in the cash of gemmed heros
/Signed
Actually there are many times where SC made updates that lowered the amount of gems people buy. Eg making troops survive when army camps are destroyed, wall price drop/ability to upgrade with elixer, massive troop and spell training time decreases etc. IMO this feature isn't too far from reality.Quote:
Originally Posted by RoaLmawdeL
/ signed
its a nice idea making the heroes available in clan wars attacks while upgrading
i wish see that happen:heart::p / signed :thumbsup:
/signed. Thankyou for this game
Yeah....
/ signed
/signed making up for 10 characters
/signed...
By a war-worm XD....
[QUOTE=Sluffy;3044192]This makes sense on every level!! Keep Clan wars viable and competitive!
/Signed
Signed. Hate it when I loose a hero and am running on fumes in a clan war because 10% of my offense strength magically disappeared.
Signed, one of the biggest complaints in our clan! Personally haven't been able to participate in wars in 3 months as been upgrading royals week after week. This really need to be change asap!
/signed
SUPERCELL makes lots of money from people who gem heroes' upgrade time to keep playing clan wars.
What they don't seem to realize is the amount of players that quit playing due to heroes' grind specially on th9.
I have more than 10 friends that stopped playing due to lack of the most fun part of the game (clan wars) during the heroes' upgrade time (7 days) and then when it's finally over they're sleeping again. They just lost the "connection" with the game. I am sure this has happened to LOTS AND LOTS of players that quit. They did quit for this reason.
Yes. It would be awesome to still have heros available for clan war at the lower level like defensive buildings. But I know this is a business so maybe a war fee to use upgrading heros in war, say 10 gems or other fair amount.
This is so right. Currently I play town hall 9. I haven't used my Barb King in 2 months for can wars because I have to upgrade him for 30 levels. What is the meaning of having that kind of troop if you can't use it to a battle. The thing is when I'm upgrading my Barb King or Arch Queen I can't use them in a war battle. But if the enemy player is also upgrading their heroes, their heroes are still up in their bases guarding. That is not fair.so
/signed
how to sig😂n?
/SignedQuote:
Originally Posted by Sluffy
Making heroes usable during wars would be great, or instead the upgrade times for heroes should be halved.
/signed
This would be amazing and make wars more competitive
I'm up for this. Tired of being active but not being able to war.
/signed
Agree that heroes should be available while upgrading them
/signed
This would be a good quality of life upgrade for clash of clans. opting out or not being able to attack at full power in cw for more than half a year to get your heroes to level 30 is quite frustrating.
/signed
i agree with everyone that hero's should be upgraded in laboratory
I like it!
/signed
:( even though half way up upgrading heroes crossed
but its still worth it :p
This will never happen accept it you stupid idiots
/signed....
/signed! I hope for this!
Hi Sluffy, I agree, 7 days out of war for 40 occaisions for 2 heros at th10 is far too much time out of war. This is killing our clan and thetefore the games longevity surely?Quote:
Originally Posted by Sluffy
How to i vote ?
Hero's should be avaliable
/signed
Couldn't agree more even though I'm almost done with the heroes
/signed .I wanna war during hero upgrades or want their time to be reduced
/signed I WANT IT
/signed Really hate missing out on a couple of wars because of a hero upgrading.
to those who agree with it, now that there is a feature that instantly finishes hero upgrades, do you still want this to happen or are you content with the magic items?
Those magic items as said in the video are rare. It will solve 10% of heroes problem.Quote:
Originally Posted by ninjalvl999
Totally disagree, put heroes in the lab you solve 1 problem and creates another one (troops and spells delaying much more to be upgrade, due to the heroes queue).Quote:
Originally Posted by Sluffy
Finally, i agree with the "heroes upgrading in the war" it is one of the most awaited feature by the coc community.
I completely agree!!!!
/signed. It interferes with Clan Wars so either you have to wait, leave people out or just suffer their greatly diminished ability.
This would really be helpful
/signed
Would love this to be added
/signed
This is a MUST!!!!!
I cannot explain how useful this would be
/signed
Typically won't be in war with hero down. This would increase clan participants. Good idea.
Signed BY DaddyJ64!Quote:
Originally Posted by Sluffy
/signed. well it can be solved by the book of hero's but it still isn't enough.
is it too late to sign?! well..
/signed!
