Challenge/Dueling system!

Ok so how this idea is going so far is:
-> If a clan member has not made adjustments in his base then is eligible for requesting/being requested for challenge
-> after challenge is done cannot be requested for X amount of hours
-> during clan wars this feature is Disabled
-> no loot would be gain for the attacker or lost as defender
-> Watch Live would hopefully be introduced (somehow in clan chat box)
-> will not effect Matchmaking stats
See any other reasons why this can be denied? I'm starting to gain hope here! :eek:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Heston

Ok so how this idea is going so far is:
-> If a clan member has not made adjustments in his base then is eligible for requesting/being requested for challenge
-> after challenge is done cannot be requested for X amount of Minutes
-> during clan wars this feature is Disabled
-> no loot would be gain for the attacker or lost as defender
-> Watch Live would hopefully be introduced (somehow in clan chat box)
-> will not effect Matchmaking stats OR Achievements
See any other reasons why this can be denied? I'm starting to gain hope here! :eek:

---

One of the more popular reasons i would see in implementing this is new base designs, so thats why i said 24 hour period as it would still enable for a timely base review as well as nulling out the prep day recon, thus two birds with one stone. Watching live would also add for more reviews and critiques as well as insight into attack strategys, but thats what replays are for anyways :rolleyes:

So what are the chances of this pushing through? and also how do I delete my other post because I was backing into a redirect URL and it double posted haha.

Under ideas ruled out there are hundreds of ideas to scroll through that have all been suggested before and they might do them in the future and they might not. This idea is actually the first one on the list. I would like it too but yeah its ruled out so it wont be long for this to be deleted.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Is0prene

Under ideas ruled out there are hundreds of ideas to scroll through that have all been suggested before and they might do them in the future and they might not. This idea is actually the first one on the list. I would like it too but yeah its ruled out so it wont be long for this to be deleted.

---

It's in the Commonly suggested? section of the ruled out thread... the ruled out ideas are at the bottom

From the sticky
Below are ideas submitted by users for Supercell to consider. It does not imply they are being worked on. Please do a forum search before starting new feature requests, especially if they are listed below.

Zombiebender's guide to searching the forums: http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...d=1#post431518

Ideas are ranked in each section by recent forum polls. Items under - - - line are newer and have not been voted on/ranked against the others.

Major Additions:
* Dueling/challenge/simulator/sparring battle area

Edit: fair point Axion!

This does not land in the categories Currently Ruled Out in the sticky thread but it is under Major Additions:
and that section has an explanation by the moderator twister which goes by:

READ BEFORE POSTING - Ideas, ruled out, subforum guidelines:

Below are ideas submitted by users for Supercell to consider. It does not imply they are being worked on. Please do a forum search before starting new feature requests, especially if they are listed below.

Zombiebender's guide to searching the forums: http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...d=1#post431518

Ideas are ranked in each section by recent forum polls. Items under - - - line are newer and have not been voted on/ranked against the others.

Major Additions:
* Dueling/challenge/simulator/sparring battle area
* Clan villages = all clan members contribute, leaders control
* Add more single player levels (permanent ones)
- - - - - - - - - -
* Add a featured temporary single player map - 1 per week/month/update on a rotating basis.
* Add single player challenges/maps - beat with specific/limited troops or troop counts, all air, tier 1, etc
* Add daily challenges for small rewards - win a raid, use 5 balloons, destroy 5x builders huts, misc stuff
* Random event - meteorite lands in village - Dark Elixir to clear, enhanced experience/gem rewards

so this topic is in the section that I am hoping to SuperCell to consider (Please!)

Heres the sticky Thread >> http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...rum-guidelines

Beat ya to it ;)

blarghgaghagd I bet my finger was descending on my left mouse button when that was posted!:p

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Denrochee

It's in the under consideration section of the ruled out thread... the ruled out ideas are at the bottom

From the sticky
Below are ideas submitted by users for Supercell to consider. It does not imply they are being worked on. Please do a forum search before starting new feature requests, especially if they are listed below.

Zombiebender's guide to searching the forums: http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...d=1#post431518

Ideas are ranked in each section by recent forum polls. Items under - - - line are newer and have not been voted on/ranked against the others.

Major Additions:
* Dueling/challenge/simulator/sparring battle area

---

There's a difference in the language of "To Consider" vs "Under Consideration", which is distinguished by the sentence just after the on you highlighted...

One signifies a future potential action while the other implies current action.

This list of features are just ideas that people have posted often enough that Twister added to his list. It's purpose is to tell the Forumer "Hey, I know you're super excited about your revolutionary NEW idea, but it's been suggested before already"