Clan Wars Leave Agreement

I've had quite the number of cases of players abandoning the clan during clan wars preparation day.

So, I propose an idea that once a war has started it's first phase and you want to leave during that period, a notification will be sent to the leader and co-leader(s) mentioning that a particular player wishes to drop out of the clan. A valid reason must be submitted to the leader or co-leader as to why you want to leave. The leader or co-leader will have to decide to let the player go or decline the request. Or it can be a poll whereby your clan members will decide whether you stay or leave, depending on the majority.

What do you guys think?

The problem is that even if you can force someone to stay, you won't be able to force him to participate in the war.

Perhaps better solution can be - to allow recruit a replacement to the war (despite it was already started). They can limit it maybe to 1-2 replacement during each war.

I don't think that it would work, if players were not allowed to leave they would just fail the attacks on purpose.

No. Leaders shouldn't be able to force people to stay in a clan.

Edit: Wow. Double-ninja'd

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by FTYeaN

I've had quite the number of cases of players abandoning the clan during clan wars preparation day.

So, I propose an idea that once a war has started it's first phase and you want to leave during that period, a notification will be sent to the leader and co-leader(s) mentioning that a particular player wishes to drop out of the clan. A valid reason must be submitted to the leader or co-leader as to why you want to leave. The leader or co-leader will have to decide to let the player go or decline the request. Or it can be a poll whereby your clan members will decide whether you stay or leave, depending on the majority.

What do you guys think?

---

Seems pointless....if you're leaving a clan after prep day started it's either because you need to go to another clan for a short amount of time or because you're leaving the clan for good....

If you're leaving for good, you probably won't attack anyway (unless you snipe a th or something), and if you have to leave for a short amount of time that'd hold you back, perhaps to the point of missing the actual war, especially if you're in a different timezone.

Yeah, I do agree that a leader is forcing someone to stay during the war = same results = no stars

Good thing my clan is understanding and will listen to reason, but the same can't be said for a lot of others, which is why this system can be abused to keep clan members in. Still, keeping someone in your clan because you can is pretty much pointless since they won't play any more = inactive. Might as well kick them.

Anyway, thanks for your responses guys! Appreciate it!