[PETITION] Make Heroes Usable in Clan Wars... While Upgrading.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ColonelAwesome

no:straightface:

---

Ok still, it can be implemented, just like you can request cc troops while the cc is upgrading

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Seuss145

Ok still, it can be implemented, just like you can request cc troops while the cc is upgrading

---

you don't request somebody to lend a hero do you? not at all the same

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ColonelAwesome

you don't request somebody to lend a hero do you? not at all the same

---

What? The clan castle's main purpose is to request reinforcement troops, it carries out that process even while upgrading, that's my point. Heroes purpose is to be used in attacks. It doesn't carry out that purpose when being upgraded. It's not a big issues except when in wars where heroes are important. Your rebuttal doesn't address my point.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ILike2Clash

you cant use a barracks when it is upgrading. You cant use your spell factory when it is upgrading. This isnt much different. Defenses are always available for wars. Offenses, not so much

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ILike2Clash

Also, the main reason this wouldn't make sense:
On your war base, everything functions properly all the time. You don't attack with the troops on your war base, only your real base. If you are upgrading your hero, and attacked in a war, it wouldn't make sense for you to suddenly have a hero in your inventory: Your hero is asleep on its altar. It wouldn't make sense to have spells for war if your spells are upgrading: You would have to make the individual spells first, but your spell factory is undergoing re-construction. And then after making the spells for war, you could just go and use them for a regular attack. The only reason your defenses and heroes are available for defense in war is because your war base is in a different place, so they are (Technically) Different cannons/whatever other defense and different heroes. You don't make spells with the spell factory at your war base, and you don't use the hero at your war base to attack. Your war base is like some outpost far away, and has absolutely nothing to do with attacking. You don't use your war castle to attack, only to defend.

---

Ilike2clash is smart. He understands all the reasons why this idea makes no sense. I have read this post twice, and any argument you make as to why this idea should be implemented, this quote has a counter to that argument. Go ahead and argue away. The quote above explains in full detail why your argument is invalid.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ColonelAwesome

Ilike2clash is smart. He understands all the reasons why this idea makes no sense. I have read this post twice, and any argument you make as to why this idea should be implemented, this quote has a counter to that argument. Go ahead and argue away. The quote above explains in full detail why your argument is invalid.

---

i think you must secretly want this.. because idk why you are commenting on it so much keeping it on the top of the list. anyway.. i think it would be a cool addition

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ColonelAwesome

Ilike2clash is smart. He understands all the reasons why this idea makes no sense. I have read this post twice, and any argument you make as to why this idea should be implemented, this quote has a counter to that argument. Go ahead and argue away. The quote above explains in full detail why your argument is invalid.

---

This mainly says why defences work and not offences for wars, not why this shouldn't be implemented.

The only way to make the use of heros viable whilst upgrading is to have them researched in lab rather than upgrading them......but then it would slow down other troop upgrades..

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ColonelAwesome

Ilike2clash is smart. He understands all the reasons why this idea makes no sense. I have read this post twice, and any argument you make as to why this idea should be implemented, this quote has a counter to that argument. Go ahead and argue away. The quote above explains in full detail why your argument is invalid.

---

Also to counter the quotes you provided, how come the shield doesnt break when using a war attack? It's because it's war, the algorithm is different from normal raiding and a hero popping up in your inventory for war would work out just like the shield doesnt break.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ROM4N

The only way to make the use of heros viable whilst upgrading is to have them researched in lab rather than upgrading them......but then it would slow down other troop upgrades..

---

Not really, SC can use the same algorithm they use for the shield system, if a shield doesnt break when using a war attack, then heroes can be used in wars while upgrading

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LordOfMayhem

i think you must secretly want this.. because idk why you are commenting on it so much keeping it on the top of the list. anyway.. i think it would be a cool addition

---

It will be at the top of the list anyways, too many people that think this idea makes sense will keep replying. Might as well fight them