Which base is better?

This base would be my war base.
Which base could handle most types of attacks like: Hogs, Giant/Healer, and Dragons?

Version 1
http://i.imgur.com/10u4vd3.png

OR

Version 2
http://i.imgur.com/vWD6p8r.png

Just my concern, shouldn't the wizard towers be covering the defenses?

Please explain why

have you consider center cc? they are pretty much identical. what does your defense log say between the 2?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by nubcakeboxer

have you consider center cc? they are pretty much identical. what does your defense log say between the 2?

---

agreed -- as a TH8, isn't your goal in clan wars to NOT get three starred? a centralized CC would help prevent lures and be more effective in preventing three star attacks than a centralized TH.

now, if you're having lots of success in clan wars and rarely get two starred, let alone three starred, I'd go ahead and keep your TH in the middle.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by nubcakeboxer

have you consider center cc? they are pretty much identical. what does your defense log say between the 2?

---

These are not my bases, I found them on forums. Also, my clan doesnt donate troops, as we do wars to test out strategies and your base strength without clan castle troops.

They are exactly the same.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MrSmart

They are exactly the same.

---

nope.. just a minor difference- traps and a few walls

also, please explain what you would change

If I have to choose one of those then the first one. However, I would recommend centralizing your wizard towers more and making your clan castle harder to lure.

I don't like having collectors inside walls so I vote for neither :D JK!

I think your wiz tower placement could be better positioned to wipe mass groups attacking your storage's rather than take the first shots, you'll lose some resources but take out more troops over the course of the battle.

Otherwise, either way they look similar. I move traps depending on what side I am attacked more on average. For some reason one side of my farm base is attacked way more often than others. So I put more traps there. In war I spread more evenly but double up big bombs for blasting a hog attack. I usually center my Townhall and place my CC nearby, though I have been considering centering my CC and off-centering my TH. Trial and Error is a great teacher, so have at it!

GL HF!