/signed
Totally agree, i love clan wars but i can't play this awesome mode because i'm perpetually upgrading my queen (th9 ...). I know this is from 2014 but never too late...
Signed%%%%%%%%%%%%
/signed
Hero unavailability is irritating.
/Signed
Bring it on!
/signed
Always on for this
I doubt Supercell will add this to the game (Though I too really want it)
It gets them a lot of money when people gem their heroes ready for wars
I agree with everyone here, every serious player who has done more than 100 wars will know how to work around upgrading royals but none the less to have them up in war will be much better and more fair if war is your primary game...signed
Reposting this here since apparently its against the rules to start new threads about it
The Hero Grind Starting at TH9 Is Slowly Killing This Game. Here's What Needs To Be Done:
CrossPosted From the subreddit since I figured it would reach more eyes over here.
Many of the people here are already aware of this on some level. This post is mainly me venting my frustrations as opposed to anything else, so sorry if Im preaching to the choir.
But anyway, as many people are aware, a very large number of people quit this game and never return soon after reaching TH9. This is, obviously because of the hero grind. But its not just because the hero grind is so daunting, and takes so long to complete. In terms of the amount of time and resources the hero grind takes beyond TH9, its mostly fine as is, seeing as its supposed to be end game content. The problem however, is how it interacts with the clan war game mechanic.
Clan Wars are for the majority of clashers, the most fun aspect of the game, and one of the main driving factors behind leveling up your base, especially since trophy pushing doesn't really matter that much outside of bragging rights and a one-time reward. The thing that keeps people playing this game for a long period of time, more often than not is clan wars.
However, upon reaching TH9, players realize a problem, upon reaching TH9, they all do some research, watch some youtube guides, browse the subreddit and the forums, and reach an unfortunate truth. In order to use nearly any competitive war strategy, you need to upgrade your heroes. But If you upgrade your heroes, you cannot participate in war. This is, as many people realize, a contradiction.
This leaves people with more or less 3 options:
1-Stay out of wars for the majority of the time, joining in occasionally when you're between upgrades. This is fine if you're in a casual clan with friends, but if youre planning on joining a more serious clan, forget about it.
2- Use strategies that dont require high level heroes such as lavaloon, or use inferior versions of popular strategies that dont involve killsquads or queen walks. This works for some people, but the result for many others is that they burn out on only being able to use an extremely limited subset of strategies, and end up quitting the game.
3- Gem your heroes so that they're always up when you need to participate in war. This is an option that a large number of people end up being forced to take, since they want to be able to progress towards unlocking high tier strategies, but they also want to participate in wars, and realistically, this is the only way to achieve that.
The solution to this contradiction is obvious, give heroes the same treatment for war attacks that they have for war defenses. Allow them to participate in war attacks while being upgraded. It would not be unreasonable for them to be able to do so. However, it is fairly obvious that due to the existance of option 3 above, it is directly against the interests of supercell to add this feature, since if they allow heroes to participate in wars while upgrading, then they lose this source of revenue.
However, I would like to make an appeal to supercell, to tell them that this business practice is hurting them in the long run. By keeping this contradiction in gameplay mechanics in the game, they are making one of the most fun portions of the entire game, clan wars, frustrating and unfun to participate in past TH9, which is the majority of the time spent playing the game for veteran players. By keeping it they are driving more and more people away from their game, all in the name of keeping a single source of revenue for whales/dolphins to drop cash on. However, relying on whales is not a good way to keep a game going forever, as without a population of non-whales to play the game, there will be no whales in the first place.
Additionally, with the addition of more and more bundles and deals that the average player is willing to spend cash on, supercell is less and less reliant on whales in the first place to make money. So why not make the game less frustrating to play so that more people will stick around to continue to enjoy and support the game?
If you have any thoughts, criticisms or anything to add, feel free to reply and let me know, this has been something bugging me for quite some time.
Tldr; heroes need to be able to attack in wars while upgrading, supercell wont add it because gemming heroes makes a ton of money and its slowly driving people away and killing their game.
In case it wasn't clear... /signed
/signed
Supercell please listen to your own freaking comunity already
I totally agree
/Signed
I have not being in war, at th9 the hero upgrade grind is a pain.
/signed
agreed, and said so beautifully.Quote:
Originally Posted by shoktherapy
/signed