If I post about a ruled out idea it is deleted. I would like to argue for one but do not want my post deleted. How can we make an argument for a solid will help the clan idea?
Printable View
If I post about a ruled out idea it is deleted. I would like to argue for one but do not want my post deleted. How can we make an argument for a solid will help the clan idea?
The definition of a ruled out idea is basically an idea that SC has determined that it will not implement it in the game whatsoever. Therefore, SC will delete your posts as they have already explained that it is ruled out and that they won't implement it
I would say that you should start by looking into why whatever this was got ruled out. There may be an aspect to it that will cause trouble or get it abused despite maybe being a wonderful idea for clans if it only goy used correctly.Quote:
Originally Posted by kx909
Not sure if that is what you have, just saying that for a lot of ideas their downfall was not that they were bad (many were awesome) but that someone other than a good decent player like the author would twist them into an opportunity to abuse.
Basically I think SC ruled out a good idea that I do not see harming or cutting into the bottom line for SC. I feel that I may be able to make a better argument on a suggestion and it could help the game for the user. If you create a forum for suggestions and you take some out of consideration it is effectively not asking for advice. I would be happy with an explanation as to why they are saying no. We would loose money is a great explanation.
My main problem is that I do not know the reason and feel that there is no upside to ruling this out. I am not a programer nor do I require tech talk but I think one of the ruled out ideas should be adopted.
Sorry for my writing. I am on my phone
Check out Sticky 2.0 for reasons why each ruled out idea has been ruled out:
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...029-Sticky-2-0
While it is useful to provide some reasons, it should be noted that not all of them have a strong explanation. It would be nice to discuss some of the less problematic ideas but the deletion makes it hard. Now that I think about it, I could just go to that post and talk thereQuote:
Originally Posted by JohnnyPC
Edit: Nevermind, I just remembered that I didn't post before when I first saw it because it didn't look like a thread that wants discussion in a sense
Suggestions do not equal advice. If an idea is ruled out, it is ruled out. It doesn't matter why.Quote:
Originally Posted by kx909
Don't whine or complain about it. Just accept it and move on.
Thanks for the replying. I was not aware of that thread. I do not think SC owes me anything to include an explination but cool beans. These guys rock and I wish them well.